Coronavirus is hundreds of times more deadly for people over 60 than people under 40
- Written by Nir Menachemi, Professor of Health Policy and Management, IUPUI
How deadly is SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19? And what are the risks of death for people of different ages and demographics? These have been hard numbers to calculate during this pandemic.
To calculate the true death rate – more accurately called the infection–fatality ratio (IFR) – you would simply divide the total number of coronavirus deaths by the total number of infections[1]. The problem is that with so many asymptomatic cases[2] and limited testing[3] for much of the pandemic, finding the true number of infections has been very difficult[4].
The easiest way to calculate more accurate infection and death rates is to perform random testing[5].
I am a professor of health policy and management[6]. In April, in partnership with the Indiana State Department of Health, I led a team of researchers at Indiana University to randomly select and test people for SARS-CoV-2[7]. Based on our statistical sample, we found that 2.8% of Indiana[8] – or approximately 188,000 people – had been cumulatively infected by that time and determined the death rate in Indiana to be 0.58%[9].
Using the data we gathered from that testing program, over the past few months, my colleagues and I set out to determine how the infection–fatality ratio differs by age, race and other demographic factors. In a study published on Sept. 2[10], we report that the coronavirus is hundreds of times more deadly for people over 60 compared to people under 40, and that in Indiana, non-white people are dying at three times the rate of white people.
Not all groups of people face the same risk of death from the coronavirus.
Mashot/iStock via Getty Images Plus[11]
Age matters most, but race matters too
Not all groups of people face equal risk of death from the coronavirus[12]. Researchers and health officials have known for months that there were discrepancies, but by calculating death rates, our paper gives the most accurate data about these differences.
Almost half of COVID-19 deaths have occurred among people in nursing homes[13] because these people are generally less healthy and face a much higher risk of serious illness. We wanted to determine the risk of death for people not in nursing homes or other live–in institutions, so the numbers below are for Indiana residents who live out in the community.
The overall infection fatality ratio among community-dwelling people in Indiana was 0.26%, or one death for every 385 people infected. Age, more than race or sex, was the biggest factor affecting the death rate.
For people 60 or over, one in every 58 infections resulted in death, an IFR of 1.7%[14]. For comparison, the IFR from influenza[15] in the U.S. among people over 65 years is 0.8%. COVID-19 is approximately 2.5 times more deadly than the flu in this age group.
Risk drops off as age decreases. For middle-aged adults between 40 and 59 years old, the IFR was 0.12% – or one death for every 833 infections.
And for infected people under 40, death was uncommon at only about one in 10,000 – an IFR of 0.01%[16].
While age was the strongest factor affecting the death rate, racial differences were notable too. Non-white Indiana residents across all age groups had a three-times higher risk of death[17] if they became infected – an IFR of 0.59% – compared to white residents – 0.18% IFR.
People with additional health problems are most at risk, and older people and racial minorities tend to be the least healthy groups in the U.S.
Ake Ngiamsanguan/iStock via Getty Images Plus[18]
Death rates mirror other measures of health
For COVID–19, like most diseases, the worse your health before you get infected, the worse your chances of fighting off the virus.
Researchers know that certain chronic diseases[19] – including cardiovascular, kidney, and lung diseases, as well as diabetes – all increase one’s risk of death from COVID-19. Our team didn’t collect extensive health data from the people we tested, but these chronic diseases are more common among the elderly[20] and racial minorities[21] in the U.S.
Other factors, like food and housing insecurity and insufficient access to care[22], also make fighting off disease more challenging and are more common among elderly and minority populations[23]. The higher infection–fatality ratios we found in these groups are likely due to a combination of comorbidities and these other factors.
Are these numbers applicable across the US?
Our study gave us the most accurate statewide look at infection and death rates so far in the U.S. The question is whether Indiana is a good comparison to the rest of the country.
Indiana ranks relatively low[24] for overall health among states in the U.S. However, Indiana’s median age[25] is slightly lower than the U.S. overall and lower than many states.
I believe that the numbers we found for community-dwelling people in Indiana are likely close to national averages, but the infection–fatality ratio could vary from state to state or town to town. If your state’s elderly population is healthier than the same group in Indiana, the IFR could be a little lower. If your state is less healthy, than the risk will be higher.
The most obvious way to prevent deaths and serious illness from COVID-19 is to reduce the number of people who are infected. By doing simple things like wearing a mask and practicing social distancing, everyone can help protect each other and especially our friends, neighbors, customers and counterparts who face the most risk from the pandemic.
[Get facts about coronavirus and the latest research. Sign up for The Conversation’s newsletter.[26]]
References
- ^ total number of infections (theconversation.com)
- ^ so many asymptomatic cases (theconversation.com)
- ^ limited testing (theconversation.com)
- ^ been very difficult (theconversation.com)
- ^ random testing (theconversation.com)
- ^ professor of health policy and management (scholar.google.com)
- ^ randomly select and test people for SARS-CoV-2 (www.cdc.gov)
- ^ 2.8% of Indiana (theconversation.com)
- ^ death rate in Indiana to be 0.58% (theconversation.com)
- ^ published on Sept. 2 (doi.org)
- ^ Mashot/iStock via Getty Images Plus (www.gettyimages.com)
- ^ equal risk of death from the coronavirus (www.nytimes.com)
- ^ people in nursing homes (www.nytimes.com)
- ^ an IFR of 1.7% (doi.org)
- ^ IFR from influenza (www.cdc.gov)
- ^ one in 10,000 – an IFR of 0.01% (doi.org)
- ^ three-times higher risk of death (doi.org)
- ^ Ake Ngiamsanguan/iStock via Getty Images Plus (www.gettyimages.com)
- ^ certain chronic diseases (www.cdc.gov)
- ^ the elderly (www.cdc.gov)
- ^ racial minorities (www.americanprogress.org)
- ^ insufficient access to care (tcf.org)
- ^ minority populations (assets.aarp.org)
- ^ ranks relatively low (www.americashealthrankings.org)
- ^ median age (en.wikipedia.org)
- ^ Sign up for The Conversation’s newsletter. (theconversation.com)
Authors: Nir Menachemi, Professor of Health Policy and Management, IUPUI
