Nocturnal dinosaurs: Night vision and superb hearing in a small theropod suggest it was a moonlight predator
- Written by Lars Schmitz, Associate Professor of Biology, Scripps College
Today, barn owls, bats, leopards and many other animals rely on their keen senses to live and hunt under the dim light of stars. These nighttime specialists avoid the competition of daylight hours[1], hunting their prey under the cloak of darkness, often using a combination of night vision and acute hearing.
But was there nightlife 100 million years ago? In a world without owls or leopards, were dinosaurs working the night shift? If so, what senses did they use to find food and avoid predators in the darkness? To better understand the senses of the dinosaur ancestors of birds, our team[2] of paleontologists[3] and paleobiologists[4] scoured research papers and museum collections looking for fossils that preserved delicate eye and ear structures. And we found some.
Using scans of fossilized dinosaur skulls, in a paper published in the journal Science on May 6, 2021[5], we describe the most convincing evidence to date for nocturnal dinosaurs. Two fossil species – Haplocheirus sollers and Shuvuuia deserti – likely had extremely good night vision. But our work also shows that S. deserti also had incredibly sensitive hearing similar to modern-day owls. This is the first time these two traits have been found in the same fossil, suggesting that this small, desert-dwelling dinosaur that lived in ancient Mongolia was probably a specialized night-hunter of insects and small mammals.
Shuvuuia deserti had acute hearing and low-light vision that would have allowed it to hunt at night.
Viktor Radermaker, CC BY-ND[6]
Looking to theropods
By studying fossilized eye bones, one of us, Lars Schmitz, had previously found that some small predatory dinosaurs may have hunted at night[7]. Most of these potentially nocturnal hunters were theropods, the group of three-toed dinosaurs that includes Tyrannosaurus rex and modern birds. But to date, fossils for only 12 theropod species included the eye structures[8] that can tell paleontologists about night vision.
Our team identified four more species of theropods with clues for their sense of vision – for a total of 16. We then looked for fossils that preserve the structures of the inner ear and found 17 species. Excitingly, for four species, we were able to get measurements for both eyes and ears.
The eye socket – and specifically the sclerical ring – of S. deserti shows an eye with a very large pupil capable of letting in large amounts of light.
Mick Ellison/American Museum of Natural History, CC BY-ND[9]
Eye bones built for night vision
Scleral ossicles are thin, rectangular bone plates that form a ring-like structure surrounding the pupils[10] of lizards as well as birds and their ancestors – dinosaurs. Scleral rings define the largest possible size of an animal’s pupil and can tell you how well that animal can see at night[11]. The larger the pupil compared to the size of the eye, the better a dinosaur could see in the dark.
This owl skull clearly shows the large scleral ring that helps animals see in darkness.
David J. Stang/WikimediaCommons, CC BY-SA[12][13]
Since the individual bony ossicles of these rings fell apart after these animals died more than 60 million years ago, our team made scans of the fossils and then digitally reconstructed the eyes. Of all the theropods we examined, H. sollers and S. deserti had some of the proportionally largest pupils.
S. deserti‘s pupil made up more than half of its eye, very similar to night-vision specialists that live today like geckos and nightjars. Our team then compared the fossils to 55 living species of lizards and 367 species of birds with known day or night activity patterns. According to the statistical analyses our team performed, there is a very high chance – higher than 90% – that H. sollers and S. deserti were nocturnal.
But those were not the only two theropods our team looked at. Our analysis also found a few other likely nighttime specialists – such as Megapnosaurus kayentakatae – as well as daylight specialists like Almas ukhaa. But we also found some species – like Velociraptor mongoliensis – with eyesight seemingly adapted for medium light levels. This might suggest that they hunted around dawn or dusk.
Molds of the inner ear canal from a barn owl (left) and S. deserti (right) are almost identical, suggesting that the small dinosaur had incredible hearing.
Jonah Choiniere/Wits University, CC BY-ND[14]
Incredible ears of a dinosaur
In today’s nocturnal animals, hearing can be as important as keen eyesight[15]. To figure out how well these extinct dinosaurs could hear, we scanned the skulls of 17 fossil theropods to decipher the structure of their inner ears and then compared our scans to the ears of modern animals.
All vertebrates have a tube-like canal called the cochlea deep in their inner ear. Studies of living mammals and birds show that the longer this canal, the wider the range of frequencies an animal can hear[16] and the better they can hear very faint sounds[17].
Our scans showed that S. deserti had an extremely elongated inner ear canal for its size – also similar to that of the living barn owl and proportionally much longer than all of the other 88 living bird species we analyzed for comparison. Based on our measurements, among dinosaurs, we found that predators had generally better hearing than herbivores. Several predators – including V. mongoliensis – also had moderately elongated inner ears, but none rivaled S. deserti’s.
The life of a nocturnal dinosaur
By studying the sensory abilities of dinosaurs, paleontologists like us not only are learning what species roamed the night, but can also begin to infer how these dinosaurs lived and shared resources.
S. deserti had extreme night vision and sensitive hearing[18], and this little dinosaur probably used its incredible senses to hunt prey at night. It could likely hear and follow rustling from a distance before visually detecting its prey and digging it up from the ground with its short single-clawed arms. In the dry, desert-like habitats of millions of years ago, it might have been an evolutionary advantage to be active in the cooler temperatures of the night.
But according to our analysis, S. deserti wasn’t the only dinosaur active at night. Other dinosaurs like V. mongoliensis and the plant-eating Protoceratops mongoliensis both lived in the same habitat and had some level of night vision.
Paleontologists currently do not know the full suite of animals that shared S. deserti’s extreme nocturnal lifestyle in the ancient deserts of Mongolia – it is rare to find fossils with the right bones intact that allow paleontologists to investigate their senses. However, the presence of a specialized night forager highlights that much like today, some dinosaurs avoided the dangers and competition of daylight hours and roamed under the stars.
[Get the best of The Conversation, every weekend. Sign up for our weekly newsletter[19].]
References
- ^ nighttime specialists avoid the competition of daylight hours (doi.org)
- ^ our team (scholar.google.com)
- ^ paleontologists (scholar.google.com)
- ^ paleobiologists (scholar.google.com)
- ^ published in the journal Science on May 6, 2021 (science.sciencemag.org)
- ^ CC BY-ND (creativecommons.org)
- ^ may have hunted at night (doi.org)
- ^ 12 theropod species included the eye structures (doi.org)
- ^ CC BY-ND (creativecommons.org)
- ^ ring-like structure surrounding the pupils (doi.org)
- ^ can see at night (doi.org)
- ^ David J. Stang/WikimediaCommons (commons.wikimedia.org)
- ^ CC BY-SA (creativecommons.org)
- ^ CC BY-ND (creativecommons.org)
- ^ hearing can be as important as keen eyesight (doi.org)
- ^ wider the range of frequencies an animal can hear (doi.org)
- ^ very faint sounds (doi.org)
- ^ S. deserti had extreme night vision and sensitive hearing (doi.org)
- ^ Sign up for our weekly newsletter (theconversation.com)
Authors: Lars Schmitz, Associate Professor of Biology, Scripps College
