Metro

  • Written by Anthony Fargo, Director, Center for International Media Law and Policy Studies, Indiana University

The images[1] from the Jan. 6 siege on the United States Capitol will likely be seared into the memories of many Americans.

Photographs and video published in print, online and on television showed protesters breaking windows[2] to enter the building, sitting at a desk in House Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s office[3] and confronting[4] an outnumbered Capitol police force.

However, it may be the unpublished images that will be of most interest to law enforcement agencies as they track down[5] and arrest as many of the rioters as possible for breaking a range of laws[6]. The agencies may request or demand that news organizations turn over their unpublished material, which would force the media outlets to make uncomfortable choices.

Journalists argue[7] that if they are forced to reveal confidential sources or turn over any news information they have gathered but not yet published, it will erode the trust of sources and the public, who will doubt the independence that journalists often claim.

Journalists serve the public, not the government. But is the public better served by bringing criminals to justice than protecting a journalistic principle?

Conflicting interests

Many of the people who participated in the attack on the Capitol building have been identified and arrested, some with help from photos published[8] by the media and selfies[9] and videos[10] taken by the protesters.

As the search for more suspects continues, if authorities seek unpublished images from the news media and media outlets willingly cooperate, it could put journalists in greater danger when covering future protests. Protesters may see them as potential informants and physically attack them to avoid being identified later.

If the outlets resist and force authorities to issue subpoenas[11] for the images, it is unlikely to improve the media’s standing with a distrustful public[12] because it may appear the news organizations are obstructing justice.

A pile of damaged news equipment, including cameras, at the Capitol riot. Equipment of media crews damaged during clashes after Trump supporters breached U.S. Capitol security. Tayfun Coskun/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images[13]

Dangers of covering protests

Covering unrest is always dangerous for journalists, but the situation at the Capitol was especially so.

The protesters were supporters of President Donald Trump, who has often referred to the media as the “enemy of the people[14].” Someone carved the words “Murder the Media”[15] into a door in the building, and news outlets lost thousands of dollars of equipment[16] when it was stolen and smashed by protesters.

During protests after George Floyd[17] was killed while being taken into police custody last summer, several reporters were injured[18] and possibly targeted by protesters and police officers.

In Seattle, police subpoenaed the Seattle Times and several television stations in June 2020 to obtain unpublished images from protests there to identify people suspected of criminal activity. The news organizations challenged the subpoenas in court under Washington state’s shield law[19], which protects journalists from being forced to name confidential sources or turn over unpublished information to state authorities. The Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press filed a brief[20] supporting the news organizations’ position, in which it argued that enforcing the subpoena would jeopardize journalists’ safety as well as their editorial independence.

A judge ruled[21] against them. Police later dropped[22] the subpoenas because media appeals of the judge’s decision were likely to take too long to resolve.

A courthouse building. Journalists often fight subpoenas for their materials. kolderal/Moment/Getty Images[23]

Legal protections for journalists

Because the Capitol siege happened on federal government property, the incident is being investigated[24] by federal authorities, meaning any court challenges to subpoenas would likely end up in federal court. This complicates matters.

Forty states have shield laws[25], but there is no federal shield law. In 1972, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that journalists do not have a First Amendment[26] right to refuse to reveal sources’ identities in response to a valid grand jury subpoena.

The Branzburg v. Hayes[27] decision was so divided, however, that many lower federal courts have limited its reach[28] to grand jury situations. This means that journalists have a better chance of winning if they are subpoenaed to provide evidence in civil lawsuits or at criminal trials.

The Jan. 6 incident does not involve confidential sources. Some federal courts have ruled that nonconfidential material gathered by journalists, including unpublished images, is also protected from disclosure[29], but the protection is usually less comprehensive than for confidential material.

Given the seriousness of the Capitol incident, which led to five deaths[30], it would be difficult for journalists to successfully argue that their interests are more important than those of law enforcement.

I have been studying[31] the law regarding journalists and their sources for nearly 24 years. To my knowledge, U.S. journalists have rarely made the argument that they could face physical danger if they are forced to turn over information they have gathered. The closest parallel is a Washington Post reporter who successfully fought[32] a subpoena from a war crimes tribunal 20 years ago because of fears of retribution in foreign conflict zones.

One possible solution would be for news outlets to publish all images that have not already been published on their websites. That way, both the public and law enforcement agents would have access without a bruising legal battle over making the images available only to the police. A bonus would be that the public would have even more information about what happened.

