Metro

  • Written by Roger J. Kreuz, Associate Dean and Professor of Psychology, University of Memphis

As the trial of alleged accomplices to the attack on Charlie Hebdo recently got underway in Paris, the magazine republished caricatures of the Prophet Muhammed[1].

It was a defiant act. The same images were cited as the grievance that led two killers to shoot dead 12 people[2] at the magazine’s offices in a terror attack in 2015.

Previously, the paper’s offices had been firebombed[3] when a caricature of the Prophet Muhammed was run on the cover of a November 2011 issue. Charlie Hebdo runs cartoons satirizing other religions[4], including Christianity[5].

Depictions of the founder of Islam are forbidden[6] in the Sunni branch of the faith. As a result, what was intended as satire was perceived as blasphemous by observant Muslims and as an unforgivable offense by extremists.

The attack on Charlie Hebdo was an extreme example of a long history of attacks on satire and those who create it. But satire can take many forms, as can its reprisals.

Satire as criticism

Indeed, condemnation of satirists has more commonly taken the form of censorship, public humiliation and imprisonment.

Aristophanes, who wrote satiric plays 2,400 years ago, was condemned during his lifetime[7] for his depictions of citizens of Athens. Plato criticized the playwright for slandering Socrates[8] as vain and arrogant in his play “The Clouds.”

In 1599, the bishops of Canterbury and London banned the publication[9] of a variety of works, including those seen as satirical. Attacks on the privileged and powerful were seen as violating cultural norms and corrosive to social order[10].

And years before writing his best-known work, “Robinson Crusoe,” Daniel Defoe wrote satirical works that were critical of many prominent figures. Among his more popular work was “The True-Born Englishman[11],” which highlighted xenophobic prejudice in England against King William III[12], a Dutchman by birth.

In 1703, Defoe also criticized individuals who wanted to separate from the Church of England. In “The Shortest Way with the Dissenters[13]” he accused separatists of being responsible for the English Civil War, among other crimes. Since Defoe was himself a separatist, his critique is considered to be a satiric attack on the leaders of the Church.

Defoe’s call to “crucify the thieves,” that is, the dissenters, led to him being accused of seditious libel[14]. He was fined, endured public humiliation in a pillory and was then thrown in prison.

Authors of what is known as Juvenalian satire, criticism of contemporary persons or institutions, engage in a full-throated condemnation. In appearing to be advocating for the public good, they could also end up with outlandish suggestions. Perhaps the best-known example of this is Jonathan Swift’s 1729 essay, “A Modest Proposal[15],” in which he suggests that the Irish sell their babies as food for the rich. It was an attack on the attitudes of the wealthy and on British policies toward the Irish.

Needless to say, assaults like these can get under the skin of those being depicted as corrupt, cruel or dimwitted.

Mild or hidden satire

But there isn’t one form of satire. Satire can be fairly gentle as well. An example of so-called Horatian satire is Alexander Pope’s 1712 “The Rape of the Lock[16].” The poem describes a mundane incident – the cutting of a lock of hair without permission – in mock-heroic terms.

Pope’s poem is relatively good-natured. His goal was to poke fun at his own society and is therefore not particularly judgmental.

Then there is the use of caricature as a form of satire, which often gets away merely by exaggerating the physical characteristics of its intended targets. Barack Obama’s ears[17] and Richard Nixon’s nose[18], for example, were often depicted as comically large by cartoonists during their respective presidencies.

But then, a work intended to be satiric may cease, over time, to be recognized as such. As I describe in my book on irony and sarcasm,[19] an example may be the Historia Augusta, a fourth-century collection of biographies of Roman emperors.

Scholars Justin Stover[20] and Mike Kestemont[21] have pointed out that the manuscript is unusual[22] in its “lurid focus on emperors’ peccadilloes and personal habits to the detriment of their political accomplishments.” There has been some discussion over the intent and purpose of such a text. Scholar Shawn Daniels[23], who has studied the text closely[24], concluded that the language of “quips and bad puns” suggest that the work was intended as satire.

Free speech and satire

In modern times, the liberty of free speech can often protect even harsh examples of satire.

In the U.S., for example, criticism of public figures is protected speech, so satire cannot be used[25] as a basis for libel or to seek damages for emotional distress. In countries such as Italy and Germany, satire is explicitly protected by the Constitution. And France has a long tradition[26] of satirists mocking religious and political institutions.

With regard to Charlie Hebdo’s caricatures of the prophet, there are those who question whether religious sentiments should not be taken into consideration. Many have described the caricatures, such as one depicting a bomb hidden in a turban, to be offensive to religious feelings[27] and in poor taste. There have been protests across several countries[28] condemning the republication.

Charlie Hebdo shootings served as an extreme example of the history of attacks on satirists Supporters of a religious group hold a rally to condemn the republication of caricatures in Lahore, Pakistan, on Sept. 10, 2020. AP Photo/K.M. Chaudary[29]

In an editorial[30] that accompanied the caricatures, the magazine has defended its actions. The editors stated that the drawings “belong to history, and history cannot be rewritten nor erased.”

[Deep knowledge, daily. Sign up for The Conversation’s newsletter[31].]

Support for freedom of expression was evident in the slogan[32] “Je Suis Charlie,” or “I am Charlie,” which was adopted by thousands soon after the attack in 2015.

Are there limits to such freedom of expression? The future of satire as a form of criticism may depend on a balance being struck between its practitioners and its targets.

