Back in the USSR: New high school textbooks in Russia whitewash Stalin’s terror as Putin wages war on historical memory
- Written by Anya Free, Faculty Associate in History, Arizona State University
Hey, kids, meet Josef Stalin.
New Russian high school textbooks – introduced in August 2023[1] on the instruction of President Vladimir Putin – attempt to whitewash Stalinist crimes and rehabilitate the Soviet Union’s legacy. While schools and teachers previously could pick educational materials from a variety of choices, these newly created textbooks are mandatory reading for 10th and 11th graders in Russia and occupied territories.
As a scholar of Russian and Soviet history[2], I see the new books as just another example of state-sponsored efforts to use history and scholarship to serve Putin’s agenda and goals.
Other recent attempts along these lines include the establishment in November 2023 of the National Center of Historical Memory[3], tasked with preserving “traditional Russian spiritual and moral values, culture and historical memory”; the creation of a sprawling network of historical parks called “Russia: My History[4],” with new branches in occupied Ukrainian cities Luhansk and Melitopol[5]; and the 2023 publication[6] of a collection of archival documents called “On Historical Unity of Russians and Ukrainians.”
These projects not only demonstrate Putin’s desire to control the historical narrative but to serve the goal of promoting Russian cultural and educational imperialism[7].
Putin’s efforts to redeem the Soviet past may help explain why Stalin is up in the polls, with 63% of Russians asked in June 2023 expressing a positive attitude[8] toward the Soviet dictator behind widespread[9] purges, mass executions, forced labor camps[10] and policies leading to the deaths of millions of his own compatriots.
But Stalin’s place in history remains divisive within the nations he once ruled over, especially where Russia retains significant political and cultural influence.
In January 2024, a newly installed icon honoring Stalin in his homeland of Georgia was defaced – an act exposing deep divisions[12].
The number of privately funded monuments to the dictator is increasing[13], while the memorials to victims of political repression in Russia are disappearing[14]. Yet, activists are still fighting to commemorate[15] those who perished.
Whitewashing history
Putin, famously obsessed with history[16], has been talking about the creation of national history textbooks since 2013. In August 2023, Putin’s wish was finally granted when one of his closest associates, former Minister of Culture Vladimir Medinsky[17], presented new textbooks for 10th and 11th grade students: two in Russian history and two in World history. Medinsky co-authored all four.
The 10th grade textbooks cover the period from 1914 to 1945. The 11th grade textbooks cover history from 1945 to the present day and include sections on the current Russian-Ukrainian war, called in Russia a “Special Military Operation” as an official euphemism.
Warping historical narratives
The new school textbooks maintain some nuance in their coverage of Stalinism, yet that nuance can be described as “yes, but,” which makes it even more effective in warping the historical narrative.
The 10th grade Russian history textbook, for example, briefly mentions the dramatic consequences of collectivization of Soviet agriculture, including the 1932-33 man-made famines in Ukraine[18], Kazakhstan[19], North Caucasus and other regions[20]. Yet it puts the blame exclusively on the poor harvests and mistakes of the local leadership rather than the Stalinist policies that caused and exacerbated the famines. Ukraine’s great famine, or Holodomor, in particular is considered by many historians and international organizations[21] to be a genocide.
Additionally, in the section on World War II, the students learn that the “collective feat of the peasantry” during the war would have been “impossible in the case of the domination of the private landholdings” – in other words, it was only possible under the Soviet system.
The Russian history textbook briefly mentions the “Great Terror” of 1937-38, in which millions were arrested and an estimated 700,000 to 1.2 million[23] were executed. Mention is also made of the personal role of Stalin, while also emphasizing the role of private denunciations and authorities of various Soviet republics and regions. But the creator of the Soviet secret police and an architect of the post-revolutionary “Red Terror,” Felix Dzerzhinsky[24], is praised for his role in “combating counter-revolution,” “creation of the professional educational system” and “restoration of the railroads.”
All national histories are inherently biased, even in democratic societies[25]. Medinsky’s textbooks are, however, a distortion of history. The authors lose any attempt at objectivity while discussing Soviet foreign policy as always defensive and serving to protect everyone whom the USSR occupies and annexes.