References

  1. ^ images (www.nbcwashington.com)
  2. ^ breaking windows (www.reuters.com)
  3. ^ desk in House Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s office (www.npr.org)
  4. ^ confronting (www.voanews.com)
  5. ^ track down (www.nytimes.com)
  6. ^ range of laws (www.washingtonpost.com)
  7. ^ argue (www.cjr.org)
  8. ^ photos published (www.nytimes.com)
  9. ^ selfies (www.nbcnews.com)
  10. ^ and videos (www.facebook.com)
  11. ^ subpoenas (www.findlaw.com)
  12. ^ distrustful public (news.gallup.com)
  13. ^ Tayfun Coskun/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images (www.gettyimages.com)
  14. ^ enemy of the people (www.nytimes.com)
  15. ^ “Murder the Media” (cpj.org)
  16. ^ equipment (cpj.org)
  17. ^ George Floyd (www.nytimes.com)
  18. ^ injured (www.usatoday.com)
  19. ^ shield law (apps.leg.wa.gov)
  20. ^ filed a brief (www.rcfp.org)
  21. ^ ruled (globalfreedomofexpression.columbia.edu)
  22. ^ dropped (www.rcfp.org)
  23. ^ kolderal/Moment/Getty Images (www.gettyimages.com)
  24. ^ investigated (www.nytimes.com)
  25. ^ shield laws (mtsu.edu)
  26. ^ First Amendment (www.law.cornell.edu)
  27. ^ Branzburg v. Hayes (www.oyez.org)
  28. ^ limited its reach (www.rcfp.org)
  29. ^ protected from disclosure (casetext.com)
  30. ^ five deaths (www.nytimes.com)
  31. ^ have been studying (mediaschool.indiana.edu)
  32. ^ fought (www.washingtonpost.com)

Authors: Anthony Fargo, Director, Center for International Media Law and Policy Studies, Indiana University

Read more https://theconversation.com/why-the-news-media-may-not-want-to-share-capitol-riot-images-with-the-police-153076

Metropolitan republishes selected articles from The Conversation USA with permission

Visit The Conversation to see more

Entertainment News

Elijah Rock - My Musical Journey

I started my musical journey singing in the Lee Heights Community Church children’s choir. People often ask me how old I was when I first discovered I could sing and interestingly enough, an age doesn’t come to mind. I can’t remember a time when I ...

Elijah Rock - avatar Elijah Rock

What is a Musician?

As a band manager, when I think about what a musician truly is, I feel like I’m on the outside looking in – but I also think my role with Greye gives me a perspective that is unique and objective and probably different than they might see themselve...

Karen Wardle, Band Manager for Greye, Daytona Beach, Florida - avatar Karen Wardle, Band Manager for Greye, Daytona Beach, Florida

Krisanthi Pappas - My Musical Journey

The Joy Of Music Persisted My musical journey began with me singing as a child in my backyard. For the sheer joy  of singing. The journey has taken me through many peaks and valleys but always  focused on the joy, my latest success has been throu...

Krisanthi Pappas - avatar Krisanthi Pappas

MICHAEL MESEY - WHAT MUSIC MEANS TO ME

As Chuck Berry’s go-to special show drummer for many years, I had the honor of meeting and playing with a lot of rock and roll icons, including original members of Bill Haley & The Comets. A few years back in Branson, MO, I went to see them per...

Michael Mesey - avatar Michael Mesey

DORIAN PAUL - MY MUSICAL JOURNEY

It’s so wonderful to be back singing and recording again after a long layoff to raise my family as a single dad. Even though my latest track “Shake It Around” has my trademark grits and gravy funk vibe, major grooves and horn sizzle right out of Ca...

Dorian Paul - avatar Dorian Paul

Originality in Music: Innovators and Imitators

Someone once said to me, “Artists are either innovators or imitators.” Nowhere is this more true than in music.  First off, I want to make it clear that both of these paths have value. People are easily impressed with innovation. If something hasn’t...

Angela Predhomme - avatar Angela Predhomme

Metropolitan Business News

5 Major Advantages of Starting a Real Estate Business

Starting and operating a real estate business is a broad concept. This is because it may involve selling, buying, managing, and developing real estate properties. It can also be a challenging line...

NewsServices.com - avatar NewsServices.com

Should I refinance my home in 2021?

Since last year, we all have seen how mortgage rates have dropped to historical lows of 3% or even less. Because of this current real estate market many have been taking advantage of either buying...

Money.com - avatar Money.com

Importance of SEO services in digital marketing

SEO services are an indispensable part of digital marketing. It is your responsibility to increase the visibility of your website and keep it ahead of all competitors. Improve website visibility, user...

NewsCo - avatar NewsCo

4 Creative suggestions for your first business card

Almost all businesses nowadays have a business card. Business cards are important to easily showcase your brand, yourself, and your business. However, not all business cards are made the same. Som...

NewsCo - avatar NewsCo

WHEN WORLDWIDE BUSINESS BUILDING POWERHOUSE ASHLEY ANN SPEAKS, LIVES CHANGE

Ask any of her thousands of global followers - especially the 11,000-plus who’ve learned to monetize their social media, and the 700-plus who’ve created six figure incomes – and they’ll be happy to ...

NewsCo - avatar NewsCo

Why Creativity Is So Important In Digital Marketing

The Role of Creativity in Digital Marketing's Future  As marketers, one of the key tasks is to be creative and look for ways to generate demand and interest in our services and products. Creati...

NewsCo - avatar NewsCo

Writers Wanted


NewsServices.com

Content & Technology Connecting Global Audiences

More Information - Less Opinion