EU plans to set up a new court to prosecute Russia's war on Ukraine – but there's a mixed record on holding leaders like Putin accountable for waging wars
- Written by Victor Peskin, Associate professor of politics and global studies, Arizona State University
A senior European Union official announced[1] on Nov. 30, 2022, that the EU will work with the United Nations in the hopes of setting up a special court that would investigate and prosecute Russian President Vladimir Putin and other Russian leaders for the crime of aggression in Ukraine.
The crime of aggression[2] punishes the illegal invasion or use of force against another country. It is a bedrock principle of the United Nations Charter[3] and post-World War II international relations.
It is not clear when or even whether the United States government will back the EU proposal made by European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen. Washington has viewed the idea of a special court for aggression warily – there is concern this could establish a legal precedent that then ensnares American leaders if the U.S. itself invades another sovereign country, as it did in Iraq in 2003.
Since Russia first invaded Ukraine in February 2022, there has been public skepticism[4] that Putin could ever be held accountable for alleged crimes in Ukraine.
History provides some lessons on charging political leaders with war crimes – a legal term[5] that includes attacking and killing civilians during war.
But as a scholar of human rights[6], conflict and international courts, I think it is important to understand that there has been a mixed record of arresting and prosecuting senior political and military leaders allegedly responsible for atrocities.
The international trial of Serbian leader Slobodan Misolevic[7] in the mid-2000s is one example of how international courts can prosecute war criminals.
Here’s the bottom line: It’s only when leaders like Milosevic fall from power that there is any chance that their governments may arrest and hand them over to international courts for prosecution.
But history also shows that even if Putin is overthrown or otherwise loses power, there’s no clear guarantee that he will ever stand trial before an international court.
Milosevic’s fall from power
There were three major wars in southeastern Europe in the 1990s. In total, approximately 130,000 people died[9] during the wars in Croatia, Bosnia and Kosovo. The rise of nationalism and tension between different ethnic groups triggered these conflicts.
The spark for these wars was kindled in 1991, when Yugoslavia, a former communist republic that once included Bosnia and Herzegovina, Croatia, Macedonia, Montenegro, Serbia and Slovenia, began to split apart[10].
Milosevic, a Serbian nationalist leader, was one of the most influential politicians in the region. He fueled the regional wars around and after the time of this dissolution.
In 1993, as the war in Bosnia was still being fought, the United Nations Security Council set up a special court, called the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia[11], to address crimes committed during the wars there.
This court indicted Milosevic for war crimes and crimes against humanity in 1999 during the the ongoing Kosovo war. Milosevic’s alleged crimes in Kosovo included a massive ethnic cleansing campaign waged against Kosovar Albanians, the largest ethnic group there. Most of the people who died during this war were Kosovar Albanians.
But Milosevic was still in power when the indictment was issued, and the Serbian government shielded him from arrest.
Milosevic lost a presidential election in late September 2000 but initially refused to give up power. After widespread protests, Milosevic stepped down[12] a week later, and a democratic government took over.
Milosevic standing trial
Almost two years later, Serbian police arrested Milosevic[13], though on domestic corruption and abuse of power charges.
The Serbian government[14] transferred Milosevic to the international tribunal[15] in June 2001.
This happened in the wake of U.S. threats to withhold much-needed loans to Serbia unless the government turned over Milosevic. Serbia later also arrested other former leaders wanted for war crimes – following intense Western political pressure and assurances by European countries and the U.S. that the government’s cooperation[16] could result in Serbia’s gaining European Union membership.
The international tribunal launched its trial[17] in The Hague, Netherlands, against Milosevic in February 2002. Milosevic faced dozens of charges for alleged crimes he committed in three different wars.
But Milosevic died in prison[18] in 2006, shortly before the end of his trial.
The challenge for international courts
International courts set up by the U.N., like the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia, have a twofold problem. First, these tribunals do not have an actual international police force to carry out arrests.
Governments implicated in their leaders’ alleged crimes also often try to obstruct international courts by not turning over suspects.
The enforcement problem, as my scholarship has shown[19], can allow a powerful country like Russia to evade arrest warrants from international courts – as long as the suspect remains within the country.
The International Criminal Court, for example, has not been able to persuade the Sudanese government to hand over former president Omar al-Bashir for alleged war crimes committed in Darfur in the 2000s.
A potential playbook for Putin
Milosevic escaped a final verdict and potential prison time with his death.
But his trial still shows that under specific circumstances, international courts can overcome their lack of enforcement powers and bring high-level suspects to trial. International political pressure and incentives often serve a role in this process.
Ukraine, meanwhile, has already convicted and sentenced[21] several Russian soldiers for war crimes during the ongoing Ukraine conflict, and, as of the beginning of August 2022, has charged 135 other Russian suspects[22].
The Ukrainian government has also pushed for the creation of a specialized court – which has now received European Union backing – to prosecute Putin and other Russian leaders for the illegal invasion of Ukraine. Beth Van Schaack, the United States’ ambassador-at-large for global criminal justice, said in November 2022[23] that the crime of aggression is the “original sin that unleashed all of the war crimes” happening in Ukraine. These include Russia’s ongoing indiscriminate bombing of Ukrainian cities[24] and atrocities against[25] Ukrainian citizens, including execution and torture.
While the International Criminal Court is investigating Russian war crimes in Ukraine, this Hague-based court does not have the jurisdiction to prosecute Russian leaders for the crime of aggression. This is partially because Russia has never joined the International Criminal Court.
As long as Putin remains in power, it is unlikely that any amount of political pressure or promises will persuade Russia to cooperate with an international court and turn over Putin, if he is indicted.
That could change if Putin ever falls from power.
But much would still depend on the new Russian government and whether Western countries would provide the type of incentives that pushed Serbian leaders to turn against their former political leaders and military heroes.
This is an updated version of an article originally published on June 15, 2022[26].
References
- ^ European Union official announced (www.reuters.com)
- ^ crime of aggression (theconversation.com)
- ^ United Nations Charter (www.un.org)
- ^ public skepticism (foreignpolicy.com)
- ^ legal term (www.un.org)
- ^ scholar of human rights (isearch.asu.edu)
- ^ international trial of Serbian leader Slobodan Misolevic (academic.oup.com)
- ^ Raphael Gaillarde/Gamma-Rapho via Getty Images (www.gettyimages.com)
- ^ 130,000 people died (www.rferl.org)
- ^ split apart (history.state.gov)
- ^ International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia (www.icty.org)
- ^ stepped down (nvdatabase.swarthmore.edu)
- ^ arrested Milosevic (www.nytimes.com)
- ^ Serbian government (www.washingtonpost.com)
- ^ Milosevic to the international tribunal (www.icty.org)
- ^ the government’s cooperation (academic.oup.com)
- ^ launched its trial (www.icty.org)
- ^ died in prison (www.theguardian.com)
- ^ as my scholarship has shown (www.cambridge.org)
- ^ Fadel Senna/AFP via Getty Images (media.gettyimages.com)
- ^ convicted and sentenced (www.washingtonpost.com)
- ^ other Russian suspects (www.reuters.com)
- ^ said in November 2022 (www.state.gov)
- ^ bombing of Ukrainian cities (www.usip.org)
- ^ atrocities against (www.defense.gov)
- ^ article originally published on June 15, 2022 (theconversation.com)
Authors: Victor Peskin, Associate professor of politics and global studies, Arizona State University
