Food has a climate problem: Nitrous oxide emissions are accelerating with growing demand for fertilizer and meat – but there are solutions
- Written by Hanqin Tian, Director and Institute Professor, Center for Earth System Science and Global Sustainability, Schiller Institute for Integrated Science and Society, Boston College
Food’s role in climate change has emerged as one of the defining challenges of our time. The journey of a steak, fruit or salad from the vast expanses of agricultural lands to the plates on our tables leaves a significant footprint on the environment.
At the heart of this challenge is the prodigious use of fertilizers and a growing global population’s increasing demand for meat.
As earth[1], climate[2] and atmospheric[3] scientists[4], we track global greenhouse gas emissions and just published the most comprehensive assessment yet[5] of a powerful greenhouse gas from food production: nitrous oxide, or N₂O.
After carbon dioxide and methane, N₂O is the most consequential greenhouse gas humans are releasing into the atmosphere. While there is less N₂O than carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, it is 300 times more powerful[6] at warming the planet, and it remains in the atmosphere, holding in heat, for over a century. Today, atmospheric N₂O levels are about 25% higher[7] than before the Industrial Revolution, and they’re still rising at an accelerating rate.
We found that, globally, fertilizers and the management of livestock manure are leading the increase in N₂O emissions and its rapid accumulation in the atmosphere. This is more than a climate problem. N₂O also depletes the ozone layer[8], which protects humans from harmful solar radiation. And nitrogen runoff from fields pollutes waterways[9], increasing harmful algal blooms and creating oxygen-depleted dead zones.
The growth of N₂O emissions is alarming, but people today have the knowledge and many of the technologies needed to reverse the trend.
Where do N₂O emissions come from?
Prior to the Industrial Revolution, natural sources of N₂O from microbes living in forest soils[10] and in the oceans were roughly equal to natural sinks that consumed N₂O in the air, so N₂O atmospheric concentrations were relatively constant.
However, the human population and its demand for food have grown rapidly, throwing that natural equilibrium out of whack.
We found that human activities alone have increased N₂O emissions by 40% over the past four decades, with agriculture contributing approximately 74% to the total anthropogenic N₂O emissions.
The biggest human sources of N₂O are agriculture, industry and the burning of forests or agriculture waste.
Annual N₂O emissions sources and change over the decade of 2010-2019. Measured in millions of metric tons.
Global Carbon Project, CC BY[11]
Nitrogen fertilizers, widely used in agriculture, are one of the biggest contributors. Fertilizers are responsible for 70% of total agricultural N₂O emissions globally. Animal manure[12] from intensive animal farming contributes around 30%. A smaller source but one that is rapidly growing is aquaculture, such as fish farming[13], particularly in China where it has increased twenty-fivefold in the past 40 years.
In addition to farming, industrial processes such as production of nylon[14], explosives and fertilizers, and the combustion of fossil fuels also contribute to N₂O emissions, but to a lesser extent than agriculture.
N₂O emissions by country
Emissions vary greatly country to country for a number of social, economic, agricultural and political reasons.
Emerging economies, such as China and India, have had strong increasing N₂O trends over the past four decades as they boosted agricultural productivity to meet their growing populations’ food demand[15].
China is the largest producer[16] and user of chemical fertilizers. Its Action Plan for Zero Growth in Fertilizer Use by 2020, issued in 2015, has helped cut those N₂O emissions[17]. However, its industrial N₂O emissions have continued to rise[18].
In Brazil and Indonesia, cutting down and burning forests to make room for crops and livestock, coupled with increasingly intensive farming practices, has exacerbated nitrogen losses[19] from natural sources and amplified greenhouse gas emissions.
Africa has opportunities to increase food production without increasing nitrogen fertilization. However, Northern African countries more than tripled their emissions growth[20] in the past two decades, primarily due to a substantial growth in the livestock population in Africa.
A few regions, however, have been able to curtail some of their N₂O emissions with more sustainable practices.
The European Union, Japan and South Korea have all successfully reduced anthropogenic N₂O emissions[21] over the past 40 years, although they remain major emitters on a global scale; reductions have largely come from the chemical industry in the 1990s. Their nitrogen use in agriculture has also become more efficient; however, they still have work to do. Their emissions from direct fertilizer and manure application have declined only slightly and have recently leveled out.
In the U.S., agricultural emissions continue to creep up, while industrial emissions have declined slightly, leaving overall emissions rather flat[22].
How to reduce N₂O emissions
Addressing the challenge of reducing N₂O emissions requires a combination of policy interventions, technological innovation and individual actions. For example:
Similarly, innovations in livestock management[24], such as dietary supplements and improved waste management practices, can reduce the amount of N₂O from cattle.
Industries, particularly production of nylon and fertilizers, can install existing, affordable technologies to abate nearly all of their N₂O emissions. That’s an easy win for implementation and the climate. Most of the world has already done so, leaving China and the U.S. responsible[25] for most of the remaining industrial emissions of N₂O.
Consumers can also make plant-based foods a larger fraction[26] of their diets. You don’t need to become vegan unless you want to, but reducing the frequency and portion sizes of meat and dairy consumption can be healthy for both you and the environment. Eco-friendly practices like composting food wastes and reducing fertilizer use on lawns also help.
Overall, a holistic approach combining policy, technology and individual actions is needed to address N₂O emissions and combat climate change. With governments, industries and citizens all working toward a sustainable future, these strategies can help ensure food security and environmental sustainability for future generations.
References
- ^ earth (scholar.google.com)
- ^ climate (scholar.google.com)
- ^ atmospheric (scholar.google.com)
- ^ scientists (scholar.google.com)
- ^ most comprehensive assessment yet (doi.org)
- ^ 300 times more powerful (theconversation.com)
- ^ about 25% higher (research.noaa.gov)
- ^ depletes the ozone layer (doi.org)
- ^ pollutes waterways (theconversation.com)
- ^ microbes living in forest soils (doi.org)
- ^ CC BY (creativecommons.org)
- ^ Animal manure (www.agric.wa.gov.au)
- ^ aquaculture, such as fish farming (doi.org)
- ^ production of nylon (www.climateactionreserve.org)
- ^ growing populations’ food demand (www.mckinsey.com)
- ^ the largest producer (agra.org)
- ^ helped cut those N₂O emissions (www.gpca.org.ae)
- ^ continued to rise (pubs.acs.org)
- ^ exacerbated nitrogen losses (doi.org)
- ^ tripled their emissions growth (doi.org)
- ^ successfully reduced anthropogenic N₂O emissions (doi.org)
- ^ leaving overall emissions rather flat (doi.org)
- ^ fotokostic/iStock/Getty Images Plus (www.gettyimages.com)
- ^ livestock management (clear.ucdavis.edu)
- ^ China and the U.S. responsible (doi.org)
- ^ plant-based foods a larger fraction (doi.org)
Authors: Hanqin Tian, Director and Institute Professor, Center for Earth System Science and Global Sustainability, Schiller Institute for Integrated Science and Society, Boston College
