Jesus, Paul and the border debate – why cherry-picking Bible passages misses the immigrant experience in ancient Rome
- Written by Rodolfo Galvan Estrada III, Adjunct Assistant Professor of the New Testament, Fuller Theological Seminary
Immigration reform is back on the agenda, with Congress taking up major legislation[1] that could usher in a pathway to citizenship for millions of people living in the U.S. without legal status.
This, and an increase in migrants crossing the southern border[2] to the U.S., has seen many people retreat to two common positions on the issue. Advocates[3] for reform generally emphasize the history of America as a nation of immigrants. Meanwhile, opponents[4] draw to the identity of America as a nation based on the rule of law[5], with a sovereign right to protect its borders[6].
Given the role that Christianity plays in many Americans’ lives[7] and in politics in general[8], it shouldn’t be surprising that people from the religious right and left draw from the Bible to support their immigration perspectives.
Biblical stories
Former U.S. Attorney General Jeff Sessions, for example, drew upon the Apostle Paul’s view of the government[9] to back his support for child separation immigration[10] policies at the border. “I would cite you to the Apostle Paul and his clear and wise command in Romans 13, to obey the laws of the government because God has ordained them for the purpose of order,” he stated. For those in favor of a more progressive policy on immigration, there are numerous passages in the Bible[11] that indicate a willingness to welcome strangers and foreigners.
The truth is, the Bible has many stories of migration, beginning in the book of Genesis with Adam and Eve[12] migrating from the Garden of Eden and concluding with the book of Revelation, where John[13], traditionally known as the apostle, lives as a deported criminal on Patmos, an island located west of Turkey.
As a New Testament scholar, my research[14] on how foreigners[15] are portrayed during the first century has led me to recognize that selecting a few texts from Jesus’ teaching[16] on welcoming the foreigner or the Apostle Paul’s teachings[17] on the government does not provide the full story on the immigrant experience.
In reality, their experience was politically and culturally complex. Immigrants in Rome during the time of Jesus and Paul encountered suspicion and hostility from the imperial authorities and Roman natives.
Unfriendly Romans and noncountrymen
Many foreigners in the capital of Rome were immigrants. David Noy[18], a scholar of classical literature[19], finds that they came to the empire either as captured slaves or voluntarily migrated in search of better opportunities.
Some ancient Roman writers during the time of Jesus viewed the presence of immigrants negatively. Nostalgia for a time when Rome was less influenced by outsiders emerged among Roman elites. Ancient Roman writers Pliny[20] and Seneca[21] believed that as the empire extended, the foreigners culturally conquered the Romans[22] by negatively influencing the Roman way of life.
There was a “strong sense that Rome was losing vigor and vitality through its luxuries and a fear of being undermined by foreign immigrants from among the subjugated people,” according to[23] classical literature scholar Benjamin Isaac[24].
To counter this immigrant threat and presence in Italy, the Romans enacted the imperial power of expulsion. The Roman historian Livy[25] remarks that those who introduced foreign religions were frequently expelled for failing to adopt to “the Roman way.”
Suetonius[26], another Roman historian, records that emperor Claudius, who ruled in the decades following Jesus’ death, banned foreigners from using a Roman name and expelled the Jews from the city of Rome. Interestingly, this Jewish expulsion also shows up in the New Testament with the expulsion of the Christian missionary couple Priscilla and Aquila[27] from Rome in A.D. 49.
Exile was a common Roman punishment, as the poet Ovid found out.
Heritage Art/Heritage Images via Getty Images[28]
Expulsions were not always permanent or reserved for foreigners. Most famously, the Roman poet Ovid[29] was expelled for writing controversial erotic literature. He was deported to the land of Tomis, current Romania.
[You’re smart and curious about the world. So are The Conversation’s authors and editors. You can read us daily by subscribing to our newsletter[30].]
Welcoming strangers
Understanding the reality of immigrants and their status during the birth of Christianity shapes how Jesus’ teachings are understood. At the time when Jesus tells his disciples about the necessity of “welcoming the stranger[31],” this was the righteous response to the political tragedy of a fellow human being. To deny them hospitality would be a death sentence. Not all immigrants migrated for economic reasons – for some it was their only life option because of the imperial act of expulsion.
Knowing that immigrants could be expelled for negatively influencing the Roman culture must also shape our understanding of Paul’s teaching to “submit[32]” to Roman authorities. Since Paul was a Roman citizen[33], it would have been instinctive to instruct other Christians living in Rome to maintain political peace with the empire. As with Ovid, being a Roman citizen did not exempt them from being treated like foreigners. The empire was indiscriminate in its deportation power, and citizens like Paul who introduced non-Roman religions were not exempt.
The U.S. immigration debate continues to be controversial. Whenever the writings of Paul or teachings of Jesus are introduced into the debate, we need to understand the context of the time. The Roman imperial power of deportation had life-and-death implications for immigrants and citizens.
Furthermore, during the time of Jesus and Paul, both Roman citizens and noncitizens could be deported from Rome. But foreigners who introduced non-Roman cultures in Rome were more likely to be expelled for being perceived as threats.
Kristin Kobes Du Mez[34], professor of history at Calvin University, notes that White evangelical Christians[35] appear “more opposed to immigration reform, and have more negative views about immigrants, than any other religious demographic.” Perhaps for some evangelicals, discomfort and suspicion with outsiders lies at the root of anti-immigrant policies as it did during the time of Romans.
References
- ^ Congress taking up major legislation (www.usatoday.com)
- ^ increase in migrants crossing the southern border (www.reuters.com)
- ^ Advocates (www.whitehouse.gov)
- ^ opponents (www.abc10.com)
- ^ rule of law (www.federalregister.gov)
- ^ to protect its borders (www.govinfo.gov)
- ^ many Americans’ lives (www.pewforum.org)
- ^ in politics in general (www.pewforum.org)
- ^ drew upon the Apostle Paul’s view of the government (www.usatoday.com)
- ^ child separation immigration (theconversation.com)
- ^ numerous passages in the Bible (sojo.net)
- ^ Adam and Eve (www.biblegateway.com)
- ^ John (www.biblegateway.com)
- ^ my research (wipfandstock.com)
- ^ foreigners (brill.com)
- ^ teaching (www.biblegateway.com)
- ^ teachings (www.biblegateway.com)
- ^ David Noy (doi.org)
- ^ scholar of classical literature (www.open.ac.uk)
- ^ Pliny (www.perseus.tufts.edu)
- ^ Seneca (www.newadvent.org)
- ^ conquered the Romans (www.perseus.tufts.edu)
- ^ according to (doi.org)
- ^ Benjamin Isaac (press.princeton.edu)
- ^ Livy (www.perseus.tufts.edu)
- ^ Suetonius (penelope.uchicago.edu)
- ^ Priscilla and Aquila (www.biblegateway.com)
- ^ Heritage Art/Heritage Images via Getty Images (www.gettyimages.com)
- ^ Ovid (www.bloomsbury.com)
- ^ You can read us daily by subscribing to our newsletter (theconversation.com)
- ^ welcoming the stranger (www.biblegateway.com)
- ^ submit (www.biblegateway.com)
- ^ Paul was a Roman citizen (www.biblegateway.com)
- ^ Kristin Kobes Du Mez (bulletin.hds.harvard.edu)
- ^ White evangelical Christians (theconversation.com)
Authors: Rodolfo Galvan Estrada III, Adjunct Assistant Professor of the New Testament, Fuller Theological Seminary
