5 ways the Syrian revolution continues
- Written by Wendy Pearlman, Associate Professor of Political Science, Northwestern University
Bashar al-Assad has “won[1]” the war in Syria – or so many analysts tell us.
His regime has reconquered swaths of territory from rebel forces with starvation-and-surrender sieges, barrel bombs, chemical weapons and what one human rights investigator called “industrial scale[2]” torture and killing of detainees.
Still, the regime might have fallen had Russia[3] not stepped in and begun bombarding opposition strongholds in 2015.
In areas now under Assad’s grip, Syrians speak of exhaustion[4], forced complicity[5] with government rule and the return of the very walls of fear[6] and silence[7] that they sacrificed so much to tear down.
No one should underestimate the crushing toll of this violence or overestimate the capacity of any people to endure more than Syrians already have.
“We’re tired and we can’t bear any more blood. We’re afraid for Syria,” an activist told me. And that was in 2012.
But that does not mean that the struggle for freedom, dignity and justice that Syrians launched eight years ago is over.
Since 2012, I have interviewed[8] hundreds of displaced Syrians who championed the uprising. I have seen that their revolution persists wherever Syrians continue to believe in their capacity to make change.
Five realms of activism and resilience stand out.
1. Nurturing civil society
Forty years of dictatorships stifled independent civil society in Syria. But the years since 2011 have witnessed a flourishing of citizen-led activities in fields from education[9] to media[10] and the creative arts[11].
In Syrian towns where rebels forced the state to withdraw, communities labored to create local councils[12] through which people governed themselves. The regime subjected these experiments in civic participation to siege and bombardment[13], and then collapsed them in areas retaken by its troops.
In this 2012 photo, Syrian shopkeeper Yasser Mamaar speaks about working as a member of his town’s revolutionary council to distribute fuel, broker a truce with the army and win the release of dozens of locals kidnapped by armed groups.
AP/ Khalil Hamra[14]
Still, civic work continues inside and outside Syria. Citizens for Syria[15], itself a Syrian initiative, identifies hundreds of organizations and projects spearheaded by and for Syrians.
Among them are the Molham Volunteering Team[16] which, beginning as a group of students, is now an essential nonprofit provider of humanitarian relief. Women Now for Development[17] offers vocational training, literacy courses and small grants that have empowered hundreds of Syrian women.
Read more: How the Syrian uprising began and why it matters[18]
In these and other efforts, Syrians are demonstrating their will to build a democratic society from the bottom up, against enormous odds. This is a realm in which individual and state contributions can help.
For example, the Trump administration froze stabilization funds for Syria in 2018[19]. That forced to a halt at least 150 civil society organizations. Some laid-off staff had no choice[20] but to seek salaries with the only entities that offered them: armed factions, including those that the United States identified as terrorist groups.
2. Mobilizing for detainees
Syrians continue to take action on behalf of the more than 100,000 citizens who have become forcibly disappeared. Most of them were nonviolent civilians arrested arbitrarily by the government.
Copious documentation details the torture[21], death[22], rape[23] and sexual violence[24] synonymous with imprisonment in Syria, and even the suspected use of crematoriums[25] to dispose of prisoners executed en masse.
The members of Families for Freedom advocate for ‘freedom and justice for their loved ones who have been detained and forcibly disappeared by the Syrian regime and armed groups.’
Families for Freedom[26]
Defying despair, groups such as the Caesar Families Association[27] and the women-led Families for Freedom[28] demand release of information about detainees and humanitarian access to detention facilities. Their mobilization, from the streets of London[29] to the halls of U.N. and EU conferences[30], is keeping attention to this issue that has left few Syrian families untouched.
3. Ending impunity
Syrians are working for justice and accountability. Teams are amassing exhaustive evidence of atrocities[31], from photographs[32] of prisoners’ emaciated corpses to documents incriminating leaders by name[33].
Several European states are using the principle of universal jurisdiction[34] to investigate, prosecute and convict Syrian officials implicated in crimes against humanity.
In recent weeks, authorities arrested[35] three Syrian officers in Germany and France for torture constituting crimes against humanity. And Syrian refugees submitted dossiers of evidence against Assad to the International Criminal Court[36] in The Hague.
While state and international institutions have an important role to play, the real engine of the fight to end impunity in Syria is coming from Syrians[37] themselves.
4. Demanding oversight for reconstruction
Assad will need hundreds of billions of dollars[38] to rebuild the country that he played a large role in shattering.
Reports suggest that the Syrian government is already using reconstruction[39] as “war by other means[40].”
For example, the Law No. 10 of 2018[41] proposed to give citizens limited time to register proof of ownership with the Syrian state before it would confiscate properties for “redevelopment.” Other legislation enables the regime to transfer these and other expropriated assets to private companies run by regime cronies[42].
Some Syrians are working to make sure that the Assad regime’s plans for reconstructing devastated towns do not enrich loyalists and rob the properties of citizens forced to flee as refugees.
AP/Hassan Ammar[43]
Critics decry such “lawfare[44]” as a strategy to to control society and the economy[45], further dispossess[46] those forced to flee the country and enrich loyalists and foreign allies[47]. It might also serve as demographic engineering[48] that cleanses areas of some ethnic or religious groups and replaces them with others.
