The workhorse ship of ocean drilling may have made its last voyage – here’s why scientists don’t want to see the JOIDES Resolution mothballed

The JOIDES Resolution leaves Honolulu in 2009. IODP/Wikipedia, CC BY^[4][5]

Sadly, the JOIDES Resolution, also known as the JR, may have sailed for the last time. On Aug. 2, 2024, it docked in Amsterdam, with no clear path to raise the US$72 million per year that’s needed to operate the vessel. Most of this funding comes from the U.S. National Science Foundation, which announced in 2023 that it would not fund the JR beyond 2024^[6] because contributions from international partners were not keeping up with rising costs. Crews have started removing scientific equipment from the ship^[7].

The National Science Foundation says it will support ongoing research using existing core samples and work with scientists to plan the future of scientific ocean drilling. But for me and many other scientists, the cost of operating the JR pales compared with the damage caused by a single large earthquake – such as Japan’s 2011 Tohuku-Oki quake, estimated at $220 billion^[8] – or the trillions of dollars^[9] in damages resulting from climate change. Ocean core research helps scientists understand events like these so that societies can plan for the future.

Decades of ocean drilling have helped scientists understand the history and behavior of Antarctica’s ice sheets. Ice shelf loss is a major driver of global sea level rise.

A floating laboratory

No other vessel has the JR’s capabilities. The ship is 469 feet (143 meters) long^[10] – 50% longer than a football field. It has more than 5 miles (8 kilometers) of drill pipe^[11] that connects the ship to the seafloor and the layers beneath it, allowing it to raise core samples from the subsea to the ship.

The JR’s dynamic positioning system^[12] enables it to stay fixed exactly in one spot for days or weeks at a time. Just two other ships in the world have this capability: the Chikyu^[13], a larger vessel operated by Japan in Japanese waters, and a new Chinese drilling ship called the Mengxiang^[14].

I’ve spent eight two-month expeditions on the JOIDES Resolution, primarily at high latitudes near the poles exploring past climates. Each trip was staffed with about 60 scientists and technicians and 65 crew members. Once the ship left port, operations ran 24 hours per day, every day. We all worked 12-hour shifts.

These voyages could be grueling. Usually, though, the excitement of new and often unexpected discoveries, and camaraderie with fellow participants, made time speed by.

Technicians describe what it’s like to work with researchers on the JOIDES Resolution.

Insights from JR expeditions

As early as the 1960s, geologists began to understand that Earth’s continents and oceans were not static. Rather, they are part of moving plates^[15] within the Earth’s crust and upper mantle. Movement of the plates, especially where they collide with one another, creates earthquakes and volcanoes.

Marine sediment cores can penetrate a mile or more^[16] into the Earth’s crust. They provide the only opportunity to investigate continuous changes in tectonic plate interactions, study climate and marine evolution, and explore the limits of terrestrial life. Here are four areas where the details of these processes have begun to emerge:

Tectonic plate creation

Oceanic crust^[17] is fundamentally different^[18] from the crust that lies under the continents. When I first learned about it in the 1970s, the model for its formation and structure was simple:

– Lava rose from magma chambers beneath chains of seafloor volcanoes, known as ocean ridges.

– It poured out onto the seafloor, creating a dark, often glassy, volcanic rock called basalt.

– Within the deeper, slowly cooling magma chamber, crystalline minerals formed, creating rocks with a texture similar to granite.

– Over millions of years, this new crust moved away from the ridges, becoming cooler and denser.

But cores retrieved by the JOIDES Resolution, along with studies using underwater robots called submersibles^[19], revealed that this view was inaccurate. For example, they showed that seawater circulates through the crust, changing its composition and the chemistry of the seawater itself^[20].

Core studies also showed that Earth’s mantle – a foundation thought to lie deep below the surface – moves on giant, previously unknown fault zones and extends upward to the surface of the ocean crust^[21]. The mantle may provide clues to the origins of life^[22].

These insights changed scientists’ basic understanding of how our planet is structured.

This cross section shows the basic structure of Earth’s interior. Volcan26/Wikimedia, CC BY-SA^[23][24]

Climate records in ocean crust

My particular interest is in sediments that accumulate on the ocean crust. These deposits contain tiny microfossils of plankton, including organisms such as diatoms and coccolithophores^[25] that live on or near the ocean’s surface. As they photosynthesize^[26], they absorb carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and produce half of all the oxygen that we breathe.

Types of plankton vary with the temperature and chemistry of seawater. When they die and fall to the sea floor, they preserve an excellent record of past climates. Scientists use them to understand how Earth’s climate has warmed and cooled in the past^[27].

Another information source is sediments that fall out of melting icebergs. Glaciers pick up rocks as they flow over land. When they reach the sea, parts of them break off to become icebergs. The ice melts when it is exposed to warmer ocean water, and the rocks fall to the seafloor. These rock deposits in sediments^[28] are a record of past transitions between warm and cold climates.

Plate destruction and recycling

Most of the Pacific Ocean and some regions of the Atlantic Ocean lie over zones called convergent margins^[29], where tectonic plates crunch against each other. This process forces some ocean crust and sediment down into the Earth, where it melts and eventually is recycled into new crust, often as volcanoes.

Giant faults along these margins can create enormous earthquakes, such as the 2011 Tohoku-Oki earthquake^[30] off the eastern coast of Japan. Cores taken near such faults help scientists understand the forces^[31] that cause these events. They also create openings where instruments can be inserted to monitor for future earthquakes.

Cores recovered from convergent margin areas have also begun to reveal how volcanoes are created and how they modulate long-term climate change by producing carbon dioxide emissions^[32].

The limits of terrestrial life

In the late 1970s, exotic new forms of terrestrial life were discovered in the Pacific Ocean at zones where ocean crust formed. At plate boundaries, cold seawater percolated down through cracks in the crust. There, it was reheated by hot magma and jetted upward through openings that scientists named hydrothermal vents^[33].

The hot water contained minerals, which cooled when they touched cold seawater and hardened into chimneylike structures around the vents. Hundreds of life forms, including microbes, mussels and tube worms, colonized these structures^[34], thriving near zones of intense pressure and temperatures as hot as 248 degrees Fahrenheit (120 Celsius).

JR coring has subsequently revealed other life forms that survive deep in the subfloor of the ocean, in conditions of extreme oxygen and energy deprivation^[35]. Scientists know almost nothing about the diversity of these organisms, or the metabolic strategies they use to survive in their challenging environment. Understanding how they thrive could inform missions to other planets, such as Saturn’s moon Enceladus and Jupiter’s moon Europa, that have subsurface oceans that might support life^[36].

What next for scientific ocean drilling?

The National Science Foundation has created a committee^[37] to consider what capabilities a new drilling ship should have, and Congress may provide funding for additional JR expeditions^[38] in 2025. Given how much scientists still don’t know about Earth’s history, and the challenges humanity faces in adapting to climate change, I and my colleagues hope the JOIDES Resolution can still sail again, and that a new ship eventually will take up its mission.

Authors: Suzanne OConnell, Harold T. Stearns Professor of Earth Science, Wesleyan University

Read more https://theconversation.com/the-workhorse-ship-of-ocean-drilling-may-have-made-its-last-voyage-heres-why-scientists-dont-want-to-see-the-joides-resolution-mothballed-236548

• Prev
• Next