.

  • Written by D. Brian Blank, Associate Professor of Finance, Mississippi State University
Economic lookahead: As we ring in 2024, can the US economy continue to avoid a recession?

With economic forecasters rewriting their 2024 outlooks[1] following recent moves[2] from the Federal Reserve[3], The Conversation turned to two financial economists to share their thoughts on the upcoming year.

D. Brian Blank[4] and Brandy Hadley[5] are professors who study finance, firm financial decisions and the economy[6]. They explain what they’re watching in 2024.

1. At this time last year, many experts saw a downturn on the horizon. Will that long-predicted recession[7] finally come to pass in 2024?

The good news is, probably not.

The U.S. economy is not in a recession[8] and will likely continue growing[9]. Over the past year, gross domestic product has outpaced expectations[10], inflation is trending downward[11] and employment remains robust[12]. Real wages have increased[13], as has consumer spending[14]. Additionally, housing demand is strong[15] and financial markets are at all-time highs[16]. While no one should argue that there will never be another recession, 2024 seems to be an unlikely time for one[17] – unless there’s some unexpected spark like, for example[18], a new global pandemic.

To be fair, optimism leads to risk-taking, which can always contribute to the next downturn[19]. And the U.S. economy faces plenty of challenges, including already elevated debt costs[20], a possible government shutdown[21], rising consumer debt[22] and continued distress in commercial real estate[23], which could result in rolling industry downturns[24]. Other headwinds include the national debt[25], other nations’[26] weaker economies[27] and ongoing global conflict[28] and trade tensions[29].

While 2023 has seemed to many people like a “soft landing[30]” – that elusive achievement in which policymakers reduce inflation without sparking a downturn[31] – prior recessions[32] have followed periods where people thought they had been avoided[33]. That may be why bankers, finance leaders[34] and economists are still noting[35] the risks of interest rates remaining high[36].

Still, the fundamentals[37] are strong[38] and may be on the rise[39], if you believe chief financial officers[40]. Plus, despite dysfunction in Washington, recent laws and policies like the CHIPS and Science Act[41], the bipartisan infrastructure deal[42], the AI Bill of Rights[43] and the Executive Order on Safe, Secure, and Trustworthy Use of Artificial Intelligence[44] could further boost economic growth[45] by stimulating job[46] creation and enhancing competitiveness. Notably, public and private manufacturing and industrial investment are at unprecedented levels[47], and technology is quickly advancing[48], further contributing to the positive economic outlook[49], not to mention strong consumer balance sheets[50].

Jay Powell, wearing a suit, gestures toward an unseen crowd during a press conference. He stands behind a podium and in front of a line of flags.
U.S. Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell speaks to the media on Dec. 13, 2023. The Fed left interest rates unchanged in December as inflation continued to cool, signaling a potentially dovish turn. Photo by Liu Jie/Xinhua via Getty Images[51]

2. Then what about a ‘vibecession[52]’? Are we in one now, and why does it matter for 2024?

When you look at the economic pessimism revealed in polls[53] and on social media[54], a fascinating paradox emerges – despite the collective bad vibes, the majority of Americans say their personal economic situations are basically fine[55].

The writer Kyla Scanlon has called this state of affairs a “vibecession”[56]: While the economy continues to grow, the vibes are just off[57]. The fact that consumer spending continues to see sustained growth[58], despite the gloomy economic outlook[59], underscores a curious split between sentiment and economic activity.

3. What if individual income and spending keep rising? Wouldn’t that be enough to end the vibecession?

In short: Not necessarily.

While inflation has been high over the past couple of years – reaching a peak of 9.1% in June 2022 before falling to 3.1% recently[60] – most Americans have not seen their income rise as fast as inflation since 2021[61]. As a result, many are frustrated[62] that they can’t afford what they could in 2020[63]. Is reminiscing like prior generations about how Coca-Cola used to cost a nickel[64] killing the vibes? If inflation rises faster than wages in 2024, the vibes may suffer.

What’s more, other positive economic developments[65] have seemed to barely affect the vibes. Just about everyone who wants a job has one[66], which is a crucial factor in maintaining consumer confidence and spending habits.

