When religion sided with science: Medieval lessons for surviving COVID-19
- Written by Phillip I. Lieberman, Associate Professor, Vanderbilt University
Faced with a range of serious patient reactions to the COVID-19 disease[1], doctors and nurses have sometimes struggled to find viable treatment options. But when we examine faith-based responses to the virus, spiritual guidance has proved even more elusive.
Guidelines for faith leaders from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention[2] encourage groups to clean surfaces and limit meetings or gatherings. But they do not address the emotional effects that COVID-19 victims, and those of us who live in fear of contracting it[3], might experience.
Religious figures such as Pope Francis have composed prayers for protection from coronavirus[4]. But the idea of prayer as a vital part of any response to COVID-19 might feel inappropriate or even irresponsible to some in a world that often views medicine and religion as polar opposites – one turning to science, the other to God.
As a social historian[5] of the medieval Islamic world, I think and write[6] about the role of religion in daily life. Looking at how people thought about science and religion in the past can inform the contemporary world’s approach to COVID-19.
Plagues – a fact of life
Plagues were a fact of life in ancient and medieval worlds. Personal letters from the Cairo Geniza[7] – a treasure trove of documents from the Jews of medieval Egypt – attest that bouts of widespread disease were so common that writers had different words for them[8]. They varied from a simple outbreak – wabāʾ, or “infectious disease” in Arabic[9] – to an epidemic – dever gadol, Hebrew for “massive pestilence,” which hearkens back to language from the 10 plagues of the Bible[10].
Fragment from Cairo Geniza held at Cambridge shows handwritten letter from Moses Maimonides. It was discovered in late 19th century.
Culture Club/Getty Images[11]
During the time of the jurist and philosopher Moses Maimonides[12] (1138-1204), who led the Jewish community of Egypt, Fusṭāṭ (Old Cairo) faced a plague so daunting[13] in 1201 that the city’s Jewish population never returned to its former glory.
Divine punishment?
Religious people throughout history often saw plagues as the manifestation of divine will[14], as a punishment for sin and a warning against moral laxity. The same chorus is heard by a minority today. As a Jewish person, I am embarrassed to read that a rabbi was recently quoted as saying that COVID-19 was divine punishment for gay pride parades[15].
In “A Mediterranean Society[16],” Geniza researcher S.D. Goitein describes Maimonides’ reaction to the plague: “Whatever the philosophers and theologians of that time might have said about man’s ability to influence God’s decisions by his deeds, the heart believed that they could be efficacious, that intense and sincere prayer, almsgiving, and fasts could keep catastrophe away.”
But the Jewish community also dealt with disease in other ways, and its holistic response to epidemics reveals a partnership – not a conflict – between science and religion.
Science and religion
In the medieval period, thinkers like Maimonides combined the study of science and religion. As Maimonides explains in his philosophical masterwork “The Guide to the Perplexed[17],” he believed that studying physics was a necessary precursor to metaphysics. Rather than seeing religion and science as inimical to one another, he saw them as mutually supportive.
Indeed, scholars of religious texts complemented their studies with science-centered writings. Maimonides’ Islamic contemporary, Ibn Rushd[18] (1126-1198), is a perfect example. Though an important philosopher and religious thinker, Ibn Rushd also made meaningful contributions to medicine, including suggesting the existence of what would later come to be called Parkinson’s disease[19].
But it was not only elite scholars who saw religion and science as complementary. In “A Mediterranean Society,” Goitein says that “even the simplest Geniza person was a member of that hellenized Middle Eastern-Mediterranean society which believed in the power of science.” He adds: “Illness was conceived as a natural phenomenon and, therefore, had to be treated with the means provided by nature.”
Tending to one’s inner life
Science and religion, therefore, were both integral to the soul of the Geniza person. There was no sense that these two pillars of thought challenged one another. By tending to their inner lives through rituals that helped them deal with the sadness and trepidation, and their bodies through the tools of medicine available to them, the Geniza people took a holistic approach to epidemics.
For them, following the medical advice of Maimonides or Ibn Rushd was an essential part of their response to plague. But while hunkered down in their homes, they also looked to the spiritual advice of these thinkers, and others, to care for their souls. Those of us experiencing stress, solitude and uncertainty[20] amid the coronavirus pandemic could learn from the medieval world that our inner lives demand attention too.
[Get facts about coronavirus and the latest research. Sign up for The Conversation’s newsletter.[21]]
References
- ^ COVID-19 disease (www.health.harvard.edu)
- ^ Guidelines for faith leaders from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (www.cdc.gov)
- ^ live in fear of contracting it (www.apa.org)
- ^ prayers for protection from coronavirus (www.vaticannews.va)
- ^ social historian (as.vanderbilt.edu)
- ^ I think and write (journals.openedition.org)
- ^ Cairo Geniza (cudl.lib.cam.ac.uk)
- ^ attest that bouts of widespread disease were so common that writers had different words for them (www.ucpress.edu)
- ^ wabāʾ, or “infectious disease” in Arabic (cudl.lib.cam.ac.uk)
- ^ dever gadol, Hebrew for “massive pestilence,” which hearkens back to language from the 10 plagues of the Bible (cudl.lib.cam.ac.uk)
- ^ Culture Club/Getty Images (www.gettyimages.com)
- ^ Moses Maimonides (plato.stanford.edu)
- ^ a plague so daunting (books.google.com)
- ^ the manifestation of divine will (bostonreview.net)
- ^ rabbi was recently quoted as saying that COVID-19 was divine punishment for gay pride parades (www.timesofisrael.com)
- ^ A Mediterranean Society (www.ucpress.edu)
- ^ “The Guide to the Perplexed (www.sacred-texts.com)
- ^ Ibn Rushd (www.iep.utm.edu)
- ^ suggesting the existence of what would later come to be called Parkinson’s disease (europepmc.org)
- ^ experiencing stress, solitude and uncertainty (www.apa.org)
- ^ Sign up for The Conversation’s newsletter. (theconversation.com)
Authors: Phillip I. Lieberman, Associate Professor, Vanderbilt University
