American gun culture is based on frontier mythology – but ignores how common gun restrictions were in the Old West
- Written by Pierre M. Atlas, Senior Lecturer, Paul H. O'Neill School of Public and Environmental Affairs, Indiana University
In the wake of the Buffalo and Uvalde mass shootings, 70% of Republicans[1] said it is more important to protect gun rights than to control gun violence, while 92% of Democrats and 54% of independents expressed the opposite view. Just weeks after those mass shootings, Republicans and gun rights advocates hailed[2] the Supreme Court ruling that invalidated New York state’s gun permit law and declared that the Second Amendment guarantees a right to carry a handgun outside the home[3] for self-defense.
Mayor Eric Adams, expressing his opposition to the ruling, suggested that the court’s decision would turn New York City into the “Wild West[4].” Contrary to the imagery of the Wild West, however, many towns in the real Old West had restrictions on the carrying of guns[5] that were, I would suggest, stricter than the one just invalidated by the Supreme Court.
Support for gun rights among Republicans played an important role in determining the contents of the the bipartisan Safer Communities Act[6], the first new gun reform bill in three decades. President Joe Biden signed it into law just two days after the Supreme Court’s decision was released. In order to attract Republican support, the new law[7] does not include gun control proposals such as an assault weapons ban, universal background checks or raising the purchasing age to 21 for certain types of rifles. Nevertheless, the bill was denounced by other Republicans in Congress[8] and was opposed by the National Rifle Association[9].
I have found that for those Americans who see the gun as both symbolizing and guaranteeing individual liberty, gun control laws are perceived as fundamentally un-American and a threat to their freedom. For the most ardent gun rights advocates, gun violence[10] – as horrible as it is[11] – is an acceptable price of that freedom[12].
My analysis finds that gun culture in the U.S. derives largely from its frontier past[13] and the mythology of the “Wild West,”[14] which romanticizes guns, outlaws, rugged individualism[15] and the inevitability of gun violence. This culture ignores the fact that gun control was widespread and common in the Old West.
The prevalence of guns
Guns are part of a deep political divide in American society. The more guns a person owns, the more likely they are to oppose gun control legislation[17], and the more likely they are to vote for Republican candidates.
In 2020, 44% of American households[18] reported owning at least one firearm. According to the 2018 international study Small Arms Survey[19], there were approximately 393 million firearms in civilian hands in the U.S., or 120.5 firearms per 100 people. That number is likely higher now, given increases in gun sales in 2019, 2020 and 2021[20].
Americans have owned guns since colonial times, but American gun culture really took off after the Civil War with the imagery, icons and tales – or mythology – of the lawless frontier and the Wild West. Frontier mythology, which celebrates and exaggerates the amount and significance of gunfights and vigilantism[21], began with 19th-century Western paintings[22], popular dime novels and traveling Wild West shows[23] by Buffalo Bill Cody and others. It continues to this day with Western-themed shows on streaming networks such as “Yellowstone[24]” and “Walker[25].”
A gunfight in the TV show ‘Yellowstone.’A marketing move
Historian Pamela Haag attributes much of the country’s gun culture to that Western theme. Before the middle of the 19th century, she writes, guns were common in U.S. society, but were unremarkable tools[26] used by a wide range of people in a growing nation.
But then gun manufacturers Colt and Winchester started marketing their firearms by appealing to customers’ sense of adventure and the romance of the frontier. In the mid-19th century, the gun manufacturers began advertising their guns[27] as a way people all around the country could connect with the excitement of the West, with its Indian wars, cattle drives, cowboys and gold and silver boomtowns. Winchester’s slogan was “The Gun That Won the West[28],” but Haag argues that it was really “the West that won the gun.”
By 1878, this theme was so successful that Colt’s New York City distributor recommended the company market the .44-40 caliber version of its Model 1873 single-action revolver as the “Frontier Six Shooter” to appeal to the public’s growing fascination[29] with the Wild West.
Colt’s Frontier Six Shooter was marketed to take advantage of people’s romantic ideas of the Wild West.
Cabelas[30]
A different reality
Gun ownership was commonplace in the post-Civil War Old West, but actual gunfights were rare. One reason was that, contrary to the mythology, many frontier towns had strict gun laws[31], especially against carrying concealed weapons[32].
As UCLA constitutional law professor Adam Winkler puts it[33], “Guns were widespread on the frontier, but so was gun regulation. … Wild West lawmen took gun control seriously and frequently arrested people who violated their town’s gun control laws.”
“Gunsmoke[34],” the iconic TV show that ran from the 1950s through the 1970s, would have seen far fewer gunfights[35] had its fictional marshal, Matt Dillon, enforced Dodge City’s real laws banning the carrying of any firearms[36] within city limits.
