• Written by Ronnie R. Gipson Jr., Assistant Professor of Law, University of Memphis

When police officers kill people without apparent justification, those officers may face both criminal charges – as in the case of Derek Chauvin, convicted of murdering George Floyd[1] in Minneapolis in 2020 – and civil lawsuits.

Floyd’s family filed a federal civil rights suit against Chauvin and three other officers, alleging they used “unjustified, excessive, illegal and deadly force[2]” while detaining him. The suit also named the city of Minneapolis, alleging city officials did not have good policies about using force and didn’t train the officers properly.

In March 2021, as Chauvin’s criminal trial was set to begin, the city settled the lawsuit – agreeing to pay US$27 million to Floyd’s family[3] – but Chauvin and the other officers paid nothing.

That’s because, as a Minneapolis police officer at the time he killed Floyd, Chauvin was legally immune from civil lawsuits seeking damages for his actions. The principle is called “qualified immunity,” and it protects government workers from being sued for things they do in their official roles at work.

A brief history of immunity

The U.S. legal system has two types of immunity. The first is absolute immunity, which has a long history dating back to judges’ rulings under English common law[4] from the 1700s. This type of immunity protects judges and lawmakers from being sued[5] by people who suffer financially from their rulings or policy decisions. Therefore, judges and lawmakers are free to make the best decisions for society as a whole without worrying that anyone who is somehow harmed by their choices could come back and sue them for damages.

The second kind of immunity, the one that affects police officers, stems from the Civil Rights Act of 1871[6]. That law allowed an officer to be sued for official acts only if he knew, or should have known, that his action would violate a person’s constitutional rights, or if he intended to deprive someone of their constitutional rights. This liability depended on the officer’s internal state of mind, which is notoriously hard to prove in court[7].

In 1967, the U.S. Supreme Court changed that focus. The change came about in a ruling that an officer could not be sued for false arrest[8] in the arrest of a person who was later found not to be guilty of a crime. The court did not look at the officer’s state of mind. Instead, the court compared the officer’s actions with those that would be taken by a reasonable public official[9] in the same circumstances. If the officer’s actions were reasonable, then immunity was granted.

Over time, this immunity has been expanded by the courts. It now extends to cover other misdeeds[10], such as infringement of a suspect’s civil rights during the exercise of a police officer’s authority, whether those misdeeds were intentional or not[11].

Police in protective gear spray chemical agents at demonstrators Police use of force, as in this July 2020 pepper-spraying incident in Seattle, is under scrutiny around the country. AP Photo/Ted S. Warren[12]

Making lawsuits harder

The current standard, created by the Supreme Court in 1982[13], protects officers from being sued in civil court unless their actions are objectively ruled a violation of the law.

An aggrieved citizen with a civil rights complaint can no longer argue that an officer’s conduct was motivated by wrongful intent, malice or even prejudice. What matters is not what the officer did but how it compares with what a reasonable officer might have done.

The result of the changed standard has been to severely limit the number of civil claims[14] against police that make it past the officer’s broad defense of qualified immunity.

Over many decades, and with increasing intensity in recent years, news reports and citizen complaints have identified police officers harming civilians, particularly Black Americans, seemingly with impunity. Officers know the law will shield them from personal liability, and they also know that it is rare for officers to face criminal charges[15] – much less be convicted.

But recent examples may bring additional attention to this issue.

In March 2021, Marion Humphrey, a Black law student at the University of Arkansas, filed a federal lawsuit against an Arkansas state trooper[16], alleging the trooper unlawfully searched his personal belongings during a traffic stop in August 2020. The trooper has not been disciplined or faced criminal changes, but the lawsuit says a video camera captured the trooper making insulting remarks about Humphrey’s race and age.

In April 2021, Caron Nazario, a Black U.S. Army lieutenant, filed a civil rights lawsuit against two police officers in Virginia who pepper-sprayed him[17] during a December 2020 traffic stop. One of the officers involved was fired[18], and the other was ordered to undergo retraining. The state attorney general is investigating the incident[19], in which Nazario says his constitutional rights were violated.

It is not yet clear how those lawsuits will address the possibility of the officers claiming – or being granted – qualified immunity. But those incidents and others like them have sparked intense debate[20] about whether, and under what circumstances, police officers should have qualified immunity.

Proponents say qualified immunity offers a balance between letting victims hold officials accountable and minimizing harm to society as a whole. Opponents say it serves as protection for wrongdoers that harks back to Jim Crow laws and is a vestige of racism that perpetuates unequal treatment before the law.

A crowd of people march, some carrying mock coffins Family members of people killed by police in Minnesota march on the state’s Capitol building in October 2020 demanding better accountability for police violence, including an end to officers’ qualified immunity from civil lawsuits. Chris Juhn/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images[21]

A move to eliminate qualified immunity

Qualified immunity is a federal law construct; however, some states are already moving to do away with this type of legal protection for police officers. In June 2020, the state of Colorado did so, in direct response to George Floyd’s death[22] and the resulting protests. In August 2020, Connecticut took a similar step[23].

In March 2021, the New York City Council did the same[24] for its police department. New Mexico joined the growing movement[25] the following month.

