Ukraine’s Twitter account is a national version of real-time trauma processing
- Written by Jessica Maddox, Assistant Professor and Co-Director, Office of Politics, Communication and Media, University of Alabama
TikToks of cats in cardboard tanks[1]. Flirty comments[2] on Instagram accounts dedicated to Vladmir Putin, begging him to stop Russia’s attacks on Ukraine. Memes bemoaning[3] what it’s like to live during a pandemic and war.
Memes, cats and TikToks are central features[4] of contemporary internet culture. And sometimes, internet culture is all three at the same time, using commonly understood templates in conjunction with cute and silly themes and materials that don’t automatically seem to mesh with the catastrophic consequences of Russia’s attack on Ukraine.
As a scholar of social media platforms and internet popular culture[5], I know that cute animal images, including cat images, are a defining communication practice online. While cats, memes and TikToks – and sometimes cat memes and cat TikToks – are ways to process and respond to current events, they are also emerging, most recently in the Ukraine war, as a way to cope with toxic, harmful and tragic situations.
Much of the public’s way of thinking about the internet has been through dichotomies: There’s online, and then there’s offline. There are cute cat videos, and then there are misinformation and harassment. There’s TikTok, and then there’s world politics.
But if Russia’s attacks on the 2016 United States election[6] taught anything , it’s that internet culture is now world politics, not some separate and distinct realm. There are recent examples of this, such as the TikTok livestreaming[7] of the Taliban’s takeover of Afghanistan, and TikTok users’ organizing to buy tickets for a rally for then-U.S. President Donald Trump, only to not show up[8].
Famed media theorist Marshall McLuhan once said that the medium is the message[9], meaning that the mode of communication carries meaning as well as the communication itself. And if that’s the case, then Russia’s invasion of Ukraine reveals that memes and cute cat content aren’t just for fun and entertainment any longer. Now, the cultural practices underscoring internet culture have become a frame through which to process catastrophe.
The memes of official Ukraine
Russian President Vladimir Putin seems to understand[10] how to manipulate the cultural practices and tactics of the internet.
Putin’s Russia knew how to use[11] memes, Facebook groups and other social media platforms to sow discord in 2016 and beyond. In the lead-up to the 2016 U.S. presidential election, Russia’s Internet Research Agency planted polarizing memes and tweets[12] on police brutality, Black Lives Matter and LGBTQ issues on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram.
But memes, TikToks and tweets aren’t just used for polarizing ends. The official Ukraine Twitter account[13], run by the Ukrainian government, has used internet culture to communicate about Russia’s aggression.
As tensions escalated between Russia and Ukraine in the latter half of 2021, the official Ukraine Twitter account began tweeting about the aggression. This often came through using memes, two of which are good examples:
In one meme, Ukraine communicates the overall message that living next to Russia is a constant source of stress and pain. The meme shows in red the specific location on the head of three types of common headaches: migraines, hypertension and stress. But there’s a fourth headache depicted, called “Living next to Russia.” Its location covers not just one spot on the head, but the entire head and neck.
The second meme has a dog sitting calmly next to a life-size werewolf statue. At the top, the meme says, “Putin’s real fears.” Lower in the picture, the dog has the words “Ukraine in NATO” superimposed on top of it. Next to the dog, the vicious-looking werewolf has text over it saying, “Human rights, free press, fair elections.” The juxtaposition of the harmless-looking dog and threatening werewolf communicates that Putin is actually afraid of freedoms for the Russian people, because such freedoms are a threat to his power - while Ukraine joining NATO is not, the meme suggests.
Large-scale trauma processing
After Russia began its large-scale invasion of Ukraine[14] on Feb. 24, 2022, many on social media noticed Ukraine’s tweets for the first time and seemed baffled[15] by why a nation’s official Twitter account would tweet such things.
But again, if memes, cats and TikToks are ways to process catastrophe in real time, then Ukraine’s Twitter account is a national version of real-time trauma processing, using formats people are familiar with.
The communal nature of memes, cats, TikToks and social media in general cannot be ignored. Memes are digital communication devices that grow and expand the more people share and create them. Cats invite sharing a cute image with another person. TikTok’s mission is to “inspire creativity and bring joy,” and platform features invite interaction with others. And social media are fundamentally social, based almost entirely on communication with others.
With this in mind, Ukraine’s memes and tweets tell something else – that this is their nation’s invitation for more people to enter the conversation. I believe this tells of their need for the rest of the world to stand in communal solidarity with them.
If the medium is the message, then internet cultural practices have become intertwined with geopolitical and military conflicts. Meming war and conflict isn’t always silly – it can be an invitation to communicate, witness, communally process and share.
[The Conversation’s Politics + Society editors pick need-to-know stories. Sign up for Politics Weekly[16].]
References
- ^ cardboard tanks (www.tiktok.com)
- ^ Flirty comments (happymag.tv)
- ^ bemoaning (www.reddit.com)
- ^ Memes, cats and TikToks are central features (inews.co.uk)
- ^ As a scholar of social media platforms and internet popular culture (scholar.google.com)
- ^ Russia’s attacks on the 2016 United States election (www.intelligence.senate.gov)
- ^ livestreaming (www.tiktok.com)
- ^ only to not show up (www.nytimes.com)
- ^ Marshall McLuhan once said that the medium is the message (mitpress.mit.edu)
- ^ Russian President Vladimir Putin seems to understand (www.rand.org)
- ^ Putin’s Russia knew how to use (www.washingtonpost.com)
- ^ polarizing memes and tweets (www.wired.com)
- ^ official Ukraine Twitter account (twitter.com)
- ^ Russia began its large-scale invasion of Ukraine (www.nytimes.com)
- ^ seemed baffled (www.protocol.com)
- ^ Sign up for Politics Weekly (memberservices.theconversation.com)
Authors: Jessica Maddox, Assistant Professor and Co-Director, Office of Politics, Communication and Media, University of Alabama
