Metropolitan Digital

The Conversation

  • Written by Dana Zartner, Associate Professor, International Studies Department; Adjunct Professor, School of Law, University of San Francisco

August and September are peak months[1] for harmful blooms of algae in western Lake Erie. This year’s outbreak covered more than 620 square miles[2] by mid-August. These blooms, which can kill fish[3] and pets[4] and threaten public health[5], are driven mainly by agricultural pollution[6] and increasingly warm waters due to climate change.

Advocates are looking for new ways to combat this problem. On February 26, 2019, Toledo citizens passed the Lake Erie Bill of Rights[7], which gives the lake the right to “exist, flourish, and naturally evolve[8]” and awards citizens the right to a “clean and healthy environment.” They join a growing movement[9] – referred to as “Rights of Nature” – providing legal personhood to natural entities.

How giving legal rights to nature could help reduce toxic algae blooms in Lake Erie Lake Erie harmful algal bloom forecasts since 2002. NOAA[10]

In theory, this action could make it possible to hold corporations and governments liable for polluting the lake. But while the concept is finding support abroad, it faces hurdles in the U.S. The Lake Erie law was immediately challenged in court[11] by an Ohio farm and has yet to take effect[12].

My work focuses on international and comparative law related to environmental justice and human rights[13]. I recently spent time[14] in New Zealand researching the impacts of a 2017 law giving the Whanganui River its own legal identity[15]. What I saw there convinced me that providing legal standing to a natural entity is a viable method of environmental protection. In my view, however, the processes that advocates use to enact Rights of Nature law critically influence whether these efforts will succeed.

A new conservation strategy

Rights of Nature laws generally are designed to improve environmental protection and encourage people to rethink their relationship to the environment. Instead of viewing nature as a commodity that exists for humans to use, and abuse, these statutes consider nature as important for its own sake.

Measures awarding legal status to nature have been adopted in Ecuador, Bolivia, Colombia, New Zealand and Bangladesh, and by several Native American nations, including the Ho Chunk and White Earth. Other efforts[16] are underway across the country, including in Oklahoma[17] and Oregon[18].

How giving legal rights to nature could help reduce toxic algae blooms in Lake Erie Maumee Bay Brewing Co. in Toledo, Ohio is making green, murky beer to draw attention to Lake Erie’s algae problems. AP Photo/John Seewer[19]

The Lake Erie Bill of Rights is the latest phase of citizen-led efforts to address chronic nutrient pollution[20] and the resulting dangerous algae blooms. In 2018 Toledoans for Safe Water[21] collected enough signatures for the Lake Erie Bill of Rights to appear on the ballot.

Local politicians[22] and farmers opposed the measure, but it passed with 61% of the vote, although only 8.9% of eligible voters participated[23]. A day later, Drewes Farm Partnership of Ohio filed a lawsuit[24] arguing that it was unconstitutional. While the city of Toledo has taken up defense of the Lake Erie Bill of Rights, the state of Ohio is siding with Drewes Farm[25].

Learning from Te Awa Tupua

How effective are Rights of Nature laws elsewhere? One of the most detailed examples is the 2017 Whanganui River Settlement Agreement[26], which resulted from years of negotiations between the Maori and New Zealand’s government. Known by its Maori name, Te Awa Tupua, it recognizes legal personhood for the Whanganui, the country’s third-longest river.

How giving legal rights to nature could help reduce toxic algae blooms in Lake Erie The Whanganui is a major river on the North Island of New Zealand. Dana Zartner, CC BY-ND[27]

The Whanganui has been an important source of food and transportation for centuries, and has great spiritual importance for the Maori, who view it as a living being[28]. Te Awa Tupua recognizes that the river possesses all the “rights, powers, duties, and liabilities of a legal person.” The Whanganui is represented by two Guardians, known as Te Pou Tupua, who are jointly appointed by the national government and local Maori.

Under the law, any activity that might affect the river must go through a consultation process and receive approval from Te Pou Tupua. One early test occurred in March 2019, when construction of a new bike bridge over the river was halted so that the required consultations could take place[29]. Bigger issues will arise in the future, particularly in regards to renewal of concessions for energy companies diverting portions of the river for power generation.

