Metropolitan Digital

  • Written by Marybeth Shinn, Cornelius Vanderbilt Professor of Human and Organizational Development, Vanderbilt University
Jeff and MacKenzie Bezos' billions for the homeless will relieve suffering but won't defeat homelessness

Amazon founder Jeff Bezos and MacKenzie Bezos[1], his ex-wife, are giving away US$2 billion. The money will fund existing nonprofits to support homeless families and establish a new network of free preschools[2] for low-income children[3].

I’ve researched the best ways to end homelessness[4] for three decades and I was initially thrilled by both parts of their plan when they announced it in 2018 because the two issues aren’t as different as they may seem. Half of the children in families that become homeless are 5 or younger[5]. In fact, the age at which a person is most likely to stay in a homeless shelter in the United States is infancy.

I believe offering families who face economic hardship high-quality child care at no cost could both prevent some family homelessness and benefit children in families who do lose their homes. But I am troubled by the homeless side of these philanthropic efforts because they appear less strategic.

Homeless infants and children

Why are so many very young children in homeless shelters?

Babies may be a blessing, but they require care that is typically costly[6] or that takes a parent out of the labor force[7]. Since either choice makes it hard for young families to afford housing, too often they fall into homelessness. Likewise, rates of homelessness drop when children enter elementary school[8].

The Bezoses haven’t yet offered details about the preschool programs they are planning to support. But they did release a list of 24 nonprofits[9] they gave either $2.5 million or $5 million to help homeless families.

Addressing root causes

Most of these programs appear likely to use this money[10] to expand their shelters and services, and perhaps offer their clients short-term rental subsidies or a combination of affordable housing with services[11] designed for people struggling with mental illnesses or other disabilities that most families experiencing homelessness don’t have. These are the same services that have been available for years – while progress in ending homelessness has stalled.

Nearly half a million people in families[12] used homeless shelters in 2017 – about the same number as in 2013 and 2007. About a third of all people who use shelters belong to families with children under 17.

Family Options Study

Most of the programs will surely make a spell of homelessness a little less miserable, but it appears that few of these organizations will offer the long-term rental subsidies my colleagues and I found to be the most effective way to end family homelessness when we conducted the Family Options Study[13].

I co-led a team that brought together experts from the Abt Associates consulting firm and scholars like me at Vanderbilt University[14] to evaluate different ways to help homeless families. Our study, funded by the Department of Housing and Urban Development, enrolled nearly 2,300 families we found in homeless shelters in 12 sites throughout the United States.

We randomly assigned the families to four options, provided by 148 different programs. Some groups the Bezoses are funding were among them.

Some of the families in this study got simply the sorts of care these programs usually provide. But three years after enrolling, many of those families were not faring well[15].

For example, two-fifths of them had used homeless shelters recently or reported being homeless or living doubled-up in a home with another family because they could not find or afford a place of their own.

One in 6 families had been separated from a child[16] who had entered a shelter with them.

One in 10 adults reported recent intimate partner violence and one in 10 indicated that they were coping with alcohol dependence or drug abuse. Almost half of families were food-insecure[17], meaning that they had inadequate or inconsistent access to food.

The people reporting these troubling outcomes found their way into a variety of housing and service programs that cost about $41,000 per family over a 37-month period.

Others were randomly assigned to get short-term rental subsidies lasting an average of six to eight months, or to longer-term transitional housing programs that offered extensive social services. We determined that they fared little better than the first group.

A better way

One program worked much better[18] than the rest: a long-term rental subsidy that held families’ housing costs to 30% of their income.

Even though the families that got these subsidies did not get special services beyond housing, they were less likely to experience homelessness again or have to double up. They were also less likely to face food insecurity.

Children in families randomly assigned to get the subsidies were more likely to remain with their parents and less likely to switch schools, to miss school or to have behavior problems. Their parents reported less domestic violence, psychological distress and alcohol or drug abuse.

That is, housing subsidies reduced problems that can sometimes cause family homelessness – even without special services like case management or counseling. The one downside we detected was that the adults, mostly parents with young children, were a little less likely to be employed.

The housing and service programs the four groups used cost similar amounts. The group that got long-term subsidies cost about 9% more than the group that got services as usual. Transitional housing also cost slightly more. The short-term subsidies cost about 9% less.

Moving the needle

In an unusual move[19], nonprofits getting the Bezos grants aren’t being asked to do or prove anything specific. Groups receiving support from nonprofits typically must formally apply – even for much-smaller sums of money – and later submit reports to show they did the work.

No-strings-attached philanthropy spares those groups lots of time they might otherwise have spent writing detailed grant proposals and reports on their work once the money is spent. But it’s a lost opportunity.

Because the homelessness program, technically called the Bezos Day 1 Families Fund, doesn’t require evaluations, I doubt that there will be a way to discover if this money could have been put to better use.

Jeff Bezos has said he’s trying to make “compassionate, needle-moving work[20]” happen. If he really does want to move the needle, I can make several recommendations.

For starters, he could invest in more of the long-term rental subsidies our study found effective for ending family homelessness.

The need for affordable housing[21] is vast. Providing enough long-term subsidies would cost $31 billion more than current levels[22] per year – less than 1% of U.S. federal government expenditures[23], but surely more than even Jeff and MacKenzie Bezos can afford.

Therefore, I think that they should consider creating a social welfare organization[24] to promote public education and spending on housing subsidies and other policies that would make housing more affordable across the nation. Jill Khadduri[25], a housing expert at the Abt consulting and research firm, and I evaluate dozens of these ideas – like zoning reform and improvements to the safety net – in our forthcoming book “In the Midst of Plenty: How to Prevent and End Homelessness[26].”