At the federal level, the U.S. House of Representatives passed the George Floyd Justice in Policing Act[26] in March 2021, which in part seeks to limit the ability of police officers to claim qualified immunity as a defense in private lawsuits. The bill is now in the U.S. Senate for consideration. Similar laws are likely to spread across the country as Americans and their lawmakers examine whether qualified immunity for police does more harm than good.

[Over 100,000 readers rely on The Conversation’s newsletter to understand the world. Sign up today[27].]


  1. ^ convicted of murdering George Floyd (
  2. ^ unjustified, excessive, illegal and deadly force (
  3. ^ pay US$27 million to Floyd’s family (
  4. ^ judges’ rulings under English common law (
  5. ^ judges and lawmakers from being sued (
  6. ^ Civil Rights Act of 1871 (
  7. ^ notoriously hard to prove in court (
  8. ^ could not be sued for false arrest (
  9. ^ reasonable public official (
  10. ^ extends to cover other misdeeds (
  11. ^ whether those misdeeds were intentional or not (
  12. ^ AP Photo/Ted S. Warren (
  13. ^ created by the Supreme Court in 1982 (
  14. ^ severely limit the number of civil claims (
  15. ^ rare for officers to face criminal charges (
  16. ^ federal lawsuit against an Arkansas state trooper (
  17. ^ two police officers in Virginia who pepper-sprayed him (
  18. ^ was fired (
  19. ^ investigating the incident (
  20. ^ sparked intense debate (
  21. ^ Chris Juhn/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images (
  22. ^ direct response to George Floyd’s death (
  23. ^ Connecticut took a similar step (
  24. ^ New York City Council did the same (
  25. ^ New Mexico joined the growing movement (
  26. ^ George Floyd Justice in Policing Act (
  27. ^ Sign up today (

Authors: Ronnie R. Gipson Jr., Assistant Professor of Law, University of Memphis

Read more

Metropolitan republishes selected articles from The Conversation USA with permission

Visit The Conversation to see more

Entertainment News

My Musical Journey – Zarbo

People call me Zarbo. I call myself an artist/producer currently focused on creating catchy electronic dance music and exploring new genres that didn’t exist at the beginning of my musical career in the ‘70’s.  I am the original founding member, fr...

Alex Zarbo - avatar Alex Zarbo

News Company asked some Music Industry “Insiders” their thoughts on the current state and future of “Real Music”

To get a feel for the current state of the music industry, NewsCo asked some insiders to share their thoughts. Here is what they had to say. Real Music, to me, means music created by real instruments where you can hear the bow go across the fiddle o...

NewsCo - avatar NewsCo

Navigating the Gender Gap, Part 2 For Women: How to Work with Men in Music

After comparing notes with some of my female music friends, I’ve come up with some pointers for women about working with male colleagues. As I mentioned in my previous article, “How to Work with Women in Music,” these guidelines are based on per...

Angela Predhomme - avatar Angela Predhomme

The Making Of “ Birkenhead Drill”

The process of self producing a full length album in the middle of a pandemic has been an unending lesson in humility, but it’s also affirmed our love of music and more importantly the music we make together. The journey of Birkenhead Drill taught ...

The Jones Title - avatar The Jones Title

A Healing Power of Rap and Rock

What do Jay-Z, Rick Ruben, Neil Diamond, Snoop Dogg, Chago G. Williams, and Toto’s Steve Lukather have in common?  They can be combined into Six Degrees of Inclusion (not separation per-se).   They all have millions of fans and they have all hugely...

Rebecca DGD - avatar Rebecca DGD

Gold selling and Platinum Award Winning Recording Artist Ny'a, giving back to her community

Gold selling and Platinum Award Winning Recording Artist Ny'a, will be Live in concert on Sessions Livestream, Saturday April 24th at 7:00pm EST. Tickets are $5 dollars, with a donation going to Rahway Food For Friends. Ny'a believe in giving back ...

NewsCo - avatar NewsCo

Metropolitan Business News

4 Creative suggestions for your first business card

Almost all businesses nowadays have a business card. Business cards are important to easily showcase your brand, yourself, and your business. However, not all business cards are made the same. Som...

NewsCo - avatar NewsCo


Ask any of her thousands of global followers - especially the 11,000-plus who’ve learned to monetize their social media, and the 700-plus who’ve created six figure incomes – and they’ll be happy to ...

NewsCo - avatar NewsCo

Why Creativity Is So Important In Digital Marketing

The Role of Creativity in Digital Marketing's Future  As marketers, one of the key tasks is to be creative and look for ways to generate demand and interest in our services and products. Creati...

NewsCo - avatar NewsCo

Essential Tips for Developing Corporate Websites

The corporate industry, just like the others, is experiencing a massive technological revolution. Organizations have changed their marketing criteria by embracing the internet. Therefore, do not be ...

News Co - avatar News Co

How to Make a Personal Injury Claim for Minors

As a parent, you want to make sure your child is always safe. But as much as you want to keep him under your watch, it is impossible to be there for him all the time. When he is out there attendin...

News Co - avatar News Co

Dress for Success - Style Essentials for Every Businessmen

Did you ever glance at a person in passing and instantly think, “Wow, they must be successful”? It seems like the rich and successful people always stand out from the crowd without even trying, ...

Diana Smith - avatar Diana Smith

Writers Wanted

News Co Media

Content & Technology Connecting Global Audiences

More Information - Less Opinion