References

  1. ^ caricatures of the Prophet Muhammed (www.nytimes.com)
  2. ^ shoot dead 12 people (www.nytimes.com)
  3. ^ firebombed (www.nytimes.com)
  4. ^ satirizing other religions (forward.com)
  5. ^ including Christianity (qz.com)
  6. ^ forbidden (theconversation.com)
  7. ^ condemned during his lifetime (www.ancient-literature.com)
  8. ^ slandering Socrates (blog.oup.com)
  9. ^ banned the publication (onlinelibrary.wiley.com)
  10. ^ corrosive to social order (www.cambridge.org)
  11. ^ The True-Born Englishman (www.poetryfoundation.org)
  12. ^ King William III (www.poetryfoundation.org)
  13. ^ The Shortest Way with the Dissenters (books.google.com)
  14. ^ accused of seditious libel (www.historytoday.com)
  15. ^ A Modest Proposal (www.gutenberg.org)
  16. ^ The Rape of the Lock (www.gutenberg.org)
  17. ^ Barack Obama’s ears (hughjnusscrapbookarnorfer7.weebly.com)
  18. ^ Richard Nixon’s nose (simplifythemessage.com)
  19. ^ irony and sarcasm, (mitpress.mit.edu)
  20. ^ Justin Stover (scholar.google.com)
  21. ^ Mike Kestemont (www.mike-kestemont.org)
  22. ^ manuscript is unusual (onlinelibrary.wiley.com)
  23. ^ Shawn Daniels (people.wright.edu)
  24. ^ who has studied the text closely (ufdcimages.uflib.ufl.edu)
  25. ^ cannot be used (www.loc.gov)
  26. ^ long tradition (www.aljazeera.com)
  27. ^ offensive to religious feelings (www.aljazeera.com)
  28. ^ protests across several countries (theprint.in)
  29. ^ AP Photo/K.M. Chaudary (www.apimages.com)
  30. ^ an editorial (m.startribune.com)
  31. ^ Sign up for The Conversation’s newsletter (theconversation.com)
  32. ^ evident in the slogan (www.bbc.com)

Authors: Roger J. Kreuz, Associate Dean and Professor of Psychology, University of Memphis

Read more https://theconversation.com/charlie-hebdo-shootings-served-as-an-extreme-example-of-the-history-of-attacks-on-satirists-145527

Metropolitan republishes selected articles from The Conversation USA with permission

Visit The Conversation to see more

Entertainment News

Musik Radio Promotions - Opening the World For Indie Artists Music

Industry without inspiration never leaves a lasting impact. Hard work and discipline often produce a reliable product but, without the spark of love behind its creation, posterity will take a dim view of its ultimate worth. Ten years ago, worldwi...

News Company - avatar News Company

The Musical Journey of Lamont Dozier, Jr.

I was quite young when music entered my life. Music always had a role in my household, being that my mother, Elizabeth Ann Dozier, was a musician and the choir director for the church that I and my sisters grew up in. My mother also taught clas...

Lamont Dozier, Jr. - avatar Lamont Dozier, Jr.

Actor Thorn Castillo is the “New Face of Schick”

Last year, just after my acting and modeling career had started taking off, I heard some interesting advice from Robert Downey Jr. during an interview on Sam Jones’ series “Off Camera.” Talking about his own early experiences, he said something l...

Thorn Castillo - avatar Thorn Castillo

SHERYL LEE RALPH 2020 Creative and Political Projects

COVID-19 has wreaked havoc on our day to day lives – but Tony nominated and Spirit Award winning actress/activist Sheryl Lee Ralph is booked and busy with her ongoing slate of dynamic TV, literary, political and entrepreneurial projects, revealin...

News Company - avatar News Company

GREYE RELEASES MUSIC VIDEO TO SUPPORT ACCLAIMED NEW SINGLE

Greye’s explosive new single “So Far So Good” is the perfect intro to the band’s new, harder-edged direction, an amped up way to experience all the dynamic elements Greye is known for.This explosive new single “So Far So Good” is the perfect intr...

News Company - avatar News Company

GLORIA LORING RETURNS WITH “THE BEST OF ME” SEPTEMBER 18th

GLORIA LORING The Best of Me   There is something beautiful about artists whose insight into the human condition allows them to create works that, even beyond their original intention, emotionally and intuitively meet the moment and help us ...

News Company - avatar News Company

Metropolitan Business News

MODEL/ACTOR THORN CASTILLO IS THE “NEW FACE” OF SCHICK STYLIST

In 2019, just as his multi-faceted career was taking off, Thorn Castillo heard Robert Downey Jr. offer a sage bit of advice during an interview on photographer/director Sam Jones’ acclaimed multi-...

News Company - avatar News Company

New Research Highlights Opportunities for Sports Betting

Revenue Stream for Sports’ Post-COVID-19 Recovery Strategies New Rochelle, NY, June 1, 2020— Twenty-four states have now legalized sports betting, with more states considering legalization la...

Len Stein - avatar Len Stein

How to make overseas transfers easier?

Mainstream banks can charge as much as $20 just to process a basic international money transfer. Fortunately, today people are not doomed to handling personal finances only through mainstream gl...

News Company - avatar News Company

The flourishing international market of fragrance and perfume

There is something special and unique about the art of fragrance. This is a big world and there are quite literally a lot of smells around at any given time. In fact, as one of the five human senses i...

News Company - avatar News Company

Impact of good marketing on sales

Sales and marketing are brothers as they go hand and in hand. The job of both of these departments is to generate revenue so that an organization can make money. A company that does not generate rev...

News Company - avatar News Company

7 effective tips for increasing sales in retail

It seems that retailers have drawn a difficult lot in the 21st century: competition from online retail is growing steadily. After all, Internet retailers can sell your products at significantly lowe...

News Company - avatar News Company

Writers Wanted


News Company Media Core

Content & Technology Connecting Global Audiences

More Information - Less Opinion