Metropolitan Digital

Google


.

  • Written by Lee Ann Rawlins Williams, Clinical Assistant Professor of Education, Health and Behavior Studies, University of North Dakota

I spoke in January 2026 with 150 high school students about career options. After explaining my own career[1] as a professor of education, health and behavior, I asked the students a simple question: Would you want to be a teacher?

“Why in the world would I want to be a teacher?” one female student said.

“My aunt is a teacher and she works all the time … no thanks,” a male student added.

Several students said it felt like teachers were doing everything: from teaching lessons and helping students through personal struggles to managing class disruptions and constantly adjusting to whatever else the day brought. Students also mentioned hearing teachers talk openly about low pay[2] or feeling a lack of respect[3] from students and others.

These students’ observations align with national trends[4]. While nearly 20% of college freshmen said in 1970 that they were interested in a teaching career[5], less than 5% said the same in 2020, according to the National Bureau of Economic Research.

Many teachers report low levels of job satisfaction, and 52% polled by Pew in 2024 said they would not advise[6] young adults to become teachers.

A woman sits in front of a group of young children in a classroom.
A teacher works with first grade students at Rosita Elementary School in Santa Ana, Calif., on Feb. 12, 2026. Paul Bersebach/MediaNews Group/Orange County Register via Getty Images[7]

Teacher pay penalty

Education researchers and labor analysts have documented[8] that teachers earn less than other people who also have college degrees.

This difference in pay is sometimes called the teacher pay penalty[9]. This gap has widened over the past few decades[10].

In 2024 the teacher pay penalty reached its highest recorded level[11], with teachers earning roughly 73 cents[12] for every dollar earned by other college graduates.

Average annual public teacher salaries[13] recently have ranged from about US$53,507 in Mississippi[14] and $53,098 in Florida[15] to more than $95,160 in California[16] and $95,615 in New York[17].

Nationwide, teachers on average earn about $72,030 per year[18].

National analyses show that teaching has steadily lost ground in wage competitiveness compared with other college-educated professionals[19] over the past few decades.

Even as some states have enacted modest teacher salary increases year over year[20], these wide disparities persist.

Expanding expectations, rising strain

Teaching once centered primarily on academic instruction. Particularly through much of the 20th century, teachers’ roles were largely defined by planning lessons, instructing on different subjects and assessing student learning.

In addition to teaching core subjects, many teachers are now often expected to help support students’ social and emotional development[21], address complex behavioral challenges[22], respond to crises[23] that spill into classrooms, such as students physically fighting, and manage substantial paperwork and administrative[24] tasks.

The COVID-19 pandemic intensified many of these responsibilities, as teachers navigated remote instruction and students’ heightened mental health needs[25].

At the same time, concerns about school safety, including the reality of school shootings[26] and other kinds of violence, have added another layer[27] to teachers’ emotional strain and required vigilance[28].

Teachers are far more likely than other college-educated professionals to report frequent[29] job-related stress and burnout[30].

Job available

Approximately 50% of all public school leaders reported[31] in October 2024 that they feel their school is understaffed. And 20% of public school leaders reported teacher vacancies during that same time period.

In January 2022, shortly after the pandemic, more than 20%[32] of public schools reported at least 5% of their teaching positions were vacant that month. Approximately 51% of schools reported that resignations[33] were the cause of these vacancies.

A 2025 national teacher shortage overview estimates that roughly 1 in 8 teaching positions nationwide are either unfilled or staffed by someone not fully certified for the assignment[34], meaning a teacher working outside their licensed subject area or grade level, for example.

When positions are filled this way, the classroom will still have a teacher present, but not necessarily one formally prepared to teach a specific subject or group of students. This can result in greater reliance on substitutes or increased class sizes for remaining[35] staff.

I asked students whether they’d want to be teachers? They quickly responded, ‘Why would I?’
Students and their teacher are seen in 1899 in a Washington, D.C., public school classroom. Heritage Art/Heritage Images via Getty Images[36]

When teaching became women’s work

History helps explain why teaching looks – and pays – the way it does today.

In the early 1800s, teaching was a predominantly male profession[37].

But as the U.S. industrialized in the late 1800s and early 1900s, higher-paying jobs in business and manufacturing[38] drew many men away from classrooms.

For many women at the time, teaching offered one of the few respectable professional careers available. It provided steady income and a measure of independence when many other professions were closed to them[39].

