• Written by Jeffrey Kucik, Assistant Professor of Political Science, University of Arizona

With the U.S.-China trade war intensifying[1], there is a lot of talk about whether tariffs save American jobs – as President Donald Trump claims[2] – or destroy them[3].

On May 14, for example, Trump said his tariffs helped save[4] the U.S. steel industry. Whether or not that’s true, many economists and industry organizations argue trade protectionism is actually hurting workers in a range of other areas, such as the solar power sector[5], civil aircraft[6] and auto manufacturing[7].

So is the trade war making Americans better off or worse? Political economists like me[8] have been exploring this question since Trump’s trade war began about a year ago. The answer makes a big difference to the economic welfare of American workers. And, with the 2020 elections soon approaching, it may help determine whether Trump is able to remain in the Oval Office.

Is Trump’s trade war saving American jobs – or killing them? Some parts of the manufacturing industry have experienced jobs growth during the trade war. Reuters/Ann Saphir[9]

The winners

At first glance, the jobs data does look good for Trump’s argument.

Since Trump announced tariffs[10] on more than 1,000 Chinese products on April 3, 2018, about 2.6 million new jobs[11] have been added to the U.S. economy.

This includes 204,000 jobs in manufacturing[12], the sector of the economy that hemorrhaged over 5 million positions from 2000 to 2009, a problem blamed on free trade[13] and China[14].

The good news for Trump doesn’t stop there. Some of the biggest gainers over the last year are industries like fabricated metals, machinery and electronic instruments, all of which saw gains of 15,000 to almost 30,000 jobs over the past year. All those industries enjoy at least some protection from Trump’s tariffs.

Those numbers seem to support Trump’s rhetoric that tariffs are providing a vital shot in the arm of America’s ailing manufacturing sector. And they may even show why the U.S. economy continues to hum despite economist fears[15] that a trade war would hurt growth[16].

Is Trump’s trade war saving American jobs – or killing them? The auto industry is among those that have been hurt by tariffs on steel imports. Reuters/William DeShazer[17]

The losers

Unfortunately, not all industries are enjoying the same success.

Of the 20 major manufacturing categories in the latest Bureau of Labor Statistics data[18], only six have grown faster during the trade war – which arguably began with the threat of widespread tariff increases in April of 2018 – than in previous years. The rest, which include chemicals, paper and textiles, either didn’t enjoy a boost or lost ground during the period.

And here is one lesson from the trade war. If Trump and his supporters want to claim that tariffs helped accelerate job creation in machinery and metals, then it follows that his policies should share some of the blame for the less encouraging performance of other sectors hurt by retaliation from other countries[19].

After Trump extended steel tariffs to the European Union, the EU hit America’s textiles industry. Canada[20] targeted some paper products in retaliation for tariffs on steel and softwood lumber[21]. And China, Trump’s primary antagonist, hit chemicals[22] along with a large swath of other industries – with further retaliation[23] on the way.

Is Trump’s trade war saving American jobs – or killing them? The U.S. and China still seem far apart on a trade deal. Reuters/Jonathan Ernst[24]

Beyond jobs

Nonetheless, the simple fact remains: The U.S. economy continues to add more jobs.

But this is only one part of the equation for how tariffs are affecting working Americans and their quality of life. What about wages, which account for 70%[25] of an employee’s average compensation?

There’s less good news for Trump in this data.

The annual growth in seasonally adjusted hourly pay during the trade war averages out to around 3.2%[26] across all private sector U.S. employees.

There are two important things to say about that 3.2%. First, it falls short of pre-Great Recession levels, when wage growth was typically a full point higher[27]. Second, wage growth in manufacturing – the sector Trump has lavished the most attention on – actually lags behind[28] the national average at just 2.3%.

Those wage numbers are good reason to hold our applause for Trump’s tariffs. Protected industries are adding jobs, but wages aren’t living up to expectations.

Looking for good news

The competing job numbers explain why the debate over Trump’s tariffs are full of confusing anecdotes – and why most anyone can find “good news” to support their favorite argument.

Americans have heard United Steel Workers thank Trump[29] for helping bring over 1,000 jobs[30] back to Birmingham, Alabama. They’ve also heard General Motors announce that it lost US$1 billion[31] in 2018, partly because tariffs contributed to rising production costs, and that as many as 14,000 jobs are being cut[32].

A fuller picture of how well workers are doing requires looking beyond the jobs numbers at how much money they’re actually taking home – and how it’s affecting their living standards.

And none of this says anything about another crucial part of the equation: consumer prices. If the latest data from Goldman Sachs is on the money, things are about to get a whole lot worse for working-class Americans as the price tags attached to products affected by the trade war begin to rocket upward[33].

