Smith College incident is latest case of racial 'profiling by proxy'

Smith College has opened an investigation into a July 31 incident in which a staff employee called campus police on a black student who supposedly “seemed to be out of place.”^[1][2]

It turns out the student, Oumou Kanoute^[3], who had a summer job with the college, was simply eating lunch^[4] in a common area.

This incident did not happen in isolation. It is just the latest in a string of cases referred to^[5] as profiling by proxy^[6] – instances where police are summoned to a situation by a biased caller.

We make this observation as researchers^[7] with a keen interest in how race comes into play^[8] during day-to-day interactions with police both in and outside of college campuses.

Outsiders on campus

College campuses are often thought of as safe spaces^[9] and commonly regarded as forward-thinking environments. However, as the Smith College incident and other events demonstrate, merely being a student or even a faculty member does not always equate to acceptance and inclusion, particularly if the student or professor is a member of a minority group on campus.

Consider, for instance, two recent incidents on college campuses that involved racial profiling by proxy^[10]. One incident took place in Colorado on the campus of Colorado State University earlier this year during a campus visit and tour. Two prospective students, who were Native American males, were accused of acting “odd” due to their quiet disposition and clothing by a parent of another student on the campus tour. Due to her heightened suspicions, she called the police^[11] on the two teens. The other incident took place in Connecticut earlier this year on the campus of Yale University. In this instance, a white student called the police^[12] on a black female graduate student who took a nap while writing a paper in their dorm’s common room.

All of these cases serve to show how racial micro- and macro-aggressions^[13] aren’t limited to neighborhoods^[14]. They surface on college and university campuses as well. These recent incidents come not even two years after the hashtag #BlackOnCampus^[15] flooded Twitter, exposing the daily occurrences of racism experienced by black students and leading to protests focused on race relations on over 50 college campuses^[16].

Campuses have often been described as “microcosms of society,”^[17] so these incidents send a troubling message that the racist attitudes and behaviors that were part and parcel of American history endure in the present. They also highlight the need to move beyond policies addressing the legal restrictions that historically limited access to spaces and places to certain racial groups. Moving beyond this negative aspect of our nation’s past requires a shift in the current discussion from one that focuses on law enforcement and campus safety towards one in which we candidly discuss shared historical fallacies about the much-maligned “other.” This unpacking necessitates an understanding of how we, as a society, got to where we are today.

The myth of black criminality

From a historical perspective, American society was based on social constructions of race, ethnicity, gender and other identities. As a result, an American narrative^[18] that defined being different from the majority as deviant^[19] became embedded within the framework of American society, as well as the nation’s legal system.

One example of this that appeared after the Civil War was the enactment of the black codes^[20], which greatly restricted blacks’ labor and movement. The different-as-deviant narrative still affects American society to this day. Public policies and governmental actions have often reinforced these notions of “otherness” by marginalizing those who are considered undeserving and uncapable^[21].

Human beings have often been described as having an affinity for myths^[23]. One myth that continues to permeate society is known as Black Crimmythology^[24] – or the myth that conflates blackness or otherness with criminality.

Black Crimmythology, as the converging legacy of the social construction of race^[25] and the stigma^[26] that accompanies it, continues to blemish our society. As such, it has a constraining limiting effect that impacts a person’s meaning, destiny and value – all based upon their physical appearance.

Political constructions are public policies that were created to reinforce the social construction of Black Crimmythology. Public policies – both before and after the Civil War – limited the spaces and places to which blacks and other people of color had access, with criminalizing effects. Implementing Black Crimmythology and the policies that legally reinforced it required the assistance of public servants – that is, law enforcement officers – and the support of white citizens who made up the dominant class.

The incidents at Smith College, Colorado State University^[27] and Yale University^[28] highlight how all these things – race or Black Crimmythology, practices of contemporary police officers and “support” from members of the dominant racial group – resulted in a negative interaction or encounter. The police were called to address each caller’s implicit or explicit bias or prejudiced anxieties. These incidents reflect the lasting nature of the old narrative of defining one who is different as deviant, even during what some have described as our post-racial^[29] or post-black^[30] society.

Toward ‘brave’ spaces

In order to make progress and lessen the potential for negative encounters between members of minority groups and campus police, society must be willing to enter into brave spaces^[31] – that is, spaces where people find the courage to risk engaging in uncomfortable and unsettling dialogue around issues of race and racism.

This effort requires more than just acknowledging the pain of others, but actually acting upon it.

One tool that can help in this regard is the Handy Guide for Objective Threat Evaluation developed by Hobart Taylor and utilized by the University of California-Irvine Police Department. This tool asks that prior to calling the police, members of the public should ask themselves a series of questions: Does someone seem suspicious because of something that they are doing? Does someone seem suspicious because of how they are behaving? Or, is it because of their appearance? If it is because of their appearance and not because of their behavior, the assessment advises not to call.

This tool was created to help the public identify when situations and incidents necessitate calling the police. If the callers at Smith College, Colorado State and Yale would have followed this guide, officers never would have been summoned in the first place.

Editor’s Note: This is an updated version of an article^[32] originally published on July 16, 2018.

References

1. ^{^} opened an investigation (www.boston.com)
2. ^{^} “seemed to be out of place.” (www.boston.com)
3. ^{^} Oumou Kanoute (www.boston.com)
4. ^{^} simply eating lunch (www.boston.com)
5. ^{^} referred to (theconversation.com)
6. ^{^} profiling by proxy (www.vera.org)
7. ^{^} researchers (scholar.google.com)
8. ^{^} keen interest in how race comes into play (scholar.google.com)
9. ^{^} safe spaces (www.jstor.org)
10. ^{^} profiling by proxy (www.vera.org)
11. ^{^} called the police (www.coloradoan.com)
12. ^{^} called the police (www.cnn.com)
13. ^{^} macro-aggressions (nyupress.org)
14. ^{^} neighborhoods (journals.sagepub.com)
15. ^{^} #BlackOnCampus (www.washingtonpost.com)
16. ^{^} over 50 college campuses (fivethirtyeight.com)
17. ^{^} “microcosms of society,” (onlinelibrary.wiley.com)
18. ^{^} American narrative (books.google.com)
19. ^{^} deviant (leeclarke.com)
20. ^{^} black codes (www.history.com)
21. ^{^} undeserving and uncapable (www.sunypress.edu)
22. ^{^} Everett Historical/www.shutterstock.com (www.shutterstock.com)
23. ^{^} myths (onlinelibrary.wiley.com)
24. ^{^} Black Crimmythology (digitalscholarship.tsu.edu)
25. ^{^} social construction of race (www.hup.harvard.edu)
26. ^{^} stigma (www.simonandschuster.com)
27. ^{^} Colorado State University (www.coloradoan.com)
28. ^{^} Yale University (www.cnn.com)
29. ^{^} post-racial (diverseeducation.com)
30. ^{^} post-black (www.greenlightbookstore.com)
31. ^{^} brave spaces (www.semanticscholar.org)
32. ^{^} article (theconversation.com)