American individualism lives on after death, as consumers choose new ways to put their remains to rest
- Written by Diana Blaine, Professor of Gender and Sexuality Studies, USC Dornsife College of Letters, Arts and Sciences
Death may be inevitable and universal, but the ways people deal with it most certainly are not. Whether doing Tibetan Buddhist sky burials[1], attending a graveside service dressed in black or putting one’s parents’ ashes in the sacred Ganges[2], each culture has its own ways to deal with death and mourning.
Yet death rites around the world do share some common goals. Traditionally, what happens to a dead body reflects communal beliefs and practices – rituals not only meant to honor the deceased but also to comfort their community.
Increasingly, however, people in the United States are choosing unconventional ways to dispose of their bodies. Today, fans of music might have their cremated remains pressed into LPs[3]. Wannabe astronomers can be shot into space[4].
In my research on death in the U.S.[5] – from mummy exhibits[6] and lurid true crime cases to Michael Jackson’s celebrity-filled memorial[7] – I have found that many Americans are more attracted to sensational portrayals of mortality than realistic ones.
Similarly, I believe these new funeral practices present death as a fantastic, personalized adventure, rather than something natural and inevitable. They emphasize the power of the individual consumer – up to and including the last purchase they’ll ever make.
Comfort and community
Even when expected, death is always upsetting, unsettling mourners’ sense of normalcy. One important function of death rituals is to help survivors process their grief and reestablish order.
Many funerary rituals also emphasize the immortality of the deceased, whom they depict as entering another realm of existence. Depending on the particular culture[8], this journey might require the community to burn the body, leave it exposed to carrion animals, bury it or mummify it.
Christians in the United States have long practiced earth burial, gathering at the graveside to witness their loved one’s final interment. A minister preaches about the soul, which in this faith is believed to transcend the body and spend eternity in a heavenly afterlife – providing that the person lived a life in line with religious dictates.
Christian teachings that Jesus will ultimately resurrect believers’ bodies[10] on Judgment Day, not just their souls, helped shape standards of funeral practices, including embalming and casketing an intact body. These religious beliefs also influenced the emergence of the modern funeral industry[11] in the U.S.
Long-term shifts
For decades, though, American norms around death and funerals have been changing.
While the nation’s majority is still Christian, religious diversity has grown significantly. About 6% of Americans belong to another faith[12], and around 3 in 10 are unaffiliated[13], according to the Pew Research Center. More Americans than ever before count themselves among the “spiritual but not religious.”
Christianity’s decreasing dominance has helped give rise to new ways of handling death – including among Christians. Half of the people who die in the U.S. each year are now cremated[14], the traditional method[15] of bodily disposal for communities like Japanese Buddhists and South Asian Hindus.
But the increasing costs of burials have also made cremation a more attractive option[16] for people from other religions. Among Christians, Protestants embraced the practice before Catholics, as the Vatican banned cremation until 1963[17]. Yet cremated Christians may still opt to include other long-standing funeral practices into their memorial services, such as reading biblical passages and using Christian symbols on urns and other mementos.
Drive-by viewings at funeral homes helped people pay their final respects during the pandemic, despite limits on the number of people at gatherings.
John Moore/Getty Images[18]
Ordering your afterlife
It is not just practices around death that have been changing, though, but attitudes.
Beginning in the 20th century, with the decrease in handling dead bodies at home, Americans grew increasingly uncomfortable with the contemplation of their own death. As my research on the popularity of true crime[19], mummy exhibits[20] and celebrity deaths[21] has shown, many people prefer to think about mortality as a phenomenon that happens to others, often in spectacular and even entertaining ways.
Anthropologist Geoffrey Gorer[22] argued in the 1950s[23] that with the decline in religious beliefs, death had become unbearable to think about – even death-bed scenes in literature had grown scarcer, he said. Instead, Gorer argued, depictions of death had become like pornography: something natural made taboo, a guilty pleasure, and represented in an unnatural light.
Today’s popularity of superhero and gangster films featuring violent deaths, or horror movies filled with otherworldly monsters, shows just how right he was. Death from natural causes, on the other hand, is typically shielded from view. Even the “Barbie” movie, which features a montage depicting what it means to be human, shies away from showing dying, grief or loss.
