Metro

  • Written by Naomi Schalit, Senior Editor, Politics + Society, The Conversation US

Democracy in America could hit a rough patch soon, as election officials tally votes in the presidential race. More than 350 lawsuits have already been filed this year across the country[1] over how, where and when voters could cast ballots. One presidential candidate – Donald Trump – has refused to commit to accepting the election’s results[2].

All that sets up the country for a disputed presidential election, with recounts and court battles in key states and a nation left wondering both who will lead it and whether they should have faith in the election’s integrity. We asked five scholars to provide a history of contested elections in the United States and to explain what happens when an election is disputed. Here are those stories, from our archives.

1. Things should be OK

“If Trump refuses to accept defeat in November, the republic will survive intact, as it has 5 out of 6 times in the past[3].” That’s the headline on political scientist Alexander Cohen’s[4] story.

Cohen lays out what elections normally do: They “generate legitimacy because citizens contribute to the selection of leadership.” And even in contested elections of the past, he continues, that legitimacy has been sustained because those disputes have been handled according to the rules. Politicians and citizens may have “howled” about the unfairness of the outcome, but, Cohen reports, they accepted it.

A contested election: 5 essential reads Santa Clara County Registrar of Voters’ Shannon Bushey shows an official county ballot collection box on Oct. 13, 2020 in San Jose, California. Justin Sullivan/Getty Images[5]

2. How to get to the Supreme Court

State law controls almost every aspect of voting, so if there’s an election dispute, then it will go to a state court[6], writes constitutional scholar John Finn[7]. “A candidate who wants to challenge the result in any particular state must first identify what provision of state law the election did not satisfy.” Most of the time, a state court decision will determine which presidential candidate gets the state’s electoral votes, with a final decision made by the state’s supreme court.

But then there is Bush v. Gore[8], the case that settled the 2000 election, which demonstrated that an election dispute can end up being heard by the Supreme Court if someone charges that a federal constitutional right has been violated. It’s possible, Finn writes, that several challenges similar to Bush v. Gore could arise in the 2020 election. “And where the lawsuits involved in Bush v. Gore all originated in Florida,” he writes, “this time the chaos may reach across several states.”

3. Throw the vote to Congress

There is another way that an election can end up being decided by others than the voters and the Electoral College. Not when it’s a disputed election, but when the Electoral College members are tied or don’t give any candidate a straight majority. That throws the election to the House of Representatives[9].

Political scientist Donald Brand[10] writes that this method of determining a winner was not exactly the first choice of the framers, who “sought to avoid congressional involvement in presidential elections.” But if the Electoral College couldn’t provide a majority vote for one candidate, the election would wind up in the House, “presumably because as the institution closest to the people, it could bestow some democratic legitimacy on a contingent election.”

A contested election: 5 essential reads Could the presidential election be decided by the Supreme Court? Astrid Riecken For The Washington Post via Getty Images[11]

4. Stolen elections leave bitterness

The republic may survive, but some disputed elections have “divided the nation, in ways that were hard to heal, or perhaps never healed[12].”

Political scientist Sarah Burns[13] says that the election of 1824, which was resolved with what was then called a “corrupt bargain,” and the disputed 2000 election, which was effectively ended by the Supreme Court, both caused such anger that they poisoned national politics for some time. Critics of the court’s decisive role in 2000 pointed out that “Bush had failed to win the popular vote, and that the Supreme Court vote was split 5-4, with the conservative justices in the majority delivering an outcome favorable to their political leanings.”

5. Judicial credibility

Judges like to stay in their branch of government – the judiciary – and leave the politics to politicians. Supreme Court Justice Felix Frankfurter warned his fellow jurists to avoid “embroilment” in “the political thicket” of “party contests and party interests.” But a disputed election will be fought in the courts, and that’s dangerous for the standing of any court, especially the U.S. Supreme Court. Voters will see judges’ actions and ascribe political intent to them, even if that’s not the case.

Austin Sarat[14], a legal scholar and political scientist, rakes into a pile the hundreds of lawsuits[15] that have already been mounted over how the election is conducted this year, describing what they aim to do. He believes that the election’s outcome is likely to end up in court – and he says there’s danger ahead, for the lower courts as well as the Supreme Court.

“Whatever decisions judges make this year, the rush to the courthouse to shape the 2020 election will pose real challenges for their legitimacy, which ultimately depends[16] on the public’s belief that they are not simply political actors.”

Editor’s note: This story is a roundup of articles from The Conversation’s archives.

