Metro

  • Written by Michael Blake, Professor of Philosophy, Public Policy and Governance, University of Washington

House Democrats have introduced an article of impeachment[1] against President Trump, charging him with “incitement of insurrection[2]” for the siege at the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 6.

One immediate difficulty facing those seeking to impeach the president is that impeachment is a lengthy process[3]. Trump has only a few days left in office before his term ends on Jan. 20. While the article of impeachment might be quickly approved by the House, in a vote scheduled for Jan. 13[4], the vote will initiate a trial in the Senate – and that trial will likely not be finished before Trump’s term of office comes to an end[5].

There is an open constitutional question about whether a president can be impeached after he has left office[6]. But a more basic question asks about the point of impeaching Trump. Conservative radio host Hugh Hewitt, writing in The Washington Post, described the entire exercise as “pointless revenge[7].”

“It isn’t principled, it isn’t concerned with justice and it isn’t concerned with the future,” he stated.

As a scholar who writes about the moral justifications of social and legal institutions[8], I argue that there may be good moral reason for this impeachment – even if it cannot be completed before Trump leaves office.

Impeachment is not a criminal procedure; it is generally described as “quasi-criminal[9]” in American law.

The philosophical justifications given for the institution of criminal law, however, might help us understand the purposes this impeachment might serve.

Impeachment and criminal law

Criminal law can serve a variety of functions. It incapacitates[10] the criminal, through incarceration; it serves a retributive[11] function, by forcing the criminal to experience punishment proportionate to the crime; and it expresses a particular view about the limits of moral diversity[12], by setting a limit to what sorts of action a society will accept.

Incapacitation is likely a bad justification for the impeachment of an outgoing or former president. Incapacitation is intended to stop a criminal from repeating his or her offense. The offense grounding the president’s impeachment, though, was an act of speech, one the article of impeachment describes as “incitement of insurrection[13].” A president who is impeached and removed from office is precluded from holding federal office in the future; that, however, does nothing to remove the power of Trump to speak.

Retribution is similarly unpromising as justification for impeachment. The “punishments” here – including the loss of Secret Service protection, office space and public funding[14] – hardly seem adequate, if they are conceived of as punishments for one who has incited an insurrection.

Donald Trump, President Donald Trump greets the crowd at the ‘Stop the Steal’ rally Jan. 6 in Washington, D.C. Tasos Katopodis/Getty Images[15]

Punishment as moral condemnation

The final function of criminal law, though – one emphasized by philosopher Joel Feinberg[16] – is likely better able to justify an attempt to impeach an outgoing president. Criminal law, for Feinberg, is intended to mark out the limits of moral disagreement, through a symbolic statement condemning certain sorts of acts as immoral[17].

Citizens in a democratic society do not need to agree about political morality. They can recognize their political opponents as entitled to their views – however mistaken each side takes those alternative views to be. Conservatives and liberals have often regarded each other as wrong, but nonetheless members in good standing in their political communities[18].

There are, however, some points at which a society makes a shared statement that a given sort of practice or act is not politically respectable – and the criminal law is one means by which that statement is made. As Feinberg notes, imprisonment is not simply an unwelcome punishment – it is a symbolic statement that the criminal has done something of which he or she ought to be ashamed[19].

The criminal – or the impeached – might not actually feel ashamed. The function of the criminal law, however, is to say that he or she ought to feel ashamed, and that those who do that sort of act are outside the realm of normal moral disagreement.

[Get the best of The Conversation, every weekend. Sign up for our weekly newsletter[20].]

Politics after violence

We might see this sort of function by examining how legal institutions have responded to much more serious forms of political wrongdoing. The Nuremberg Tribunals[21], most famously, put the Nazi hierarchy on trial, for aggressive war[22] and for crimes against humanity.

The punishments meted out – ranging from 10 years in prison to a relatively quick death by hanging[23] – would seem grossly inadequate, if they were intended to match the moral gravity of genocide and forced labor.

The best justification of Nuremberg, though, looked not to the Nazis themselves, but to those who might have followed in their footsteps[24]. The trial was intended to identify the line past which political societies could not stray without being regarded as shameful – with an eye not simply on the present, but in the future[25].

President Trump’s wrongdoing is nowhere near as grotesque as that of the Nazis, and no purposes are served by pretending otherwise. The best moral purpose for his impeachment, though, might have some moral similarities to the functions of Nuremberg.

If Congress chooses to impeach President Trump, it is because there is a need to mark out, through a definitive statement, what no president ought to do. It will also set the moral limits of the presidency – and, thereby, send a message to future presidents who might be tempted to follow in President Trump’s footsteps.