The appeal of this mythology extends to the present day. In August 2021, a Colt Frontier Six Shooter became the world’s most expensive firearm when the auction house Bonhams sold “the gun that killed Billy the Kid” at auction for over $6 million[37]. As a mere antique firearm, that revolver would be worth a few thousand dollars[38]. Its astronomic selling price was due to its Wild West provenance.
The historical reality of the American frontier was more complex and nuanced than its popular mythology. But it’s the mythology that fuels American gun culture today, which rejects the types of laws that were commonplace in the Old West.
A particular view of safety and freedom
Hardcore gun owners, their lobbyists and many members of the Republican Party refuse to allow[39] the thousands of annual gun deaths[40] and the additional thousands of nonfatal shootings[41] to be used as justifications for restricting their rights[42] as law-abiding citizens.
They are willing to accept gun violence as an inevitable side effect of a free and armed but violent society.
Their opposition to new gun reforms as well as the current trends in gun rights legislation – such as permitless carry[43] and the arming of teachers[44] – are but the latest manifestations of American gun culture’s deep roots in frontier mythology.
Wayne LaPierre[45], executive director of the National Rifle Association, the country’s largest gun rights group, tapped into imagery from frontier mythology and American gun culture following the Sandy Hook massacre in 2012. In his call to arm school resource officers and teachers, LaPierre adopted language that could have come from a classic Western film: “The only thing that stops a bad guy with a gun[46] is a good guy with a gun.”
This view of a lone, armed person[47] who can stand up and save the day has persisted ever since[48], and provides an answer of its own to mass shootings: Guns are not the problem – they’re the solution.
References
- ^ 70% of Republicans (www.npr.org)
- ^ gun rights advocates hailed (www.cbsnews.com)
- ^ Second Amendment guarantees a right to carry a handgun outside the home (www.oyez.org)
- ^ Wild West (www.bloomberg.com)
- ^ restrictions on the carrying of guns (www.smithsonianmag.com)
- ^ the bipartisan Safer Communities Act (www.npr.org)
- ^ new law (www.congress.gov)
- ^ denounced by other Republicans in Congress (www.cnn.com)
- ^ opposed by the National Rifle Association (www.nraila.org)
- ^ gun violence (hub.jhu.edu)
- ^ as horrible as it is (www.gunviolencearchive.org)
- ^ acceptable price of that freedom (www.thepriceoffreedommovie.com)
- ^ from its frontier past (doi.org)
- ^ mythology of the “Wild West,” (www.oupress.com)
- ^ romanticizes guns, outlaws, rugged individualism (utpress.utexas.edu)
- ^ Ben Wittick via Kansas Historical Society (www.kshs.org)
- ^ oppose gun control legislation (global.oup.com)
- ^ 44% of American households (news.gallup.com)
- ^ Small Arms Survey (www.smallarmssurvey.org)
- ^ increases in gun sales in 2019, 2020 and 2021 (www.theguardian.com)
- ^ celebrates and exaggerates the amount and significance of gunfights and vigilantism (doi.org)
- ^ 19th-century Western paintings (truewestmagazine.com)
- ^ traveling Wild West shows (centerofthewest.org)
- ^ Yellowstone (www.imdb.com)
- ^ Walker (www.imdb.com)
- ^ unremarkable tools (www.basicbooks.com)
- ^ began advertising their guns (www.basicbooks.com)
- ^ The Gun That Won the West (www.grunge.com)
- ^ appeal to the public’s growing fascination (www.nxtbook.com)
- ^ Cabelas (www.cabelas.com)
- ^ many frontier towns had strict gun laws (global.oup.com)
- ^ against carrying concealed weapons (www.smithsonianmag.com)
- ^ As UCLA constitutional law professor Adam Winkler puts it (wwnorton.com)
- ^ Gunsmoke (www.imdb.com)
- ^ far fewer gunfights (www.historynet.com)
- ^ real laws banning the carrying of any firearms (www.nytimes.com)
- ^ Bonhams sold “the gun that killed Billy the Kid” at auction for over $6 million (www.bonhams.com)
- ^ few thousand dollars (truegunvalue.com)
- ^ refuse to allow (apnews.com)
- ^ thousands of annual gun deaths (www.pewresearch.org)
- ^ thousands of nonfatal shootings (doi.org)
- ^ restricting their rights (www.nytimes.com)
- ^ permitless carry (www.politifact.com)
- ^ arming of teachers (www.k12dive.com)
- ^ Wayne LaPierre (www.nbcnews.com)
- ^ The only thing that stops a bad guy with a gun (www.npr.org)
- ^ lone, armed person (www.pbs.org)
- ^ persisted ever since (www.vox.com)
Authors: Pierre M. Atlas, Senior Lecturer, Paul H. O'Neill School of Public and Environmental Affairs, Indiana University