References

  1. ^ More than 350 lawsuits have already been filed this year across the country (www.nytimes.com)
  2. ^ Donald Trump – has refused to commit to accepting the election’s results (www.cnn.com)
  3. ^ the republic will survive intact, as it has 5 out of 6 times in the past (theconversation.com)
  4. ^ political scientist Alexander Cohen’s (scholar.google.com)
  5. ^ Justin Sullivan/Getty Images (www.gettyimages.com)
  6. ^ then it will go to a state court (theconversation.com)
  7. ^ writes constitutional scholar John Finn (jfinn.faculty.wesleyan.edu)
  8. ^ Bush v. Gore (www.oyez.org)
  9. ^ That throws the election to the House of Representatives (theconversation.com)
  10. ^ Donald Brand (www.holycross.edu)
  11. ^ Astrid Riecken For The Washington Post via Getty Images (www.gettyimages.com)
  12. ^ divided the nation, in ways that were hard to heal, or perhaps never healed (theconversation.com)
  13. ^ Political scientist Sarah Burns (sarahmburns.com)
  14. ^ Austin Sarat (www.amherst.edu)
  15. ^ rakes into a pile the hundreds of lawsuits (theconversation.com)
  16. ^ depends (www.jstor.org)

Authors: Naomi Schalit, Senior Editor, Politics + Society, The Conversation US

Read more https://theconversation.com/a-contested-election-5-essential-reads-148311

Metropolitan republishes selected articles from The Conversation USA with permission

Visit The Conversation to see more

Entertainment News

SHERYL LEE RALPH PRESENTS THE 30TH ANNUAL DIVAS: SIMPLY SINGING UPDATE

DIVAS Simply Singing!, the longest consecutive running musical AIDS benefit in the United States, hits a major milestone in 2020, hosting its 30th annual fundraiser for The D.I.V.A. Foundation as a virtual event and on Saturday, December 5th on K...

News Co - avatar News Co

MICHAEL MESEY and AMERICAN GREED Release “Together”

“Together” As the go-to special show and traveling drummer for Chuck Berry for many years, Michael Mesey had a blast creating explosive moments on stage with the legendary musical pioneer all over the country. Yet one of his most cherished me...

News Co - avatar News Co

Actress Paris Hepburn Fights Through Covid Crisis

The entertainment industry has been hard hit in 2019 as we all know.  Since Covid-19 started entering the US in January 2019, one by one, movie studios, talent agencies, actors, crews and everything else associated with the entertainment industry...

News Co - avatar News Co

Why You Should Explore Your Creativity

You might think that you weren’t fortunate enough to be gifted at birth with creativity. You might say, “Oh, my brother got the creative genes, and I didn’t,” or “Why would I want to be creative”? Someone once asked me that last question, to whi...

Angela Predhomme - avatar Angela Predhomme

What does being the Happiness Warrior mean to me?

I’ve always felt I’ve had an innate need to set things right. If I see someone or something struggling, my nature is to help. I want them to feel good about themselves and their abilities but most importantly to find the best solution that make...

Eric North aka “The Happiness Warrior” - avatar Eric North aka “The Happiness Warrior”

THE WORLD OPERATES NOT ON REALITY, BUT ON PERCEPTION OF REALITY

Ben Kingsley's character Cosmo in the 1992 cult classic Sneakers prophetically quipped , The world doesn't operate on reality, but on perception of reality. Those words have come to roost in this year 2020 as we find ourselves living in a world ...

Brandyn Cross - avatar Brandyn Cross

Metropolitan Business News

5 Key Factors To Starting A Website

Every business needs a website to be successful. However, this is a challenge for many due to the lack of coding and designing skills. The good news is, you do have a way around this—hire a deve...

News Co - avatar News Co

So You Want To Be A Project Manager? Here's What You Must Do

Project management is often a popular choice for people looking to make a mark in the organizations they work for. It's a great choice as well. If you hate monotony, love getting people and res...

News Co - avatar News Co

How to Deliver the Perfect Elevator Pitch

Do you struggle with explaining your career with professional or personal contacts, and you want to make a lasting impression? Whether you're looking for a job or building up your network, a wel...

Adam Jacobs - avatar Adam Jacobs

Three Asian Countries That are Leaders in Outsourcing

Would it surprise you to know that three of the top five ranked countries for ease of doing business are in Asia? Would it surprise you more to know that India and China aren’t even in the top 3...

Adam Jacobs - avatar Adam Jacobs

FCB and oOh! help Kiwis vote with dynamic campaign for Electoral Commission

oOh!media and FCB NZ are helping Kiwi voters exercise their democratic rights this general election, via a localised dynamic Out of Home campaign for the New Zealand Electoral Commission. The c...

Lighthouse Communications. - avatar Lighthouse Communications.

MODEL/ACTOR THORN CASTILLO IS THE “NEW FACE” OF SCHICK STYLIST

In 2019, just as his multi-faceted career was taking off, Thorn Castillo heard Robert Downey Jr. offer a sage bit of advice during an interview on photographer/director Sam Jones’ acclaimed multi-...

News Company - avatar News Company

Writers Wanted


News Co Media Group

Content & Technology Connecting Global Audiences

More Information - Less Opinion