Especially since Jeff Bezos lobbied against a Seattle tax[27] that would have raised money for the government to spend on affordable housing, he should back strategies to prevent and end homelessness, not just make it easier to bear.

[ Deep knowledge, daily. Sign up for The Conversation’s newsletter[28]. ]


  1. ^ MacKenzie Bezos (
  2. ^ new network of free preschools (
  3. ^ low-income children (
  4. ^ researched the best ways to end homelessness (
  5. ^ 5 or younger (
  6. ^ care that is typically costly (
  7. ^ parent out of the labor force (
  8. ^ children enter elementary school (
  9. ^ 24 nonprofits (
  10. ^ to use this money (
  11. ^ affordable housing with services (
  12. ^ Nearly half a million people in families (
  13. ^ Family Options Study (
  14. ^ scholars like me at Vanderbilt University (
  15. ^ not faring well (
  16. ^ separated from a child (
  17. ^ food-insecure (
  18. ^ One program worked much better (
  19. ^ unusual move (
  20. ^ compassionate, needle-moving work (
  21. ^ need for affordable housing (
  22. ^ $31 billion more than current levels (
  23. ^ U.S. federal government expenditures (
  24. ^ social welfare organization (
  25. ^ Jill Khadduri (
  26. ^ In the Midst of Plenty: How to Prevent and End Homelessness (
  27. ^ against a Seattle tax (
  28. ^ Sign up for The Conversation’s newsletter (

Authors: Marybeth Shinn, Cornelius Vanderbilt Professor of Human and Organizational Development, Vanderbilt University

Read more

Metropolitan republishes selected articles from The Conversation USA with permission

Visit The Conversation to see more

Entertainment News

WENDY MOTEN I’ve Got You Covered

WENDY MOTEN may have launched her career as a pop/R&B artist and taken cool detours into jazz along the way, but her heart clearly belongs to NashvilleWendy Moten may have launched her career ...

News Company - avatar News Company

Smooth Jazz Music Legend “Dr. Dave” Releases An Homage To The Tonight Show

Writing and recording smooth jazz albums and performing live over the past 25 years, I’ve learned that people react most powerfully to a song’s rhythms. If you’ve got a great beat that they can mo...

Dr. Dave - avatar Dr. Dave

Singer/Songwriter Darrell Kelley Talks Music and Social Relevance

I feel very blessed that two of my songs, “The Coronavirus” and “Because of You,” are currently in the Top Five on the World Indie Music charts and continue to grow in influence, with over 100,0...

Darrell Kelley - avatar Darrell Kelley

How to Create a Melody on the Piano

Have you ever wondered what it would be like to be able to write a song? Maybe you’ve wondered how anybody goes about writing a song? Once you understand how music works, you can use building b...

News Company - avatar News Company


In the midst of the devastating COVID-19 pandemic, the release of “In the Morning” on Pure Mission Entertainment – the label he partners on with Aaron Emig - follows on the heels of the global s...

Tom Estey - avatar Tom Estey

Expert Advice: Indie Record Producing and Engineering

My career as an independent artist evolved out of my career as an entrepreneur and restaurant owner. I moved to from my hometown of Boston Atlanta in 2013 and opened my soul food restaurant Soul D...

Darrell Kelley - avatar Darrell Kelley

Weight of The World

When the calm of the world is at stake, and every message of hope is crucial to our collective peace of mind and the endurance of the human spirit, it’s not only possible, but essential to present any...

Tom Estey - avatar Tom Estey

DARRELL KELLEY “The Coronavirus”

Even though I have been releasing tracks and albums since 2018, I never considered myself an artist until I started getting responses from people telling me that my songs were resonating with them. ...



During these tumultuous times, people are feeling a loss that is akin to grieving.  Grieving for their former lives and ways and it is unclear when things will return to “normal.”  Grieving for th...

Stephanie Hochman of My Luv Notes - avatar Stephanie Hochman of My Luv Notes

Metropolitan Business News

How to make overseas transfers easier?

Mainstream banks can charge as much as $20 just to process a basic international money transfer. Fortunately, today people are not doomed to handling personal finances only through mainstream gl...

News Company - avatar News Company

The flourishing international market of fragrance and perfume

There is something special and unique about the art of fragrance. This is a big world and there are quite literally a lot of smells around at any given time. In fact, as one of the five human senses i...

News Company - avatar News Company

Impact of good marketing on sales

Sales and marketing are brothers as they go hand and in hand. The job of both of these departments is to generate revenue so that an organization can make money. A company that does not generate rev...

News Company - avatar News Company

7 effective tips for increasing sales in retail

It seems that retailers have drawn a difficult lot in the 21st century: competition from online retail is growing steadily. After all, Internet retailers can sell your products at significantly lowe...

News Company - avatar News Company

10 Reasons to Use Labels

People cannot stop biting their nails, considering the messy condition of their homes. You open your kitchen drawer to grab some utensils, but instead, you take a glance at toys lying inside that dr...

News Company - avatar News Company

15 ways to encourage your office employees

We often get so busy managing our companies and business that we forget about the most important resource that is making our business reach new height every day, our employees. Support of the manage...

News Company - avatar News Company



Are you planning to go on a trip? Possibly, you do not know what things are most necessary on a trip. In this article, we will guide you through some important tips. These tips help you to...

News Company - avatar News Company

New Baggage Regulations to Help Aussie Parents Travel with Infants

Travelling around the globe has never been easy, especially when infants tag along for the trip. One of the main issues that parents often have to deal with is the need to bring extra item...

News Company - avatar News Company

Maya Beach Opens to Tourists

Despite recent reports that Southern Thailand's famous Maya Beach will close for three months this year, in fact no decision to this effect has been made by Thai authorities. Phi Phi Nati...

Maevadi Rosenfeldt - avatar Maevadi Rosenfeldt


Breaking News & Opinion