Don't buy that Gucci knockoff: Your bargain benefits organized crime while endangering countless others
- Written by Jay Kennedy, Assistant Professor of Criminal Justice, Michigan State University
If you’ve ever been to New York’s Chinatown[1], Los Angeles’ Santee Alley[2] or Hong Kong’s Gage Street[3], you know what draws the crowds: the chance to snag knockoff Jimmy Chu shoes, a Rolex watch or a pair of Ray-Ban sunglasses for a fraction of the retail price[4].
While consumers may think it’s a “victimless crime[5]” that only hurts big corporations, counterfeiting harms countless individuals as well, from sweatshop workers who toil without legal protections to consumers themselves, many thousands of whom die annually[6] due to fraudulent drugs and foods. It’s also the biggest source of profit for criminal gangs.
President Donald Trump highlighted the problem[7] in early April when he ordered U.S. federal agencies to do more to stem the flow of counterfeit goods online. But what has been lost in debates about how to curb counterfeiting is the role consumers play[8].
I’ve spent the past five years studying[9] the serious problem of product counterfeiting as part of my ongoing research on crimes committed against businesses. Just as U.S. demand fuels illegal drug trafficking[10], it has become exceedingly clear to me that consumers play an integral part in the persistence and growth of product counterfeiting.
New York police sized over $1 million in counterfeit Gucci, Prada, Fendi, Rolex and Coach goods in a Chinatown raid in 2008.
AP Photo/Bebeto Matthews[11]
‘Wild West’ of retail
The growth of e-commerce, which the Trump administration compares with the lawless “Wild West,” is making it easier for counterfeiters[12] to reach U.S. consumers.
In the U.S., the number of counterfeit products seized[13] at ports of entry has more than doubled over the past decade.
Globally, counterfeiters sold an estimated US$1 trillion of fake goods[14] in 2017, a figure that is expected to soar past $1.8 trillion by 2020. As a result, businesses suffered an estimated $323 billion in losses in 2017.
E-commerce sites are rife with cheap knockoffs like this one.
eBay[15]
Profits earned from the sale of counterfeit goods benefit legitimate companies[16] who manufacture, sell or distribute counterfeits, as well as illegal businesses and criminal organizations.
Trump’s directive focused on getting online marketplaces like eBay, Amazon and Alibaba to do more to remove knockoffs from their virtual shelves or trying to stem the flow of goods over the border. While this makes some sense given estimates[17] that a large share of goods being sold on these sites are counterfeit, what it does not do is address the source of the problem: consumer demand.
Counterfeit accomplices
A common saying among brand owners, the companies that own legitimate trademarks, is that the only sure way for a company to avoid a counterfeiting problem is to produce a product that no one wants to buy.
If no one wanted[18] Coach, Chanel or Michael Kors handbags, for example, there would be no point in knockoffs.
The lesson to take away from this is that consumer demand for legitimate goods creates incentives for counterfeiters to create and sell fakes. And while the majority of shoppers have no desire to purchase counterfeit products[19] – and in fact are themselves victims of this deception – there are many who willingly buy counterfeit goods[20] in order to get what they perceive is a bargain.
Researchers have found[21] that there are two general price-focused reasons consumers choose to purchase counterfeit goods. They may feel that the cost of the desired legitimate good is too high, thus they settle for a knockoff that costs a fraction of the price. Or, even if they could afford the legitimate good, they choose the fake because it seems to be a savvy shopping decision.
Regardless of the reason, their decision makes them accomplices[22] to this illegal activity, providing counterfeiters with more financial resources. And more importantly, it can place them at risk for serious harm.
While it may seem normal and not harmful to rationalize the purchase of a counterfeit purse as a way to save money, my own research[23] has found that the same logic can lead people to buy tobacco laced with arsenic[24] and tainted medications that have led to serious illness[25] or even death[26].
Factories making counterfeit goods sometimes employ children and pay workers poorly.
Reuters/John Ruwitch[27]
Who gets hurt
While it may be difficult for consumers to care about the losses suffered by a multinational company like Gucci, Chanel or Rolex, they should be able to sympathize with the plight of other victims of counterfeiting.
For example, the people producing counterfeit goods include children forced to work in sweatshop[28] conditions for hours on end and underpaid people forced to work in dangerous conditions[29] under threat of punishment from factory owners.
Some counterfeiting schemes[30] have even been tied to human smuggling rings, international organized crime groups and drug gangs. The United Nations lists counterfeiting as one of the most lucrative criminal activities[31] for transnational organized gangs. In fact, counterfeiting is more profitable[32] for these groups than drug smuggling or human trafficking.
Put another way, counterfeiting is not an issue of who is losing money. It’s about who is getting the money: criminals. And the victims include pretty much everyone else, from the workers to unsuspecting consumers themselves.
References
- ^ New York’s Chinatown (www.nycgo.com)
- ^ Los Angeles’ Santee Alley (www.thesanteealley.com)
- ^ Hong Kong’s Gage Street (fathomaway.com)
- ^ fraction of the retail price (www.researchgate.net)
- ^ victimless crime (globalnews.ca)
- ^ many thousands of whom die annually (www.reuters.com)
- ^ highlighted the problem (www.apnews.com)
- ^ role consumers play (doi.org)
- ^ I’ve spent the past five years studying (scholar.google.com)
- ^ U.S. demand fuels illegal drug trafficking (www.journals.uchicago.edu)
- ^ AP Photo/Bebeto Matthews (www.apimages.com)
- ^ is making it easier for counterfeiters (www.adweek.com)
- ^ counterfeit products seized (www.cbp.gov)
- ^ US$1 trillion of fake goods (www.apnews.com)
- ^ eBay (www.ebay.co.uk)
- ^ benefit legitimate companies (archive.fortune.com)
- ^ given estimates (www.gao.gov)
- ^ no one wanted (strathprints.strath.ac.uk)
- ^ no desire to purchase counterfeit products (a-capp.msu.edu)
- ^ who willingly buy counterfeit goods (doi.org)
- ^ Researchers have found (dx.doi.org)
- ^ makes them accomplices (www.emeraldinsight.com)
- ^ my own research (doi.org)
- ^ buy tobacco laced with arsenic (www.independent.co.uk)
- ^ serious illness (www.nature.com)
- ^ even death (link.springer.com)
- ^ Reuters/John Ruwitch (pictures.reuters.com)
- ^ children forced to work in sweatshop (www.cnbc.com)
- ^ underpaid people forced to work in dangerous conditions (heinonline.org)
- ^ counterfeiting schemes (share.america.gov)
- ^ most lucrative criminal activities (www.unicri.it)
- ^ counterfeiting is more profitable (www.occrp.org)
Authors: Jay Kennedy, Assistant Professor of Criminal Justice, Michigan State University
