Reporting is not espionage – but history shows that journalists doing the former get accused of the latter

The detention of Wall Street Journal reporter^[1] Evan Gershkovich in Russia on espionage charges marks an unusual throwback to the old Soviet tactics for handling foreign correspondents.

Authorities in Vladimir Putin’s Russia have increasingly used criminal charges against their own journalists^[2] as part of a “increasing crackdown on free and independent media,” as Jodie Ginsberg, the president of the Committee to Protect Journalists, has put it^[3]. But prosecutions of international journalists in Russia are still rare enough.

Indeed, media historians like myself^[4] have to reach back decades to recall similar incidents. History shows that when they do occur, arrests of foreign journalists over espionage charges tend to provoke a diplomatic tempest.

Tinker, tailor, soldier, journalist?

Take, for example, the Prague “show trial^[5]” of Associated Press reporter William Oatis at the height of the Cold War in 1951. The prosecution of Oatis on spying charges was choreographed to suit the Soviet authorities, but the only real issue was that Oatis talked with Czechs and didn’t get government permission first.

“Reporting is not espionage,” The New York Times said in an editorial^[7] at the time. “[Oatis] was doing what all good newspaper men do in countries whose governments have not chosen to crawl back into the dark recesses of pre-historic barbarism.”

The case became a cause celebre^[8] from 1951 to 1953, and led to years of travel and trade embargoes between the U.S. and Czechoslovakia, which was then strictly controlled by the Soviet Union.

When Oatis was finally released in 1953, the journalist emerged weak and tubercular, describing his prison experience^[9] as akin to being “buried alive.” Still he carried on reporting, returning to the U.S. to cover the United Nations for decades before retiring.

Oatis’ case was perhaps the most famous during the Cold War, but it was far from the only one. Other American journalists who were arrested in Soviet sweeps of countries behind the Iron Curtain included Oatis’ fellow Associated Press reporters Leonard Kirschen – arrested in 1950 in Romania and held in jail for a decade^[10] – and Endre Marton^[11], who was arrested in Hungary in 1955 along with his wife, Ilona Marton^[12], who worked for United Press. They were released in 1956 and smuggled out of the country and into the U.S. the following year^[13]. Dozens of reporters from other agencies and other Western countries were also expelled from Eastern Europe around this time.

The risks of reporting

Of course, arrest wasn’t the only way to silence a reporter. Then – as now – there’s a risk of violence and death.

Dozens of journalists were killed around the world’s hot conflicts in every year of the Cold War. With the fall of the Soviet Union in the 1990s, attacks on journalists slowed down^[14]. Nonetheless, the global death toll since 1992 stands at over 2,190^[15], according to the Committee to Protect Journalists. And in nearly 8 out of 10 cases, the murderers go free. Of those deaths, at least 12 have involved journalists covering the war in Ukraine^[16], according to a March 2023 report by the human rights organization Council of Europe.

As part of its crackdown on free and independent media, Russia’s forces have been particularly hostile to journalists on the front lines of Ukraine, the Council of Europe report noted. Meanwhile, data from the Committee to Protect Journalists suggest an uptick in the number of Russian journalists being held behind bars. Of the 19 currently imprisoned, half were picked up by authorities^[17] after the invasion of Ukraine.

Journalists working in hostile nations or in war zones do so knowing the risk that death or imprisonment may be used as diplomatic leverage or as a warning to other journalists. It is part of the job.

Cover stories

Yet not all reporters or editors are innocent observers. It is true that over the years, American journalists have indeed worked with, or even for, the U.S. government or intelligence services. Several hundred, at least, worked closely with the CIA and other intelligence agencies during World War II and through the course of the Cold War, according to evidence that emerged during the Watergate era^[18].

For many, the collaboration had laudable aims. American journalist Virginia Hall^[19] used her credentials as a New York Post reporter to help the French resistance in World War II, guiding downed Allied airmen to safety in neutral countries and arranging weapons drops.

Her story was told in the book^[21] “A Woman of No Importance.” The Norwegian journalist Erling Espeland^[22] did similar work in World War II.

In some cases, like that of The New York Times’ Donald A. Allan^[23], American journalists transitioned from World War II reporting into work for intelligence agencies with relative ease. Allan quit the New York Times in 1952 and supposedly went to work for CBS and United Press. But later, he said that was nothing more than a cover^[24] for his work with the CIA.

In 1975, the U.S. and Russia signed the Helsinki Final Act^[25], starting a process of detente and trade normalization, including guarantees of press freedom. Still, Western journalists were routinely harassed and detained in the Cold War Soviet Union. In a case that resonates with that of Gershkovich’s, in 1986 Nicholas Daniloff, the Moscow correspondent for U.S. News & World Report, was arrested and detained^[26] on charges of espionage. He was later allowed to leave the Soviet Union.

A totalitarian tool

Most journalists today would reject the practice of being entangled with the work of the intelligence services. In 1996, Society of Professional Journalists President G. Kelly Hawes rejected the use of American journalism^[27] as a cover for intelligence.

“The public shouldn’t have to fear speaking to the press, and journalists shouldn’t have to fear for their safety,” she said. “Our integrity is compromised and our lives are endangered. That is wrong.” And to be clear, Gershkovich and The Wall Street Journal have denied the espionage claims^[28].

But to officials in an authoritarian government like that of Russia, journalists are not much different from spies. It is, after all, a reporter’s job to uncover uncomfortable truths, often hidden from the wider world.

Seen in that light, slapping a charge of espionage on a journalist is one of the more Orwellian tools in the authoritarian playbook.

References

1. ^{^} detention of Wall Street Journal reporter (www.cnn.com)
2. ^{^} charges against their own journalists (ipi.media)
3. ^{^} has put it (autos.yahoo.com)
4. ^{^} like myself (scholar.google.com)
5. ^{^} Prague “show trial (www.washingtonpost.com)
6. ^{^} AP Photo (newsroom.ap.org)
7. ^{^} said in an editorial (www.nytimes.com)
8. ^{^} became a cause celebre (doi.org)
9. ^{^} describing his prison experience (www.nytimes.com)
10. ^{^} held in jail for a decade (www.nytimes.com)
11. ^{^} Endre Marton (www.nytimes.com)
12. ^{^} Ilona Marton (www.nytimes.com)
13. ^{^} into the U.S. the following year (www.nytimes.com)
14. ^{^} attacks on journalists slowed down (cpj.org)
15. ^{^} stands at over 2,190 (cpj.org)
16. ^{^} journalists covering the war in Ukraine (cpj.org)
17. ^{^} half were picked up by authorities (cpj.org)
18. ^{^} evidence that emerged during the Watergate era (www.carlbernstein.com)
19. ^{^} journalist Virginia Hall (www.npr.org)
20. ^{^} Apic/Getty Images (www.gettyimages.com)
21. ^{^} told in the book (www.penguinrandomhouse.com)
22. ^{^} Norwegian journalist Erling Espeland (journalistandspy.substack.com)
23. ^{^} New York Times’ Donald A. Allan (journalistandspy.substack.com)
24. ^{^} nothing more than a cover (www.nytimes.com)
25. ^{^} signed the Helsinki Final Act (history.state.gov)
26. ^{^} arrested and detained (www.usnews.com)
27. ^{^} rejected the use of American journalism (www.spj.org)
28. ^{^} denied the espionage claims (www.nytimes.com)