Syrian activists drawing attention to the dangerous politics of reconstruction call for transparency and accountability[49] that were missing in the realm of humanitarian relief.
Since 2011, for example, United Nations[50] aid programs in Syria awarded tens of millions of dollars in contracts to Assad family members and associates, thereby propping up the regime. In working against repetition of such oversight failures, Syrians continue the revolution’s fight against corruption and unfairness.
5. Building dignified lives
The approximately 5.6 million[51] refugees in countries on Syria’s borders continue to work to achieve their aspirations despite severe legal and economic precariousness[52].
Many lack minimal access to health care[53] and decent housing[54]. Some 40 percent of children[55] are not in school.
As war dies down in Syria, host states and international agencies increasingly discuss refugees’ return[56]. The small numbers who have gone back to Syria report that they did so because they could no longer endure the harshness[57] of life in neighboring states. Yet return is not a safe solution[58]; already some returnees have been disappeared[59] or killed upon arrival.
Displaced persons are eager to continue that most revolutionary act of building dignified lives, but they cannot do so unless states offer them a modicum of safety and opportunity.
Past and continuing atrocities in Syria will haunt history for generations to come. That Syrians retain any hope in a better future is not only a testament to their sheer will. It is also a sign, I believe, that the revolution they began eight years ago continues today.
Syria’s uprising did not happen in a vacuum. Read the first part of this series, “How the Syrian uprising began and why it matters,”[60] to hear the voices of Syrians describing the oppression that characterized their lives for decades, and how they mobilized against it.
References
- ^ won (www.wsj.com)
- ^ industrial scale (www.theguardian.com)
- ^ Russia (www.economist.com)
- ^ exhaustion (www.regthink.org)
- ^ forced complicity (www.synaps.network)
- ^ fear (syriadirect.org)
- ^ silence (www.aljumhuriya.net)
- ^ interviewed (www.harpercollins.com)
- ^ education (www.karamfoundation.org)
- ^ media (www.mei.edu)
- ^ creative arts (creativememory.org)
- ^ local councils (iwpr.net)
- ^ siege and bombardment (www.swp-berlin.org)
- ^ AP/ Khalil Hamra (www.apimages.com)
- ^ Citizens for Syria (citizensforsyria.org)
- ^ Molham Volunteering Team (molhamteam.com)
- ^ Women Now for Development (women-now.org)
- ^ How the Syrian uprising began and why it matters (theconversation.com)
- ^ Trump administration froze stabilization funds for Syria in 2018 (www.washingtonpost.com)
- ^ no choice (www.middleeasteye.net)
- ^ torture (saydnaya.amnesty.org)
- ^ death (www.amnesty.org)
- ^ rape (www.independent.co.uk)
- ^ sexual violence (www.washingtonpost.com)
- ^ crematoriums (www.nytimes.com)
- ^ Families for Freedom (syrianfamilies.org)
- ^ Caesar Families Association (syrianobserver.com)
- ^ Families for Freedom (syrianfamilies.org)
- ^ streets of London (www.theguardian.com)
- ^ U.N. and EU conferences (euobserver.com)
- ^ evidence of atrocities (www.newsdeeply.com)
- ^ photographs (www.hrw.org)
- ^ documents incriminating leaders by name (www.newyorker.com)
- ^ universal jurisdiction (www.lawfareblog.com)
- ^ arrested (www.nytimes.com)
- ^ International Criminal Court (www.theguardian.com)
- ^ Syrians (vdc-sy.net)
- ^ hundreds of billions of dollars (www.csmonitor.com)
- ^ reconstruction (syriauntold.com)
- ^ war by other means (www.washingtoninstitute.org)
- ^ Law No. 10 of 2018 (www.hrw.org)
- ^ cronies (cadmus.eui.eu)
- ^ AP/Hassan Ammar (www.apimages.com)
- ^ lawfare (syriauntold.com)
- ^ control society and the economy (www.brookings.edu)
- ^ dispossess (library.fes.de)
- ^ enrich loyalists and foreign allies (www.atlanticcouncil.org)
- ^ demographic engineering (www.middleeasteye.net)
- ^ transparency and accountability (www.washingtoninstitute.org)
- ^ United Nations (www.theguardian.com)
- ^ 5.6 million (data2.unhcr.org)
- ^ precariousness (theconversation.com)
- ^ lack minimal access to health care (www.brookings.edu)
- ^ decent housing (www.middleeasteye.net)
- ^ 40 percent of children (www.savethechildren.net)
- ^ refugees’ return (www.nrc.no)
- ^ no longer endure the harshness (www.newsdeeply.com)
- ^ return is not a safe solution (theconversation.com)
- ^ returnees have been disappeared (foreignpolicy.com)
- ^ “How the Syrian uprising began and why it matters,” (theconversation.com)
Authors: Wendy Pearlman, Associate Professor of Political Science, Northwestern University
Read more http://theconversation.com/5-ways-the-syrian-revolution-continues-112802