On an individual level, too, some Americans are opting to handle their remains in new ways, including methods that feel removed from the reality of death and decomposition. Rather than being planted under a field of green grass, for example, people who enjoyed hunting can choose to have their cremains placed in bullet casings[24] – fantasizing their continued identity as killers. Those preferring a less aggressive finish might have their cremains transformed into diamond jewelry[25]. A trace of carbon remains after bodies have been burned, and numerous companies will take that small bit and purify enough out of it to form a sparkly jewel.
Wearable memorial tokens actually have origins in the Victorian era. England’s Queen Victoria became a symbol of public mourning[26] following the death of her husband, Prince Albert, whose hair she had fashioned into jewelry. During the era, locks from the dead were woven into designs, placed in frames and worn as pendants.
A Victorian bracelet with a band of woven hair, from the mid-19th century, which may have been a piece of mourning jewelry.
Museum of London/Heritage Images/Hulton Archive via Getty Images[27]
Traditional mourning jewelry, therfore, was a visible reminder of death, with the loved one’s hair on display. Today’s commercial enterprises[28], on the other hand, offer mass-marketed gemstones to a consumer public and look indistinguishable from any other jewelry, effectively hiding their relation to the dead body.
Lest jewelry seem too materialistic, nature lovers can request that they be incorporated into coral reefs[29] or trees[30] after death. The variety of products using hair and ashes keeps growing: One company[31] creates glass sex toys that house customers’ cremains, while other services will package ashes into fireworks[32] or scatter them during a skydive[33].
But despite these secular, consumer-based, highly individualized options reflecting the move away from traditional religious explanations for death, I believe each one still appeals to a desire for immortality. In that sense, they connect to a universal human longing to live on – as people who remain active, present and vital, even in death.
References
- ^ Tibetan Buddhist sky burials (www.atlasobscura.com)
- ^ in the sacred Ganges (www.youtube.com)
- ^ pressed into LPs (www.andvinyly.com)
- ^ shot into space (www.celestis.com)
- ^ my research on death in the U.S. (dornsife.usc.edu)
- ^ mummy exhibits (www.academia.edu)
- ^ Michael Jackson’s celebrity-filled memorial (www.taylorfrancis.com)
- ^ Depending on the particular culture (www.wiley.com)
- ^ RubberBall Productions/Brand X Pictures via Getty Images (www.gettyimages.com)
- ^ resurrect believers’ bodies (www.biblegateway.com)
- ^ the modern funeral industry (www.penguinrandomhouse.com)
- ^ belong to another faith (www.pewresearch.org)
- ^ around 3 in 10 are unaffiliated (www.pewresearch.org)
- ^ are now cremated (www.washingtonpost.com)
- ^ the traditional method (escholarship.org)
- ^ a more attractive option (theconversation.com)
- ^ banned cremation until 1963 (www.nytimes.com)
- ^ John Moore/Getty Images (www.gettyimages.com)
- ^ true crime (www.academia.edu)
- ^ mummy exhibits (www.jstor.org)
- ^ celebrity deaths (www.taylorfrancis.com)
- ^ Anthropologist Geoffrey Gorer (www.sussex.ac.uk)
- ^ argued in the 1950s (www.unz.com)
- ^ placed in bullet casings (www.myholysmoke.com)
- ^ transformed into diamond jewelry (www.saintdiamonds.com)
- ^ a symbol of public mourning (daily.jstor.org)
- ^ Museum of London/Heritage Images/Hulton Archive via Getty Images (www.gettyimages.com)
- ^ Today’s commercial enterprises (www.heart-in-diamond.com)
- ^ incorporated into coral reefs (www.eternalreefs.com)
- ^ or trees (www.thelivingurn.com)
- ^ One company (marksturkenboom.com)
- ^ into fireworks (heavenlystarsfireworks.com)
- ^ scatter them during a skydive (skyhighskydiving.co.uk)
Authors: Diana Blaine, Professor of Gender and Sexuality Studies, USC Dornsife College of Letters, Arts and Sciences