To be sure, gas prices also play an outsized role in shaping sentiment[67], and as they unexpectedly fell in December, sentiment improved[68]. This highlights the impact of energy costs[69] on the public’s mood and suggests that fluctuations in gas prices[70] can quickly influence overall economic sentiment.

However, we suspect that consumers will keep doing what they’re doing[71] – spending money and feeling bad about the economy[72] – until some shock forces them out of it. This weird contradiction[73] between perceived gloom and personal financial well-being highlights the complex interplay of psychological factors[74] and material realities that shapes the overall economic narrative.

4. Could the vibecession become a self-fulfilling prophecy?

Consumers say they feel bad, but they’re continuing to spend more than expected[75], which has been the case[76] for more than[77] a year now[78]. These facts seem at odds with each other, and some experts worry the pessimism itself[79] could hurt the economy[80]. This is because people spend less[81] when they’re concerned about[82] the future.

However, this has been the case for months – so it’s unclear why it should change now.

While understanding[83] that consumer sentiment[84] is complex[85], we think it makes more sense to focus on what people do, not what they say. And people are behaving in a way that’s consistent with a strong economy due to rising real income[86], not to mention a robust labor market[87].

And overall, if you tell people for the better part[88] of two years[89] that a recession[90] is imminent[91], you shouldn’t be shocked that they’re gloomy[92]. If the consensus[93] is wrong[94], it should surprise no one when sentiment diverges[95] from economic data – especially with[96] politicians blaming[97] each other[98] for a weaker economy[99].

5. What else are you watching for in 2024?

Coming off[100] the December Federal Reserve meeting[101], many forecasters[102] have rewritten[103] their 2024[104] outlooks with the[105] expectation that[106] the Fed will[107] lower rates[108] more than they anticipated before Chair Jerome Powell gave an optimistic press conference. Though many expected Powell to minimize discussions about lowering rates[109], meeting responses were strong, deeming inflation defeated and consensus expectations forecasting a benchmark federal funds rate below 4% by year end[110] to relax[111] financial conditions[112].

Federal reserve policymakers see falling rates in the future. An infographic shows the Federal Reserve’s dot plot, which charts policymakers’ forecasts for the federal funds rate. Omar Zaghloul/Anadolu via Getty Images[113]

While investors appear to have overreacted[114] – again – additional slowing in inflation[115] and economic growth is likely as the economy continues to normalize post-pandemic. The most likely outcome for 2024 is that the Federal Open Market Committee lowers rates following more downward revisions to inflation data[116] beginning as early as March[117] until rates end the year just below the Fed’s 4.5% federal funds rate projection[118]. However, the Fed isn’t waiting[119] for inflation to reach its 2% target before lowering rates, which means that rapidly falling inflation could make more rate cuts possible.

Economic growth is likely to remain strong in 2024, and inflation will likely slow[120], albeit at a more muted rate. And with mortgage rates falling below 7% now[121], housing starts and mortgage originations are rising[122]. Now, housing affordability[123] may improve in the coming year[124], albeit from the worst level in decades.

While 2024 is likely[125] to involve debates in other areas[126], hopefully fewer of these[127] economic conversations will happen in 2024 than in 2023[128]. And if we are lucky, markets will rise at least as quickly[129], though we should remember that almost everyone was wrong last year – and if there’s one prediction we can make with confidence, it’s that at least some of[130] today’s forecasts[131] will look pretty silly[132] in retrospect[133].