This is hardly good news for the average household.


  1. ^ intensifying (
  2. ^ claims (
  3. ^ destroy them (
  4. ^ helped save (
  5. ^ solar power sector (
  6. ^ civil aircraft (
  7. ^ auto manufacturing (
  8. ^ like me (
  9. ^ Reuters/Ann Saphir (
  10. ^ announced tariffs (
  11. ^ 2.6 million new jobs (
  12. ^ 204,000 jobs in manufacturing (
  13. ^ free trade (
  14. ^ China (
  15. ^ economist fears (
  16. ^ hurt growth (
  17. ^ Reuters/William DeShazer (
  18. ^ latest Bureau of Labor Statistics data (
  19. ^ retaliation from other countries (
  20. ^ Canada (
  21. ^ softwood lumber (
  22. ^ hit chemicals (
  23. ^ further retaliation (
  24. ^ Reuters/Jonathan Ernst (
  25. ^ account for 70% (
  26. ^ around 3.2% (
  27. ^ a full point higher (
  28. ^ lags behind (
  29. ^ thank Trump (
  30. ^ over 1,000 jobs (
  31. ^ lost US$1 billion (
  32. ^ 14,000 jobs are being cut (
  33. ^ begin to rocket upward (

Authors: Jeffrey Kucik, Assistant Professor of Political Science, University of Arizona

Read more

Metropolitan republishes selected articles from The Conversation USA with permission

Visit The Conversation to see more

Entertainment News

Gonna Tell You A Bit About Me & My Journey

There was a time that I didn’t like seeing myself in a mirror. I lacked confidence. I was shy. Then, I found modeling. When I first started modeling, being in front of the camera didn’t feel natural and I was nervous. Like most things – practice ...

Thorn Castillo - avatar Thorn Castillo

#1 Chart-Topping Band GREYE Comes Full Circle With “I Don’t Mind”

Six years after releasing their debut album Providence, Greye’s evolution from progressive Americana upstart to trailblazing indie rock powerhouse is complete. Pandemic and lockdown be damned, the well-traveled multi-generational Daytona Beach, F...

News Co - avatar News Co


From COVID-19 To the Shocking Events of January 6, This Is Michael Mesey’s Song of Hope to A Weary Nation and World This Inauguration Day is a chance to turn the page from a difficult, divisive era and embrace a more hopeful spirit of unity m...

Michael Mesey - avatar Michael Mesey

EMODULARI Releases The Hard-Driving, Intensely Visceral “Craniotomy”

Caught up in the maelstrom of bad to worse news in the New York Times one morning, Eli Soiefer spotted an uplifting article offering respite from the crazy. It was a piece about an open-brain surgical procedure where they keep the patient awake t...

News Co - avatar News Co


“Super Cool” is more than the name of rising international hitmaker AV Super Sunshine’s latest infectious 80’s techno inflected single. It’s the dizzying, freewheeling world he’s been living in these past months since the release of his previous ...

News Co - avatar News Co

Angela Predhomme - “Warmest Wish for You”

What could possibly help us heal from the exceptionally trying year of 2020? Singer-songwriter Angela Predhomme hopes that an inspiring new holiday song might give us a little solace. “Warmest Wish for You” is soul-tinged, feel-good song with a ...

News Co - avatar News Co

Metropolitan Business News

Do Directories Still Help SEO?

Directories were once one of the main staples of SEO and they were definitely in existence before search engines took over. Directories were once the main way that people navigated the world wide we...

News Co - avatar News Co

Shipping Container FAQs

If you are looking to rent or purchase a shipping container, you probably have a few questions. We have selected some of the most common questions and answered them here. We hope that you find this ...

News Co - avatar News Co

Is Duplicate Content an SEO Myth?

Any marketer you speak to about duplicate content is concerned about a “duplicate content penalty” but they are probably not very experienced with SEO. Google has specific guidelines on duplicate co...

News Co - avatar News Co

5 Key Factors To Starting A Website

Every business needs a website to be successful. However, this is a challenge for many due to the lack of coding and designing skills. The good news is, you do have a way around this—hire a deve...

News Co - avatar News Co

So You Want To Be A Project Manager? Here's What You Must Do

Project management is often a popular choice for people looking to make a mark in the organizations they work for. It's a great choice as well. If you hate monotony, love getting people and res...

News Co - avatar News Co

How to Deliver the Perfect Elevator Pitch

Do you struggle with explaining your career with professional or personal contacts, and you want to make a lasting impression? Whether you're looking for a job or building up your network, a wel...

Adam Jacobs - avatar Adam Jacobs

Writers Wanted

News Co Media Group

Content & Technology Connecting Global Audiences

More Information - Less Opinion