The whitewashing of Stalin and his crimes is, I believe, crucial for understanding Putin’s creep toward ever more imperialist ideology and goals. In 2017, Putin participated in the opening ceremony[26] for the memorial to the victims of political repressions in Moscow, during which he acknowledged the violence of Stalin’s terror[27] and argued that it cannot be “justified by anything.” Yet his obsession with World War II led him to just that.
Putin and ideologists in the Russian leader circle have increasingly asserted that Stalin’s foreign policy and his leadership in World War II supersede his crimes against his own people. In his 2020 article in the U.S. journal National Interest[28], Putin praised Stalin for his great “understanding of the nature of external threats” and actions that he undertook to “strengthen the country’s defenses.”
The war on historical memory
The more aggressive Russia’s politics are, the more protective the state is over the Soviet historical legacy. Since 2020, Moscow authorities have not allowed demonstrations[29] traditionally held in Moscow on Oct. 29 to commemorate victims of the Great Terror of the 1930s.
In December 2021, Russian authorities ordered the “liquidation” of the human rights group Memorial [30], fully unleashing the war on historical memory. The organization, which was among the three recipients of the Nobel Peace Prize[31] in 2022, was blamed by the Russian Supreme Court for “distorting memory about the War,” “rehabilitating Nazis” and “creating a false image of the USSR and Russia as terrorist states.” It is not a coincidence that an attack on the organization that for decades documented the Soviet terror came in the midst of the anti-Western and anti-Ukrainian hysteria and right before the full-scale invasion of Ukraine.
Memorial, however, still stands[32], despite immense pressure from the authorities, attesting to the great power of resistance.
In the newly written Putinist narrative of history, the state and its expansion is always at the center, just as it was during Stalinism. The people are treated according to a proverb favored by Stalin, which sums up his attitude toward the ruthless and brutal measures he imposed: “When the wood is cut down, the chips are flying.”
References
- ^ introduced in August 2023 (www.washingtonpost.com)
- ^ scholar of Russian and Soviet history (search.asu.edu)
- ^ National Center of Historical Memory (www.kommersant.ru)
- ^ Russia: My History (jordanrussiacenter.org)
- ^ occupied Ukrainian cities Luhansk and Melitopol (myhistorypark.ru)
- ^ 2023 publication (statearchive.ru)
- ^ Russian cultural and educational imperialism (carnegieendowment.org)
- ^ expressing a positive attitude (www.bbc.com)
- ^ behind widespread (www.loc.gov)
- ^ forced labor camps (gulag.online)
- ^ Sasha Mordovets/Getty Images (www.gettyimages.com)
- ^ exposing deep divisions (www.reuters.com)
- ^ is increasing (www.svoboda.org)
- ^ are disappearing (www.bbc.com)
- ^ commemorate (www.reuters.com)
- ^ famously obsessed with history (www.wilsoncenter.org)
- ^ Vladimir Medinsky (www.nytimes.com)
- ^ Ukraine (www.britannica.com)
- ^ Kazakhstan (www.rferl.org)
- ^ North Caucasus and other regions (www.cambridge.org)
- ^ organizations (www.europarl.europa.eu)
- ^ Dimitar Dilkoff/AFP via Getty Images (www.gettyimages.com)
- ^ an estimated 700,000 to 1.2 million (sovietinfo.tripod.com)
- ^ Felix Dzerzhinsky (www.reuters.com)
- ^ in democratic societies (soeonline.american.edu)
- ^ participated in the opening ceremony (en.kremlin.ru)
- ^ the violence of Stalin’s terror (www.reuters.com)
- ^ article in the U.S. journal National Interest (nationalinterest.org)
- ^ have not allowed demonstrations (apnews.com)
- ^ Russian authorities ordered the “liquidation” of the human rights group Memorial (nsarchive.gwu.edu)
- ^ the Nobel Peace Prize (www.nobelprize.org)
- ^ still stands (www.codastory.com)
Authors: Anya Free, Faculty Associate in History, Arizona State University