The local Maori tribe of Whanganui fought for recognition of their river as an ancestor for 140 years.

Lake Erie and the law

Unlike Te Awa Tupua, the Lake Erie law does not include much detail regarding its requirements or specific mechanisms to guide implementation. Ultimately courts may strike the measure down based on these omissions and potential conflicts with state and federal regulations.

Lake Erie is governed by treaty law[30] between the U.S. and Canada, so the Drewes Farm lawsuit asserts that the Bill of Rights infringes upon U.S. government authority. Similarly, because the lake touches four U.S. states, the lawsuit argues that any new law related to Lake Erie should be adopted by states, not individual cities.

Drewes Farm also claims that the Bill of Rights violates its 14th Amendment rights to equal protection[31], since the law mentions only corporations and governments, and conflicts with Fifth Amendment prohibitions on law that is too vague[32].

On July 22, 2019, Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine signed a budget bill which includes a provision stating that “Nature or any ecosystem does not have standing[33] to participate in or bring an action in any court.” The bill creates a new fund called H2Ohio[34], purportedly to provide US$172 million to address pollution in Lake Erie, but critics want more proactive measures[35].

Making Rights of Nature work

In my view, challenges to the Lake Erie Bill of Rights are not surprising. Within the U.S. environmental regulatory framework, which vests authority mainly with federal and state agencies and is affected by the influence that corporate interests assert in the American political system, protecting the environment by awarding legal personhood to nature will be an uphill battle.

But I believe that it is still worth trying, and that passage of the Lake Erie Bill of Rights is significant, even if it is ultimately struck down. Widespread coverage of the issue[36] has already increased awareness of the idea of legal personhood for nature in the U.S.

I see learning from the negotiation and implementation of more developed Rights of Nature laws like Te Awa Tupua as the next step. As measures like this become more common, a new view of our relationship to nature may develop. I expect that recognizing the legal standing of natural entities will become a significant legal tool in the fight for better environmental protections, including addressing toxic algae blooms in Lake Erie.

[ You’re smart and curious about the world. So are The Conversation’s authors and editors. You can read us daily by subscribing to our newsletter[37]. ]

References

  1. ^ peak months (www.wemu.org)
  2. ^ more than 620 square miles (weather.com)
  3. ^ kill fish (www.epa.gov)
  4. ^ pets (www.toledoblade.com)
  5. ^ threaten public health (www.michiganradio.org)
  6. ^ mainly by agricultural pollution (theconversation.com)
  7. ^ Lake Erie Bill of Rights (www.courtlistener.com)
  8. ^ exist, flourish, and naturally evolve (www.courtlistener.com)
  9. ^ growing movement (celdf.org)
  10. ^ NOAA (www.noaa.gov)
  11. ^ challenged in court (nbc24.com)
  12. ^ has yet to take effect (www.farmanddairy.com)
  13. ^ environmental justice and human rights (scholar.google.com)
  14. ^ spent time (www.nzherald.co.nz)
  15. ^ its own legal identity (www.legislation.govt.nz)
  16. ^ Other efforts (celdf.org)
  17. ^ Oklahoma (indigenousagain.com)
  18. ^ Oregon (www.culturalsurvival.org)
  19. ^ AP Photo/John Seewer (www.apimages.com)
  20. ^ chronic nutrient pollution (www.nytimes.com)
  21. ^ Toledoans for Safe Water (www.facebook.com)
  22. ^ Local politicians (www.toledoblade.com)
  23. ^ only 8.9% of eligible voters participated (radio.wosu.org)
  24. ^ filed a lawsuit (www.courtlistener.com)
  25. ^ siding with Drewes Farm (www.agri-pulse.com)
  26. ^ Whanganui River Settlement Agreement (www.nzherald.co.nz)
  27. ^ CC BY-ND (creativecommons.org)
  28. ^ living being (www.ngatangatatiaki.co.nz)
  29. ^ required consultations could take place (www.nzherald.co.nz)
  30. ^ treaty law (www.ijc.org)
  31. ^ rights to equal protection (www.courthousenews.com)
  32. ^ law that is too vague (www.law.cornell.edu)
  33. ^ Nature or any ecosystem does not have standing (celdf.org)
  34. ^ H2Ohio (h2.ohio.gov)
  35. ^ want more proactive measures (nbc24.com)
  36. ^ Widespread coverage of the issue (www.cc.com)
  37. ^ You can read us daily by subscribing to our newsletter (theconversation.com)

