Massive planet too big for its own sun pushes astronomers to rethink exoplanet formation

Imagine you’re a farmer searching for eggs in the chicken coop – but instead of a chicken egg, you find an ostrich egg, much larger than anything a chicken could lay.

That’s a little how our team^[1] of astronomers^[2] felt when we^[3] discovered a massive planet^[4], more than 13 times heavier than Earth, around a cool, dim red star, nine times less massive than Earth’s Sun, earlier this year.

The smaller star, called an M star, is not only smaller than the Sun in Earth’s solar system, but it’s 100 times less luminous. Such a star should not have the necessary amount of material in its planet-forming disk to birth such a massive planet.

The Habitable Zone Planet Finder

Over the past decade, our team designed and built a new instrument at Penn State capable of detecting the light from these dim, cool stars at wavelengths beyond the sensitivity of the human eye – in the near-infrared – where such cool stars emit most of their light^[5].

Attached to the 10-meter Hobby-Eberly Telescope in West Texas, our instrument, dubbed the Habitable Zone Planet Finder^[6], can measure the subtle change in a star’s velocity as a planet gravitationally tugs on it. This technique, called the Doppler radial velocity technique, is great for detecting exoplanets^[7].

“Exoplanet^[8]” is a combination of the words extrasolar and planet, so the term applies to any planet-sized body in orbit around a star that isn’t Earth’s Sun.

Thirty years ago, Doppler radial velocity observations enabled the discovery of 51 Pegasi b^[9], the first known exoplanet orbiting a Sunlike star. In the ensuing decades, astronomers like us have improved this technique. These increasingly more precise^[10] measurements have an important goal: to enable the discovery of rocky planets in habitable zones^[11], the regions around stars where liquid water can be sustained on the planetary surface.

The Doppler technique doesn’t yet have the capabilities to discover habitable zone planets the mass of the Earth around stars the size of the Sun. But the cool and dim M stars show a larger Doppler signature for the same Earth-size planet. The lower mass of the star leads to it getting tugged more by the orbiting planet. And the lower luminosity leads to a closer-in habitable zone^[12] and a shorter orbit, which also makes the planet easier to detect.

Planets around these smaller stars were the planets our team designed the Habitable Zone Planet Finder to discover. Our new discovery, published in the journal Science^[13], of a massive planet orbiting closely around the cool dim M star LHS 3154 – the ostrich egg in the chicken coop – came as a real surprise.

LHS 3154b: The planet that should not exist

Planets form in disks^[14] composed of gas and dust. These disks pull together dust grains that grow into pebbles and eventually combine to form a solid planetary core. Once the core is formed, the planet can gravitationally pull in the solid dust, as well as surrounding gas such as hydrogen and helium. But it needs a lot of mass and materials to do this successfully. This way to form planets is called core accretion^[15].

A star as low mass as LHS 3154, nine times less massive than the Sun, should have a correspondingly low-mass planet forming disk.

A typical disk around such a low-mass star should simply not have enough solid materials or mass to be able to make a core heavy enough to create such a planet. From computer simulations our team conducted, we concluded that such a planet needs a disk at least 10 times more massive than typically assumed from direct observations of planet-forming disks^[16].

A different planet formation theory, gravitational instability^[17] – where gas and dust in the disk undergo a direct collapse to form a planet – also struggles to explain the formation of such a planet without a very massive disk.

Planets around the most common stars

Cool, dim M stars are the most common stars in our galaxy^[18]. In DC comics lore, Superman’s home world^[19], planet Krypton, orbited an M dwarf star^[20].

Astronomers know, from discoveries made with Habitable Zone Planet Finder and other instruments, that giant planets in close-in orbits around the most massive M stars are at least 10 times rarer^[21] than those around Sunlike stars. And we know of no such massive planets in close orbits around the least massive M stars – until the discovery of LHS 3154b.

Understanding how planets form around our coolest neighbors will help us understand both how planets form in general and how rocky worlds around the most numerous types of stars form and evolve. This line of research could also help astronomers understand whether M stars are capable of supporting life.

References

1. ^{^} our team (scholar.google.com)
2. ^{^} of astronomers (scholar.google.com)
3. ^{^} felt when we (science.psu.edu)
4. ^{^} discovered a massive planet (doi.org)
5. ^{^} emit most of their light (www.e-education.psu.edu)
6. ^{^} Habitable Zone Planet Finder (hpf.psu.edu)
7. ^{^} great for detecting exoplanets (theconversation.com)
8. ^{^} Exoplanet (exoplanets.nasa.gov)
9. ^{^} 51 Pegasi b (exoplanets.nasa.gov)
10. ^{^} increasingly more precise (noirlab.edu)
11. ^{^} habitable zones (exoplanets.nasa.gov)
12. ^{^} closer-in habitable zone (exoplanets.nasa.gov)
13. ^{^} published in the journal Science (doi.org)
14. ^{^} Planets form in disks (theconversation.com)
15. ^{^} core accretion (earthhow.com)
16. ^{^} from direct observations of planet-forming disks (doi.org)
17. ^{^} gravitational instability (astrobites.org)
18. ^{^} the most common stars in our galaxy (www.stsci.edu)
19. ^{^} Superman’s home world (theconversation.com)
20. ^{^} planet Krypton, orbited an M dwarf star (www.theguardian.com)
21. ^{^} at least 10 times rarer (doi.org)