Labor force participation for women expanded significantly during the 1960s, ’70s, and ’80s, as legal and social barriers began to fall[40]. Yet the pay and public standing of teaching does not seem to have risen at the same pace[41].

By the early 1900s, women made up about 70% of teachers[42]. In 2024, 77% of teachers were women[43].

Nationwide, the gender wage gap has narrowed in the past few decades. Still, women in the U.S. earn an average 85%[44] of what men make.

Who will teach the next generation?

Each year, more than 80,000 new teachers[45] step into classrooms. But the overall pipeline has narrowed since the early 2010s, with enrollment at teacher preparation programs[46] declining sharply and only partially rebounding in recent years[47].

Today’s students are coming of age in a landscape where teaching competes with many other college-degree professions that may offer higher pay, more predictable hours or clearer career advancement.

College students are often weighing financial security, mental health and long-term sustainability as they imagine their future.

Research consistently shows that compensation, working conditions[48] and professional support play a central role[49] in job retention. When those elements erode, so too does workforce stability.

Stability is the key as students are evaluating teaching – not as a calling, but as a potential career within a competitive labor market.

References

  1. ^ my own career (campus.und.edu)
  2. ^ openly about low pay (www.epi.org)
  3. ^ lack of respect (www.edweek.org)
  4. ^ align with national trends (www.nber.org)
  5. ^ interested in a teaching career (www.nber.org)
  6. ^ 52% polled by Pew in 2024 said they would not advise (www.pewresearch.org)
  7. ^ Paul Bersebach/MediaNews Group/Orange County Register via Getty Images (www.gettyimages.com)
  8. ^ have documented (www.edweek.org)
  9. ^ teacher pay penalty (edsource.org)
  10. ^ gap has widened over the past few decades (www.nea.org)
  11. ^ highest recorded level (www.epi.org)
  12. ^ earning roughly 73 cents (cepr.net)
  13. ^ teacher salaries (www.nea.org)
  14. ^ US$53,507 in Mississippi (www.clarionledger.com)
  15. ^ $53,098 in Florida (iteach.net)
  16. ^ $95,160 in California (moreland.edu)
  17. ^ $95,615 in New York (www.nea.org)
  18. ^ $72,030 per year (www.nea.org)
  19. ^ college-educated professionals (www.epi.org)
  20. ^ modest teacher salary increases year over year (www.rand.org)
  21. ^ social and emotional development (doi.org)
  22. ^ behavioral challenges (www.rethinked.com)
  23. ^ respond to crises (mepli.gse.harvard.edu)
  24. ^ substantial paperwork and administrative (www.pewresearch.org)
  25. ^ mental health needs (www.rand.org)
  26. ^ school shootings (k12ssdb.org)
  27. ^ have added another layer (files.eric.ed.gov)
  28. ^ strain and required vigilance (doi.org)
  29. ^ report frequent (www.rand.org)
  30. ^ job-related stress and burnout (www.wooclap.com)
  31. ^ all public school leaders reported (nces.ed.gov)
  32. ^ more than 20% (nces.ed.gov)
  33. ^ reported that resignations (nces.ed.gov)
  34. ^ certified for the assignment (learningpolicyinstitute.org)
  35. ^ increased class sizes for remaining (teachers-blog.com)
  36. ^ Heritage Art/Heritage Images via Getty Images (www.gettyimages.com)
  37. ^ predominantly male profession (medium.com)
  38. ^ jobs in business and manufacturing (stuff.mit.edu)
  39. ^ were closed to them (thewesterncarolinajournalist.com)
  40. ^ barriers began to fall (www.bls.gov)
  41. ^ risen at the same pace (files.eric.ed.gov)
  42. ^ about 70% of teachers (genderpolicyreport.umn.edu)
  43. ^ teachers were women (www.pewresearch.org)
  44. ^ earn an average 85% (www.pewresearch.org)
  45. ^ 80,000 new teachers (nces.ed.gov)
  46. ^ teacher preparation programs (archive.ph)
  47. ^ rebounding in recent years (www.insidehighered.com)
  48. ^ working conditions (freedomined.org)
  49. ^ professional support play a central role (www.rand.org)

Authors: Lee Ann Rawlins Williams, Clinical Assistant Professor of Education, Health and Behavior Studies, University of North Dakota

Read more https://theconversation.com/i-asked-students-whether-theyd-want-to-be-teachers-they-quickly-responded-why-would-i-275904