References

  1. ^ article of impeachment (www.documentcloud.org)
  2. ^ incitement of insurrection (www.washingtonpost.com)
  3. ^ impeachment is a lengthy process (www.govinfo.gov)
  4. ^ in a vote scheduled for Jan. 13 (www.nytimes.com)
  5. ^ comes to an end (nymag.com)
  6. ^ after he has left office (reason.com)
  7. ^ pointless revenge (www.washingtonpost.com)
  8. ^ the moral justifications of social and legal institutions (phil.washington.edu)
  9. ^ quasi-criminal (digitalcommons.law.yale.edu)
  10. ^ incapacitates (openoregon.pressbooks.pub)
  11. ^ retributive (plato.stanford.edu)
  12. ^ limits of moral diversity (www.jstor.org)
  13. ^ incitement of insurrection (www.documentcloud.org)
  14. ^ loss of Secret Service protection, office space and public funding (reason.com)
  15. ^ Tasos Katopodis/Getty Images (www.gettyimages.com)
  16. ^ Joel Feinberg (www.nytimes.com)
  17. ^ immoral (www.jstor.org)
  18. ^ members in good standing in their political communities (www.nbr.co.nz)
  19. ^ ought to be ashamed (www.jstor.org)
  20. ^ Sign up for our weekly newsletter (theconversation.com)
  21. ^ Nuremberg Tribunals (nuremberg.law.harvard.edu)
  22. ^ aggressive war (www.law.ox.ac.uk)
  23. ^ ranging from 10 years in prison to a relatively quick death by hanging (www.history.com)
  24. ^ those who might have followed in their footsteps (www.nationalww2museum.org)
  25. ^ in the future (www.jstor.org)

Authors: Michael Blake, Professor of Philosophy, Public Policy and Governance, University of Washington

Read more https://theconversation.com/is-impeaching-president-trump-pointless-revenge-not-if-it-sends-a-message-to-future-presidents-153063

Metropolitan republishes selected articles from The Conversation USA with permission

Visit The Conversation to see more

Entertainment News

Gonna Tell You A Bit About Me & My Journey

There was a time that I didn’t like seeing myself in a mirror. I lacked confidence. I was shy. Then, I found modeling. When I first started modeling, being in front of the camera didn’t feel natural and I was nervous. Like most things – practice ...

Thorn Castillo - avatar Thorn Castillo

#1 Chart-Topping Band GREYE Comes Full Circle With “I Don’t Mind”

Six years after releasing their debut album Providence, Greye’s evolution from progressive Americana upstart to trailblazing indie rock powerhouse is complete. Pandemic and lockdown be damned, the well-traveled multi-generational Daytona Beach, F...

News Co - avatar News Co

AN INAUGURATION AND AMERICAN GREED’S SINGLE “TOGETHER” START AMERICA ON A PATH TOWARD'S HEALING

From COVID-19 To the Shocking Events of January 6, This Is Michael Mesey’s Song of Hope to A Weary Nation and World This Inauguration Day is a chance to turn the page from a difficult, divisive era and embrace a more hopeful spirit of unity m...

Michael Mesey - avatar Michael Mesey

EMODULARI Releases The Hard-Driving, Intensely Visceral “Craniotomy”

Caught up in the maelstrom of bad to worse news in the New York Times one morning, Eli Soiefer spotted an uplifting article offering respite from the crazy. It was a piece about an open-brain surgical procedure where they keep the patient awake t...

News Co - avatar News Co

AV SUPER SUNSHINE “Super Cool”

“Super Cool” is more than the name of rising international hitmaker AV Super Sunshine’s latest infectious 80’s techno inflected single. It’s the dizzying, freewheeling world he’s been living in these past months since the release of his previous ...

News Co - avatar News Co

Angela Predhomme - “Warmest Wish for You”

What could possibly help us heal from the exceptionally trying year of 2020? Singer-songwriter Angela Predhomme hopes that an inspiring new holiday song might give us a little solace. “Warmest Wish for You” is soul-tinged, feel-good song with a ...

News Co - avatar News Co

Metropolitan Business News

Do Directories Still Help SEO?

Directories were once one of the main staples of SEO and they were definitely in existence before search engines took over. Directories were once the main way that people navigated the world wide we...

News Co - avatar News Co

Shipping Container FAQs

If you are looking to rent or purchase a shipping container, you probably have a few questions. We have selected some of the most common questions and answered them here. We hope that you find this ...

News Co - avatar News Co

Is Duplicate Content an SEO Myth?

Any marketer you speak to about duplicate content is concerned about a “duplicate content penalty” but they are probably not very experienced with SEO. Google has specific guidelines on duplicate co...

News Co - avatar News Co

5 Key Factors To Starting A Website

Every business needs a website to be successful. However, this is a challenge for many due to the lack of coding and designing skills. The good news is, you do have a way around this—hire a deve...

News Co - avatar News Co

So You Want To Be A Project Manager? Here's What You Must Do

Project management is often a popular choice for people looking to make a mark in the organizations they work for. It's a great choice as well. If you hate monotony, love getting people and res...

News Co - avatar News Co

How to Deliver the Perfect Elevator Pitch

Do you struggle with explaining your career with professional or personal contacts, and you want to make a lasting impression? Whether you're looking for a job or building up your network, a wel...

Adam Jacobs - avatar Adam Jacobs

Writers Wanted


News Co Media Group

Content & Technology Connecting Global Audiences

More Information - Less Opinion