References

  1. ^ economic forecasters rewriting their 2024 outlooks (www.bloomberg.com)
  2. ^ following recent moves (www.bloomberg.com)
  3. ^ from the Federal Reserve (www.schwab.com)
  4. ^ D. Brian Blank (scholar.google.com)
  5. ^ Brandy Hadley (scholar.google.com)
  6. ^ finance, firm financial decisions and the economy (www.sciencedirect.com)
  7. ^ long-predicted recession (www.forbes.com)
  8. ^ not in a recession (www.c-span.org)
  9. ^ continue growing (www.bloomberg.com)
  10. ^ gross domestic product has outpaced expectations (www.whitehouse.gov)
  11. ^ inflation is trending downward (www.usnews.com)
  12. ^ employment remains robust (www.cbsnews.com)
  13. ^ Real wages have increased (finance.yahoo.com)
  14. ^ consumer spending (www.bbc.com)
  15. ^ housing demand is strong (www.reuters.com)
  16. ^ all-time highs (www.washingtonpost.com)
  17. ^ 2024 seems to be an unlikely time for one (www.wsj.com)
  18. ^ spark like, for example (www.gspublishing.com)
  19. ^ which can always contribute to the next downturn (calvinrosser.com)
  20. ^ already elevated debt costs (www.businessinsider.com)
  21. ^ a possible government shutdown (thehill.com)
  22. ^ consumer debt (fredblog.stlouisfed.org)
  23. ^ continued distress in commercial real estate (www.nber.org)
  24. ^ rolling industry downturns (www.schwab.com)
  25. ^ the national debt (www.forbes.com)
  26. ^ other nations’ (twitter.com)
  27. ^ weaker economies (www.eastasiaforum.org)
  28. ^ ongoing global conflict (www.spglobal.com)
  29. ^ trade tensions (www.economist.com)
  30. ^ soft landing (twitter.com)
  31. ^ without sparking a downturn (www.cnn.com)
  32. ^ prior recessions (www.sciencedirect.com)
  33. ^ where people thought they had been avoided (www.nytimes.com)
  34. ^ finance leaders (www.bloomberg.com)
  35. ^ still noting (x.com)
  36. ^ the risks of interest rates remaining high (twitter.com)
  37. ^ the fundamentals (www.whitehouse.gov)
  38. ^ are strong (www.richmondfed.org)
  39. ^ may be on the rise (www.bloomberg.com)
  40. ^ if you believe chief financial officers (twitter.com)
  41. ^ CHIPS and Science Act (www.congress.gov)
  42. ^ bipartisan infrastructure deal (www.congress.gov)
  43. ^ AI Bill of Rights (www.whitehouse.gov)
  44. ^ Executive Order on Safe, Secure, and Trustworthy Use of Artificial Intelligence (www.whitehouse.gov)
  45. ^ boost economic growth (www.atlantafed.org)
  46. ^ stimulating job (www.mckinsey.com)
  47. ^ unprecedented levels (www.whitehouse.gov)
  48. ^ quickly advancing (www.stateof.ai)
  49. ^ positive economic outlook (www.marketplace.org)
  50. ^ strong consumer balance sheets (fred.stlouisfed.org)
  51. ^ Photo by Liu Jie/Xinhua via Getty Images (www.gettyimages.com)
  52. ^ ‘vibecession (www.nytimes.com)
  53. ^ revealed in polls (www.conference-board.org)
  54. ^ social media (www.nytimes.com)
  55. ^ Americans say their personal economic situations are basically fine (www.nytimes.com)
  56. ^ writer Kyla Scanlon has called this state of affairs a “vibecession” (www.bloomberg.com)
  57. ^ the vibes are just off (kyla.substack.com)
  58. ^ continues to see sustained growth (fred.stlouisfed.org)
  59. ^ gloomy economic outlook (ca.finance.yahoo.com)
  60. ^ inflation has been high over the past couple of years – reaching a peak of 9.1% in June 2022 before falling to 3.1% recently (www.usbank.com)
  61. ^ most Americans have not seen their income rise as fast as inflation since 2021 (twitter.com)
  62. ^ many are frustrated (www.conference-board.org)
  63. ^ they can’t afford what they could in 2020 (www.bloomberg.com)
  64. ^ about how Coca-Cola used to cost a nickel (www.wbur.org)
  65. ^ other positive economic developments (twitter.com)
  66. ^ everyone who wants a job has one (fred.stlouisfed.org)
