Tobacco killed 500,000 Americans in 2020 – is it time to control cigarette-makers?

Tobacco use killed an estimated 500,000 Americans^[1] in 2020, about the same number the pandemic killed in one year^[2]. Although education efforts by government and nonprofits have helped to curb tobacco use, 14% of American adults still smoke^[3], even with warning labels on the packages^[4]. Tobacco deaths are so high that the World Health Organization^[5] calls smoking an epidemic.

A potential solution to tobacco-related deaths is a corporate “death penalty”^[6] – otherwise known as judicial dissolution – when a judge revokes a corporation’s charter for causing significant harm to society. The legal procedure forces the corporation to dissolve; it ceases to exist. Both management and employees lose their jobs.

Although legal, corporate death penalties in the U.S.^[7] have not been used in years. Yet even the threat of one can be effective. For example^[8], simply announcing the intention to revoke the charters of two tobacco industry misinformation groups (the Council for Tobacco Research and the Tobacco Institute, Inc.) resulted in both quietly closing in 1999.

I became^[9] intrigued with corporate death penalties while researching another topic – alternative energy sources. One statistic stuck with me from my own research: Replacing coal power with solar energy would save an estimated 50,000 American lives per year^[10] because of the air pollution produced by coal-fired power plants. The dead would fill the seats of the Sun Bowl.

With solar already^[11] widely available and less costly than coal, and as coal companies continue to go bankrupt^[12], there seems no reason to drag out the inevitable. I began to wonder: Is there a way to control an industry that causes unnecessary death?

Setting the minimum bar

Building a generalized model for applying a corporate death penalty first requires the comparison of human rights to an industry’s right to existence. My model^[13] relies on three assumptions, based on the U.N.‘s Universal Declaration of Human Rights^[14]:

• Everyone has the right to life.
• Everyone has the right to work.
• Human law should give corporations the right to exist if they benefit humanity.

Put simply, corporations may act as a single legal entity – that is, as a person – to efficiently create jobs and generate profit for the benefit of humans. When corporations create profit and jobs, they can largely be viewed as good, unless they interfere with our right to life.

That last bit is the tricky point. Essentially, it means a company or industry, at the very least, must earn its right to exist by employing more people than it kills each year. Perhaps that sounds a bit arbitrary, but let’s call that the minimum bar for an industry’s existence. (This is the absolute minimum. Most people, including myself, would agree that a single job does not equal the value of one life.)

Industries that would be banned

Imagine the corporate death penalty dealing with a new industry represented by a flagship company: “Lazy Assassins Inc.” Lazy Assassins, under aggressive corporate leadership, estimates it could employ 120,000 professional killers that would eliminate one victim per employee per quarter. That’s 480,000 lives per year.

That’s almost exactly the number of Americans the tobacco industry employs^[15], and almost exactly the number of Americans it kills each year: 124,342 jobs and 480,000 deaths, including 41,000 from secondhand smoke. To put it another way^[16], four Americans die every year for each tobacco industry employee.

Granted, with tobacco companies, this is an all-or-nothing proposition. If only a handful of companies had their corporate charters revoked, other tobacco companies would simply ramp up production to fill the demand.

But if all the charters were revoked, no tobacco company would exist to fund distribution or advertising. There would be only limited access to tobacco products. They could still be produced and used, just not on an industrial scale. That way, we would still maintain the “rights” of smokers to harm themselves.

We have made major changes to our economy to prevent even more COVID-19 deaths^[17]. With that in mind, isn’t it reasonable to help 124,342 people find new jobs in exchange for saving 480,000 American lives every year?

[Get the best of The Conversation, every weekend. Sign up for our weekly newsletter^[18].]

References

1. ^{^} Tobacco use killed an estimated 500,000 Americans (www.cdc.gov)
2. ^{^} the pandemic killed in one year (www.cdc.gov)
3. ^{^} 14% of American adults still smoke (www.cdc.gov)
4. ^{^} warning labels on the packages (www.samwoolfe.com)
5. ^{^} World Health Organization (www.who.int)
6. ^{^} corporate “death penalty” (doi.org)
7. ^{^} corporate death penalties in the U.S. (www.commondreams.org)
8. ^{^} For example (www.tandfonline.com)
9. ^{^} I became (scholar.google.com)
10. ^{^} an estimated 50,000 American lives per year (doi.org)
11. ^{^} With solar already (www.woodmac.com)
12. ^{^} to go bankrupt (www.newsweek.com)
13. ^{^} My model (doi.org)
14. ^{^} Universal Declaration of Human Rights (www.un.org)
15. ^{^} employs (www.ilo.org)
16. ^{^} To put it another way (doi.org)
17. ^{^} changes to our economy to prevent even more COVID-19 deaths (theconversation.com)
18. ^{^} Sign up for our weekly newsletter (theconversation.com)