Unequal treatment for college women's basketball players has deep historical roots
- Written by Lindsey Darvin, Assistant Professor of Sport Management, State University of New York College at Cortland
When college women basketball players began to post photos[1] and videos[2] of how they got less food[3], less accurate COVID-19 testing[4] and less exercise equipment[5] in the NCAA March Madness Tournament bubbles[6] than their male counterparts, a sense of collective outrage ensued.
U.S. Sen. Kristen Gillibrand, a Democrat from New York, tweeted out: “This is outrageous – but it’s not just about the weight room. From their facilities, to their food, to giving them less reliable COVID tests, the women’s NCAA basketball teams are being shortchanged.”
Sabrina Ionescu[7], the star Women’s National Basketball Association player with the New York Liberty, added[8]: “Women’s @NCAA bubble weight room vs Men’s weight room… thought this was a joke. WTF is this?!? To all the women playing in the @marchmadness tournament, keep grinding!”
Natasha Cloud, a WNBA star with the Washington Mystics, was equally outraged[9], having tweeted: “Don’t worry @ncaawbb @marchmadness @NCAA we see what and who yall value. Title 9.”
Dan Gavitt, NCAA vice president for basketball, has apologized[10], but several college women’s basketball coaches say[11] the situation is part of a long-standing pattern of unfair treatment for college women athletes.
As researchers[12] who study inequities in college sports[13] and Title IX[14] – the federal law meant to, among other things, curtail such inequities – we, too, believe that the March Madness debacle is just the latest episode in what at times seems like an entrenched culture of unfair treatment for women athletes[15].
As Muffet McGraw, former University of Notre Dame women’s head basketball coach, tweeted[16], “the fact that there’s a huge disparity between men’s and women’s sports is hardly breaking news. We have been fighting this battle for years.”
Indeed, the fight for equity throughout women’s sport has been a battle for decades[17].
A long-standing problem
Previous research demonstrates how the NCAA leadership routinely provides women with fewer resources. Men’s sports[18], athletes[19], coaches[20] and events[21] have always been the association’s priority[22].
For starters, female athletes were not provided consistent opportunities to participate in sports until the passage of Title IX in 1972[23]. Among other things, the landmark legislation[24] prohibits sex-based discrimination in extracurricular activities within schools that receive federal funding. Once women did receive competitive opportunities, they still faced discrimination[25], sexism[26] and stereotyping[27].
Men outnumber women[28] throughout sport leadership positions[29]. Consequently, the decision-making processes are mostly controlled by men. Walter Beyers[30], the first executive director[31] of the NCAA, fought to get intercollegiate sports exempted[32] from Title IX regulation.
“The NCAA became concerned by what it perceived to be the potential weakening of its position as the dominant and controlling body of intercollegiate athletics,” Richard C. Bell wrote in article about the history of women in college sports[33] before Title IX. “If Title IX was to apply to intercollegiate sports at all levels and women were to be elevated to a status equal to the men, its financial assets and political power were threatened.”
Legal questions
Across social media, some questioned why Title IX does not apply to the NCAA and the March Madness disparities.
However, in 1999, the U.S. Supreme Court held in NCAA v. Smith[34] that the NCAA was not subject to Title IX because it was not a direct recipient of federal financial assistance. Title IX applies only to educational programs that receive federal financial assistance. As the late Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, writing for the unanimous court, stated in the decision: “Dues payments from recipients of federal funds … do not suffice to render the dues recipient subject to Title IX.”
While the NCAA is not subject to Title IX, that does not let schools off the hook[35]. Therefore, once schools were made aware of the disparities between amenities and services provided by the NCAA, they had a legal obligation to determine whether this disparity was justified under Title IX[36].
[You’re smart and curious about the world. So are The Conversation’s authors and editors. You can get our highlights each weekend[37].]
In fact, institutions and teams were made aware of the facility and equipment disparities within the women’s bubble via the NCAA Tournament Manual[38]. The NCAA did not plan to provide the women’s teams with a full weight room until the Sweet Sixteen, which is set to take place on March 27[39].
University of Georgia women’s basketball head coach Joni Taylor confirmed this in her statement to the media[40] revealing that their staff had to make their own arrangements for workouts and meals before arriving at the tournament bubble.
So while the disparities for female athletes are not new or shocking, perhaps, in the words of Dawn Staley, a storied player and the current coach of the 2017 NCAA Women’s Basketball Champions South Carolina, it is time “for the NCAA to reevaluate the value they place on women[41].”
References
- ^ photos (twitter.com)
- ^ videos (twitter.com)
- ^ less food (twitter.com)
- ^ less accurate COVID-19 testing (www.chicagotribune.com)
- ^ exercise equipment (twitter.com)
- ^ NCAA March Madness Tournament bubbles (www.washingtonpost.com)
- ^ Sabrina Ionescu (www.basketball-reference.com)
- ^ added (twitter.com)
- ^ equally outraged (twitter.com)
- ^ apologized (www.espn.com)
- ^ several college women’s basketball coaches say (www.espn.com)
- ^ researchers (scholar.google.com)
- ^ inequities in college sports (scholar.google.com)
- ^ Title IX (louisville.edu)
- ^ unfair treatment for women athletes (doi.org)
- ^ tweeted (twitter.com)
- ^ decades (www.wsj.com)
- ^ Men’s sports (doi.org)
- ^ athletes (doi.org)
- ^ coaches (doi.org)
- ^ events (doi.org)
- ^ always been the association’s priority (doi.org)
- ^ Title IX in 1972 (doi.org)
- ^ landmark legislation (www2.ed.gov)
- ^ discrimination (doi.org)
- ^ sexism (doi.org)
- ^ stereotyping (doi.org)
- ^ Men outnumber women (doi.org)
- ^ throughout sport leadership positions (doi.org)
- ^ Walter Beyers (bleacherreport.com)
- ^ first executive director (www.nytimes.com)
- ^ fought to get intercollegiate sports exempted (www.nationalaffairs.com)
- ^ history of women in college sports (thesportjournal.org)
- ^ NCAA v. Smith (www.law.cornell.edu)
- ^ off the hook (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov)
- ^ Title IX (files.eric.ed.gov)
- ^ You can get our highlights each weekend (theconversation.com)
- ^ via the NCAA Tournament Manual (nypost.com)
- ^ set to take place on March 27 (www.ncaa.com)
- ^ statement to the media (www.redandblack.com)
- ^ for the NCAA to reevaluate the value they place on women (twitter.com)
Authors: Lindsey Darvin, Assistant Professor of Sport Management, State University of New York College at Cortland
