Ice storms, January downpours, heavy snow, no snow: Diagnosing ‘warming winter syndrome’
- Written by Richard B. (Ricky) Rood, Professor of Climate and Space Sciences and Engineering and School of Environment and Sustainability, University of Michigan
One of the most robust measures of Earth’s changing climate is that winter is warming more quickly than other seasons. The cascade of changes it brings, including ice storms and rain in regions that were once reliably below freezing, are symptoms of what I call “warming winter syndrome.”
Wintertime warming represents the global accumulation of heat. During winter, direct heat from the Sun is weak, but storms and shifts in the jet stream bring warm air[1] up from more southern latitudes into the northern U.S. and Canada. As global temperatures[2] and the oceans warm[3], that stored heat has an influence on both temperature and precipitation.
The warming is evident in changes to growing seasons, reflected in recent updates to plant hardiness zones printed on the back of seed packages[4]. These maps show the northward and, sometimes, westward movement of freezing temperatures in eastern North America.
The shift of this freezing line between snow and rain can mean ice storms in places and at times when communities aren’t prepared to handle them, as several parts of the U.S. saw in early 2024[7].
Ice storms and wet snow
I study the impact of global warming[8] and have documented changes to the climate and weather over the decades.
On average, freezing temperatures are moving[9] northward and, along the Atlantic coast, toward the interior of the continent. For individual storms, the transition to freezing temperatures even in the dead of winter can now be as far north as Lake Superior and southern Canada in places where, 50 years ago, it was reliably below freezing from early December through February.
When temperatures are close to the freezing point, water can be rain, snow or ice. Regions on the colder side, which historically would have been below freezing and snowy, are seeing an increase in ice storms[12].
The character of snow also changes near the freezing line. When the temperature is well below freezing, the snow is dry and fluffy. Near freezing, snow has big, wet, heavy flakes that turn roads into slush and stick on tree branches and bring down power lines.
Because the climate in which snowstorms are forming is warmer due to global accumulation of heat, and wetter because of more evaporation and warmer air that can hold more moisture, individual snowstorms can also result in more intense snowfalls[13]. However, as temperatures get warmer in the future, the scales will tilt toward rain, and the total amount of snow[14] will decrease.
Indeed, on the warmer side of the freezing line, winter rain is already becoming the dominate type of precipitation[15], a trend that is expected to continue. With the warmer oceans as a major source of moisture, the already wet Eastern U.S. can expect more winter precipitation over the next 30 years[16]. Looking to the future, soggy wet winters are more likely.
Disaster and water planning gets harder
For communities, planning for water supplies and extreme weather gets more complicated in a rapidly changing climate. Planners can’t count on the weather 30 years in the future being the same as weather today. It’s changing too quickly.
In many places, snow will not persist as late into spring. In regions like California and the Rockies that rely on the snowpack for water through the year, those supplies will become less reliable[17].
Rain falling on snowpack can also speed up melting, trigger flooding and change the flows of creeks and rivers. This shows up in changing runoff patterns in the Great Lakes[18], and it led to flooding on the East Coast[19] in January 2024.
For road planners, the rate of freeze-thaw cycles that can damage roads will increase during winters in many regions unaccustomed to such quick shifts.
An especially interesting effect happens in the Great Lakes. Already, the Great Lakes do not freeze as early[21] or as completely as in the past. This has large effects on the famous lake-effect precipitation zones.
With the lakes not frozen, more water evaporates into the atmosphere. In places where the wintertime air temperature is still below freezing, lake-effect snow is increasing[22]. The Buffalo, New York, region saw 6 feet of snow[23] from one lake-effect storm in 2022. As the air temperature flirts with the freezing line, these events are more likely to be rain and ice than snow.
These changes don’t mean cold is gone for good[24]. There will be occasions when Arctic air dips down into the U.S. This can cause flash freezing[25] and fog when warm wet air surges back over the frozen surface.
Enormous consequences for economies
What we are experiencing in warming winter syndrome is a consistent and robust set of symptoms on a fevered planet.
Novembers and Decembers will be milder; Februarys and Marches will be more like spring. Wintry weather will become more concentrated around January. There will be unfamiliar variability with snow, ice and rain. Some people may say these changes are great; there is less snow to shovel and heating bills are down.
But on the other side, whole economies are set up for wintertime[27], many crops rely on cool winter temperatures[28], and many farmers rely on freezing weather to control pests. Anytime there are changes to temperature and water, the conditions in which plants and animals thrive are altered[29].
These changes, which affect outdoor sports and recreation[30], commercial fisheries[31] and agriculture, have enormous consequences[32] not only to the ecosystems but also to our relationship to them. In some instances, traditions will be lost, such as ice fishing. Overall, people just about everywhere will have to adapt.
References
- ^ shifts in the jet stream bring warm air (theconversation.com)
- ^ global temperatures (climate.copernicus.eu)
- ^ the oceans warm (climatereanalyzer.org)
- ^ back of seed packages (planthardiness.ars.usda.gov)
- ^ Climate Central (www.climatecentral.org)
- ^ CC BY (creativecommons.org)
- ^ saw in early 2024 (www.accuweather.com)
- ^ study the impact of global warming (scholar.google.com)
- ^ freezing temperatures are moving (nca2023.globalchange.gov)
- ^ Omar Gates/GLISA (www.ncei.noaa.gov)
- ^ CC BY-ND (creativecommons.org)
- ^ increase in ice storms (glisa.umich.edu)
- ^ more intense snowfalls (www.washingtonpost.com)
- ^ total amount of snow (glisa.umich.edu)
- ^ becoming the dominate type of precipitation (glisa.umich.edu)
- ^ more winter precipitation over the next 30 years (nca2023.globalchange.gov)
- ^ become less reliable (nca2023.globalchange.gov)
- ^ runoff patterns in the Great Lakes (theconversation.com)
- ^ flooding on the East Coast (weather.com)
- ^ NASA (en.m.wikipedia.org)
- ^ Great Lakes do not freeze as early (research.noaa.gov)
- ^ lake-effect snow is increasing (glisa.umich.edu)
- ^ 6 feet of snow (theconversation.com)
- ^ don’t mean cold is gone for good (theconversation.com)
- ^ can cause flash freezing (www.wilx.com)
- ^ AP Photo/Jenny Kane (newsroom.ap.org)
- ^ whole economies are set up for wintertime (www.freep.com)
- ^ crops rely on cool winter temperatures (www.climatehubs.usda.gov)
- ^ conditions in which plants and animals thrive are altered (www.wbez.org)
- ^ outdoor sports and recreation (theconversation.com)
- ^ commercial fisheries (glisa.umich.edu)
- ^ have enormous consequences (nca2023.globalchange.gov)
Authors: Richard B. (Ricky) Rood, Professor of Climate and Space Sciences and Engineering and School of Environment and Sustainability, University of Michigan
