Hope is not the same as optimism, a psychologist explains − just look at MLK’s example
- Written by Kendra Thomas, Associate Professor of Psychology, Hope College
On April 3, 1968, standing before a crowded church, the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr. painted his vision for justice. “I’ve seen the Promised Land[1],” he said. “I may not get there with you. But I want you to know tonight that we, as a people, will get to the Promised Land.”
Twenty-two hours later, he was assassinated.
King’s prophetic words express the virtue of hope amid hardship. He was not optimistic that he would reach the “Promised Land,” yet he was hopeful about the ultimate goal.
In conversation, “hope” and “optimism” can often be used as synonyms. But there’s an important gap between them, as psychology research suggests.
One of the most common tools to measure optimism[2] asks people how much they agree with statements such as, “In uncertain times, I usually expect the best.” Those who strongly agree are regarded as highly optimistic.
But optimism can rely on a sense of luck over action. Self-help books on optimism are lined with hacks – like imagining your greatest possible self or focusing on the best-case scenario.
My psychology research[3] studies how people perceive hope and justice. Long-term hope is not about looking on the bright side. It is a mindset that helps people endure challenges, tackle them head-on and keep their eyes on the goal – a virtue that King and other community leaders exemplify.
We, not me
Hope is often defined in psychological research[5] as having strong will to succeed and plans to reach a goal.
Hope is stronger than optimism at predicting[6] academic success[7] and people’s ability to cope with pain[8]. Plenty of scientific evidence suggests that hope improves individuals’ health[9] and boosts their well-being[10].
But branding hope as a self-improvement tool cheapens this long-established virtue. Hope has benefits beyond the self[11]. Thus, many psychologists are expanding the study of hope[12] beyond personal success. My research team defines this “virtuous hope[13]” as striving toward a purposeful vision of the common good – a hope often shaped by hardship and strengthened through relationships.
Many leaders, including King, have channeled that lesson to inspire change. Centuries of spiritual and philosophical work describe hope as a virtue[14] that, like love, is a decision, not a feeling.
The myth of time
King wasn’t known for looking on the bright side or expecting the best from others. He faced repeated waves of criticism, and, at the time of his death, fewer Americans approved[15] of him than of the Vietnam War[16].
In “Letter from a Birmingham Jail[17],” King lamented the optimism of moderate white Americans who said they supported his goals but took little action. There is a “strangely irrational notion that there is something in the very flow of time that will inevitably cure all ills,” he wrote. “Actually, time itself is neutral; it can be used either destructively or constructively.”
He chastised society for believing that improvement would simply happen on its own. When he said, “The arc of the moral universe is long, but it bends towards justice[18],” he was not describing its natural trajectory, but what people have the power to change. You cannot expect greener pastures if they are not tended today.
The Revs. Ralph Abernathy and Martin Luther King Jr. greet supporters as they are released from jail in Birmingham, Ala., on April 20, 1963.
Chris McNair/Archive Photos via Getty Images[19]
King was not alone in leveraging virtuous hope for justice. Brazilian educator Paulo Freire described hope as an “existential imperative[20]” that promotes action. Nelson Mandela, who spent 27 years in prison, called hope a “powerful weapon[21].”
Forged in adversity
What makes hope a virtue is not its ability to promote happiness and success but its commitment to a greater good beyond the self.
I study virtuous hope in a South African Zulu community, where there are few reasons for optimism. South Africa has the world’s steepest inequality[22]. Unemployment is high[23], and social mobility[24] is low. This is the part of the country where HIV is most widespread[25], with the percentage near 50%[26] in some communities.
We studied several people seen as embodying hope[27], based on their reputation and community suggestions. These individuals demonstrated an unwavering focus on striving for a better future, often unglued from expectations of personal success.
One local farmer nominated by his community struggled to buy seeds for his crops but still helped others apply for grants to buy them. Even when his own future was uncertain, he was not hoarding. He described his hope as a commitment to help others. His hope is not a positive expectation but a moral commitment.
Our interviewees did not describe hardship as a suppressor of hope but as its context to grow.
One unemployed young woman said she had applied for jobs for four years and would continue, though she was not naïve about the tough future. She said applying for jobs and reading to her child were her acts of hope. Her hope didn’t expect a quick improvement, yet it warded off paralysis.
Many of our interviewees anchored their hope in their Christian faith, as did King. King often referenced[28] St. Paul, one of the first Christian writers, who wrote[29], “Suffering produces endurance, endurance produces character, and character produces hope. Now this hope does not disappoint us.”
Hope, in other words, plays the long game: enduring suffering with integrity. Like King’s, it manifests in hardship and is refined in adversity. Hope enables communities to march for justice and democracy[30] even while tasting the danger of dictatorship, apartheid or oligarchy.
Hope knows it may take another generation to reach the Promised Land, but it acts today to bend the moral arc[31] toward justice.
References
- ^ I’ve seen the Promised Land (www.americanrhetoric.com)
- ^ measure optimism (www.hsph.harvard.edu)
- ^ My psychology research (hope.edu)
- ^ Bettmann via Getty Images (www.gettyimages.com)
- ^ defined in psychological research (doi.org)
- ^ at predicting (doi.org)
- ^ academic success (doi.org)
- ^ cope with pain (academic.oup.com)
- ^ improves individuals’ health (doi.org)
- ^ well-being (doi.org)
- ^ beyond the self (doi.org)
- ^ study of hope (doi.org)
- ^ virtuous hope (doi.org)
- ^ as a virtue (plato.stanford.edu)
- ^ fewer Americans approved (www.smithsonianmag.com)
- ^ Vietnam War (www.digitalhistory.uh.edu)
- ^ Letter from a Birmingham Jail (www.africa.upenn.edu)
- ^ but it bends towards justice (www.npr.org)
- ^ Chris McNair/Archive Photos via Getty Images (www.gettyimages.com)
- ^ existential imperative (www.bloomsbury.com)
- ^ powerful weapon (www.nytimes.com)
- ^ the world’s steepest inequality (data.worldbank.org)
- ^ Unemployment is high (data.worldbank.org)
- ^ social mobility (www3.weforum.org)
- ^ HIV is most widespread (hsrc.ac.za)
- ^ near 50% (www.csis.org)
- ^ several people seen as embodying hope (doi.org)
- ^ often referenced (kinginstitute.stanford.edu)
- ^ who wrote (www.bible.com)
- ^ justice and democracy (philpapers.org)
- ^ bend the moral arc (www.si.edu)
Authors: Kendra Thomas, Associate Professor of Psychology, Hope College