Authors: Dana Zartner, Associate Professor, International Studies Department; Adjunct Professor, School of Law, University of San Francisco

Read more http://theconversation.com/how-giving-legal-rights-to-nature-could-help-reduce-toxic-algae-blooms-in-lake-erie-115351

Metropolitan republishes selected articles from The Conversation USA with permission

Visit The Conversation to see more

Entertainment News

Phish’s 2018 Fall Tour to Conclude with Four Performances at MGM Grand Garden Arena

LAS VEGAS (May 15, 2018) – Phish, the American rock band known worldwide for its dedicated fan base, recently announced a 14-date Fall tour which will conclude in Las Vegas with four performances at...

Blane Ferguson - avatar Blane Ferguson

Dave Damiani and The No Vacancy Orchestra are “Bending The Standard”

Tina Sinatra, Dave Damiani & Landau Murphy Jr. celebrate 100 years of Frank Sinatra in Los Angeles There have been stories about independent filmmakers, but how about the independent big band...

Tom Estey - avatar Tom Estey

Billboard Chart-Topping Saxophonist VANDELL ANDREW Returns With New Single

From the vantage point of 30, his age and the name of his infectious, sensually grooving new full length album, Vandell continues to be fueled by the impressive roar of accolades and achievements th...

Metropolitan Digital - avatar Metropolitan Digital

Metropolitan Business News

Office Cleaner Takes Ownership of the Neglected Dishwasher

In an office that a dishwasher is being used communally, it is pretty difficult to set rules on how a certain appliance needs to be taken cared of. A dishwasher is a responsibility of no one until you...

News Company - avatar News Company

Amazing tips to become a successful trader

Everyone is working very hard to secure their financial freedom. Most of the people find it hard to support their family even after having a 9-5 day job. For this very reason, people often look for ...

News Company - avatar News Company

Best Practice For Young Professionals Working Through HR Internships

The industry of human relations is vitally important to the health and prosperity of a business.   Whether they are operating in textile manufacturing, accounting, sports, IT development or hospit...

News Company - avatar News Company

4 Easy Steps To Gaining SEO Momentum For Your Business

SEO (search engine optimisation) does not have to be a tiresome and overbearing exercise that diverts attention away from the core functions of a business.   SEO Shark affirms this as a smart and ...

News Company - avatar News Company

How to Manage An SEO Project On Limited Funds

SEO operators don’t need thousands upon thousands of dollars to become successful.   What SEO practitioners needs more than ever is the skills and diligence to identify problems that are acting a...

News Company - avatar News Company

An Introduction To Coworking For Australian Business Owners

Advancing technology is bringing with it great advantages in communications and networking, and to survive in business you need to keep up. With the rate at which everything changes these days, that...

News Company - avatar News Company

Holidays

New Baggage Regulations to Help Aussie Parents Travel with Infants

Travelling around the globe has never been easy, especially when infants tag along for the trip. One of the main issues that parents often have to deal with is the need to bring extra item...

News Company - avatar News Company

Maya Beach Opens to Tourists

Despite recent reports that Southern Thailand's famous Maya Beach will close for three months this year, in fact no decision to this effect has been made by Thai authorities. Phi Phi Nati...

Maevadi Rosenfeldt - avatar Maevadi Rosenfeldt

SKYN LAUNCHES GUIDE TO THE BEST PLACES TO GET INTIMATE

SKYN®, Australia’s best-selling condom*, today launches its very first SKYN® Places of Intimacy Guide.   Curated in partnership with GQ Magazine and Conde Nast, the Guide features 30 lux...

SKYN - avatar SKYN