Immigrants and some people of color are moving to the suburbs – but life there isn't as promising as it once was
- Written by Grigoris Argeros, Associate Professor of Sociology, Eastern Michigan University
In the traditional American image of suburbia[1], the majority of residents are predominately native-born white Americans, living in large single-family houses enclosed by white picket fences.
Americans presume that moving to such suburbs will offer them access to resources and opportunities to improve their quality of life – with, for example, better schools, less crime and lower poverty rates.
But that image represents a bygone era.
I have examined data from the American Community Survey[2]. American suburbs are changing – socioeconomically, demographically and structurally. As more people of color move there, they might not find the full range of opportunities and resources that white European ethnic groups did for most of the previous century.
The American dream
The dream of a good suburban life exists for all racial and ethnic group members, both native and foreign-born.
Traditionally[3], as people earned more money, they eventually move from less desirable central cities to more desirable suburbs[4].
This path worked for the majority of white European ethnic groups. such as Greeks and Italians, through most of the 20th century[5]. As they spent more time in the U.S., improved their English and earned more money – in other words, as they adapted to American culture, they eventually moved out of cities and into higher-income suburbs[6].
There are many different ways to describe the differences between and desirability of suburbs. One focuses on housing construction: mature suburbs, with most of their housing built before 1969, and those that are still developing, with most of their housing built after 1970.
On average, developing suburbs are wealthier, with a larger white population.
Mature suburbs[7], which are often located closer to a central-city core, tend to have higher poverty and crime rates and households that are lower-income and less educated. They also tend to have more families that deviate from the classic suburban family type[8] – such as single parent households or gay families.
Shift in the suburbs
Suburbs are being transformed by a number of different forces.
For example, white Americans are getting older[9] and having fewer children[10] than non-white Americans.
At the same time, more black Americans[11] are moving to the suburbs, thanks to increased income levels and decreasing rates of housing discrimination[12].
These changes mean that both mature and developing suburbs are rapidly becoming less white[13].
Non-Hispanic Asians and Hispanics accounted for the largest percentage increase of residents in both suburban types between 2000 and 2017.
In developing suburbs, the number of non-Hispanic blacks also increased slightly during the same time period.
Between 2000 and 2017, both suburban types also witnessed an increase in non-white immigrants who have been living in the U.S. for less than 10 years.
Stratification by race
My research underscores the idea that[14], rather than being the homogeneous enclaves of American myth, suburbs are stratified by race and ethnicity, native status and socioeconomic status.
Looking at American Community Survey data from the 2012 to 2016 time period, I found that white and Asian families are more likely than black and Hispanic families to live in suburbs with higher levels of household education and homeownership.
That may be due to the fact that white and Asian households tend to be higher-income. However, white and Asian households are more likely than black and Latino households to live in developing suburbs, regardless of differences in socioeconomic status.
So, even when black and Latino families have the means to move into more desirable neighborhoods, they are not as easily moving into such neighborhoods.
Access for immigrants
Rather than starting in cities and then moving out to the suburbs, as immigrants often did in the past, many of today’s immigrants are moving directly into the suburbs.
The evidence[15] also shows that immigrants no longer need to adapt to American culture before they move to the suburbs.
I found[16] that Asian and Hispanic Latino families living in the U.S. less than 10 years are more likely to be found in developing suburbs than their respective native-born members, even when accounting for differences in their educational and income levels.
In another study[17], I found that black ethnic immigrants from the Caribbean and Africa end up in different types of suburbs, depending on their English abilities and how long they had been living in the U.S. Those who had limited English language proficiency and had lived in America for less than five years were more likely to live in developing suburbs.
No guarantee
The research shows that, for non-white Americans and immigrants, there are now fewer barriers to the suburbs.
However, that doesn’t guarantee that the American dream of living in a good suburban neighborhood is equally accessible to all racial and ethnic groups.
Suburbs[18] are not only becoming more diverse in terms of race and ethnicity, but also in terms of income, housing affordability, crime and poverty[19].
In the past two decades, mature suburbs have also started to suffer similar issues as cities. Housing continues to age, wages are stagnated and there are fewer well-paying blue-collar jobs[20] available.
All of these factors are breaking the traditional stereotype of suburbs being the ultimate place to live and grow.
Of course, the racial and ethnic diversification of suburbia is a positive change. But the question remains: Will all groups actually achieve that American dream of life in a good suburban neighborhood?
[ Expertise in your inbox. Sign up for The Conversation’s newsletter and get a digest of academic takes on today’s news, every day.[21] ]
References
- ^ traditional American image of suburbia (global.oup.com)
- ^ American Community Survey (usa.ipums.org)
- ^ Traditionally (doi.org)
- ^ more desirable suburbs (doi.org)
- ^ white European ethnic groups. such as Greeks and Italians, through most of the 20th century (www.hup.harvard.edu)
- ^ into higher-income suburbs (doi.org)
- ^ Mature suburbs (tupress.temple.edu)
- ^ deviate from the classic suburban family type (www.routledge.com)
- ^ white Americans are getting older (www.npr.org)
- ^ fewer children (www.pewsocialtrends.org)
- ^ black Americans (www.brookings.edu)
- ^ housing discrimination (doi.org)
- ^ suburbs are rapidly becoming less white (usa.ipums.org)
- ^ My research underscores the idea that (www.mdpi.com)
- ^ The evidence (www.hup.harvard.edu)
- ^ I found (www.mdpi.com)
- ^ In another study (www.mdpi.com)
- ^ Suburbs (www.routledge.com)
- ^ poverty (www.russellsage.org)
- ^ fewer well-paying blue-collar jobs (tupress.temple.edu)
- ^ Expertise in your inbox. Sign up for The Conversation’s newsletter and get a digest of academic takes on today’s news, every day. (theconversation.com)
Authors: Grigoris Argeros, Associate Professor of Sociology, Eastern Michigan University