  67. ^ outsized role in shaping sentiment (www.theatlantic.com)
  68. ^ sentiment improved (www.sca.isr.umich.edu)
  69. ^ energy costs (trends.google.com)
  70. ^ fluctuations in gas prices (www.wsj.com)
  71. ^ consumers will keep doing what they’re doing (kahlerfinancial.com)
  72. ^ and feeling bad about the economy (civiqs.com)
  73. ^ weird contradiction (thehustle.co)
  74. ^ highlights the complex interplay of psychological factors (www.theatlantic.com)
  75. ^ continuing to spend more than expected (fortune.com)
  76. ^ has been the case (www.reuters.com)
  77. ^ for more than (www.cnbc.com)
  78. ^ a year now (www.usnews.com)
  79. ^ worry the pessimism itself (kyla.substack.com)
  80. ^ hurt the economy (www.richmondfed.org)
  81. ^ people spend less (doi.org)
  82. ^ concerned about (www.nytimes.com)
  83. ^ While understanding (www.mercatus.org)
  84. ^ that consumer sentiment (www.convenience.org)
  85. ^ is complex (news.gallup.com)
  86. ^ consistent with a strong economy due to rising real income (twitter.com)
  87. ^ robust labor market (www.bls.gov)
  88. ^ tell people for the better part (www.worldbank.org)
  89. ^ two years (money.usnews.com)
  90. ^ a recession (www.bloomberg.com)
  91. ^ is imminent (time.com)
  92. ^ they’re gloomy (ca.finance.yahoo.com)
  93. ^ the consensus (www.wsj.com)
  94. ^ is wrong (www.forbes.com)
  95. ^ sentiment diverges (podcasts.apple.com)
  96. ^ from economic data – especially with (youtu.be)
  97. ^ politicians blaming (www.cnn.com)
  98. ^ each other (thefulcrum.us)
  99. ^ weaker economy (www.politico.com)
  100. ^ Coming off (www.wsj.com)
  101. ^ the December Federal Reserve meeting (www.bloomberg.com)
  102. ^ many forecasters (t.co)
  103. ^ have rewritten (twitter.com)
  104. ^ their 2024 (twitter.com)
  105. ^ outlooks with the (www.bloomberg.com)
  106. ^ expectation that (twitter.com)
  107. ^ the Fed will (twitter.com)
  108. ^ lower rates (twitter.com)
  109. ^ many expected Powell to minimize discussions about lowering rates (www.regions.com)
  110. ^ expectations forecasting a benchmark federal funds rate below 4% by year end (twitter.com)
  111. ^ to relax (twitter.com)
  112. ^ financial conditions (twitter.com)
  113. ^ Omar Zaghloul/Anadolu via Getty Images (www.gettyimages.com)
  114. ^ appear to have overreacted (twitter.com)
  115. ^ additional slowing in inflation (www.foxbusiness.com)
  116. ^ lowers rates following more downward revisions to inflation data (twitter.com)
  117. ^ beginning as early as March (www.cmegroup.com)
  118. ^ Fed’s 4.5% federal funds rate projection (twitter.com)
  119. ^ the Fed isn’t waiting (www.federalreserve.gov)
  120. ^ Economic growth is likely to remain strong in 2024, and inflation will likely slow (podcasts.apple.com)
  121. ^ mortgage rates falling below 7% now (www.bloomberg.com)
  122. ^ are rising (twitter.com)
  123. ^ housing affordability (www.resiclubanalytics.com)
  124. ^ improve in the coming year (twitter.com)
  125. ^ 2024 is likely (abcnews.go.com)
  126. ^ debates in other areas (theconversation.com)
  127. ^ fewer of these (www.bloomberg.com)
  128. ^ 2024 than in 2023 (twitter.com)
  129. ^ markets will rise at least as quickly (twitter.com)
  130. ^ at least some of (www.ft.com)
  131. ^ today’s forecasts (biancoresearch.com)
  132. ^ look pretty silly (www.cnbc.com)
  133. ^ in retrospect (www.calculatedriskblog.com)

Authors: D. Brian Blank, Associate Professor of Finance, Mississippi State University

Read more https://theconversation.com/economic-lookahead-as-we-ring-in-2024-can-the-us-economy-continue-to-avoid-a-recession-220007

Metropolitan republishes selected articles from The Conversation USA with permission

Visit The Conversation to see more