Domestic violence 911 calls increased during lockdown, but official police reports and arrests declined
- Written by Jillian B. Carr, Assistant Professor of Economics, Purdue University
COVID-19 stay-at-home orders surely saved many lives[1], but a growing number of studies document that lockdowns led to more reports of domestic violence[2].
Even as 911 calls for police help increased, official reports and arrests for domestic crimes fell by 6.8% and 26.4%[3], respectively, in the first two months of lockdown in Chicago.
I study the economics of crime and poverty[4]. My colleagues, Lindsey Rose Bullinger[5] of Georgia Institute of Technology and Analisa Packham[6] of Vanderbilt University and the National Bureau of Economic Research, and I found this puzzling. How could 911 calls reporting domestic incidents increase without an accompanying increase in police reports of domestic violence?
Our research suggests that this discrepancy is due to pandemic-related changes in how third-party witnesses, law enforcement and victims respond to domestic violence. These changes, compounded by strained social services, have led to a systemic failure to protect victims of domestic abuse.
Witnesses are calling more
Third-party witnesses play an important role in reporting crime[7]. Even if the same number of crimes occur, changing reporting volumes could artificially inflate or deflate crime rates. For example, child maltreatment allegations in March and April 2020 were 27% lower than expected[8] in Florida because schools, where teachers and staff are mandatory reporters[9] of child abuse, were closed due to COVID-19. At the same time, reports of child abuse and neglect that did come in were more likely to be confirmed with evidence[10] in areas with greater stay-at-home compliance.
Domestic violence is an ongoing pandemic that has been exacerbated by COVID-19 lockdowns.A similar trend can be seen with domestic violence reporting. Prior to the pandemic, domestic violence victims were twice as likely[11] to report abuse to police compared to witnesses. Since lockdown, however, third-party reporting has increased while victim reporting decreased. One study found third-party domestic abuse reporting went up[12] by 35% in Greater London. Other studies suggest that victim-reporting declined because victims were spending most of their time at home with their abusers[13], making it harder for them to call for help.
Third-party reporting rates were also higher for residents of higher-density housing, like apartments and townhouses. In residences where neighbors are nearby, stay-at-home orders increased the number of witnesses in close proximity to domestic disturbances. This is reflected by the 10.3% increase[14] in 911 calls made from areas in Chicago with more renters, compared to the 7.4% call increase for the city overall. Neighbors who would have otherwise been at work, restaurants and gyms were now more likely to be at home and within earshot of abuse behavior.
Law enforcement are arresting less
Not all 911 calls related to domestic violence lead to an official crime report. In our domestic violence data, the number of official reports is around one-fourth the number of 911 calls.
Compared to before the pandemic, there was an estimated 11.2% decline[15] in this ratio of domestic incidence-related crime reports to 911 calls for police service from March to April in Chicago. This meant that 600 fewer domestic crimes[16] were officially documented by law enforcement than would have been expected over a five-week period.
Changes to how police interact with citizens may explain this decline. In the early days of the pandemic, officers were told to limit their contact[17] with residents in nonemergency situations in order to minimize their own exposure to the virus. This may have led to reduced law enforcement response to domestic disturbances deemed less serious by police officers. While officers still responded to all 911 calls related to domestic issues, they may have not pursued official action if the situation had already defused before their arrival.
Victims are facing new obstacles
Victims had fewer options for escaping abusive situations during the pandemic.
Fear of COVID-19 exposure may have made victims less likely to file an official domestic violence report. Given that the Chicago Cook County Jail experienced a COVID-19 outbreak in late March and April[18], victims may have wanted to avoid getting their partner arrested. Furthermore, because many defendants are released before they are tried[19] and not all arrestees will face charges, jail stays are often short-term. Individuals cycling in and out of Cook County Jail have been linked to accelerating the spread of COVID-19 in Chicago[20].
The pandemic also put the squeeze on personal and public resources across the board. Not only did women lose jobs at a higher rate[21] than men during the pandemic, they also make up the majority of domestic abuse victims[22]. Many shelters had to operate at limited capacity while demand for their services increased[23]. This loss of financial and housing support may have made victims less confident that they could successfully leave an abusive household.
Better protections are needed for victims
Our research shows that stay-at-home orders have disrupted traditional abuse-detection processes and support systems in multiple ways. A real increase in domestic violence[24] indicates that this disruption occurred at a particularly damaging time. Better measures need to be put in place in order to protect victims during future outbreaks and keep everyone safe during lockdowns.
[Understand new developments in science, health and technology, each week. Subscribe to The Conversation’s science newsletter[25].]
References
- ^ saved many lives (www.healthaffairs.org)
- ^ lockdowns led to more reports of domestic violence (doi.org)
- ^ fell by 6.8% and 26.4% (doi.org)
- ^ I study the economics of crime and poverty (scholar.google.com)
- ^ Lindsey Rose Bullinger (scholar.google.com)
- ^ Analisa Packham (scholar.google.ca)
- ^ reporting crime (doi.org)
- ^ 27% lower than expected (doi.org)
- ^ mandatory reporters (www.childwelfare.gov)
- ^ confirmed with evidence (dx.doi.org)
- ^ twice as likely (doi.org)
- ^ third-party domestic abuse reporting went up (econpapers.repec.org)
- ^ at home with their abusers (dx.doi.org)
- ^ 10.3% increase (doi.org)
- ^ 11.2% decline (doi.org)
- ^ 600 fewer domestic crimes (doi.org)
- ^ limit their contact (www.npr.org)
- ^ COVID-19 outbreak in late March and April (doi.org)
- ^ released before they are tried (www.doi.org)
- ^ accelerating the spread of COVID-19 in Chicago (doi.org)
- ^ lose jobs at a higher rate (www.doi.org)
- ^ majority of domestic abuse victims (icjia.illinois.gov)
- ^ operate at limited capacity while demand for their services increased (blockclubchicago.org)
- ^ real increase in domestic violence (doi.org)
- ^ Subscribe to The Conversation’s science newsletter (theconversation.com)
Authors: Jillian B. Carr, Assistant Professor of Economics, Purdue University
